Sherlock had studied many solved and unsolved cases over the years. He also remembered most of them, so he could easily connect a specific set of evidence to the crime scene it came from. However, this was the first time he managed to link a person’s face to an unsolved case, specifically, the disappearance of a young woman from the pub she was working in. The police had had very little to go on, and he recalled reading about the woman’s mother and mother-in-law asking for Scotland Yard’s help in finding her.
However, no matter how hard the detectives worked, they found no trace of her. The woman’s mother faded into obscurity, but the image of the missing woman now swam to the front of his mind, and she was a carbon copy of the one sitting in front of him. As absurd as his deductions were becoming, he trusted them. Inspector Lestrade might refuse to believe in the notion that the missing Irene Barnes was the same woman who was asking him for help. That was the DI’s flaw: to refuse the seemingly impossible.
After he’d examined all of the available evidence, including the information that came from her, Sherlock was more convinced that the missing Irene and the Irene in front of him were one and the same. That only meant that ‘Bucky’ was also James Buchanan Barnes, her husband. A married couple disappeared and were placed in some kind of program that turned them into killers. A far-fetched idea, but he’d heard that there were a few experiments in Russia that were focused on creating the perfect soldier.
A few moments of silence passed among all four before he continued. He was quick to point out a few of the key observations he’d made. Different accents. The heavier step that Bucky had on one side of his body, indicating a metal prosthetic. Given the almost religious way he was hiding his left arm, he’d have to deduce it was that particular limb. Then, of course, there was the fact that she had her face plastered on a specific newspaper article, which he pulled up on his phone and showed it to her.
“I remember your disappearance clearly. It was widely reported but never
solved. It also nearly coincided with the report of Sergeant Barnes’ status
as killed in action; however, I refuse to believe in coincidence. You didn’t
disappear. You were taken. A more important question is by whom. Tell
me that, Mrs. Barnes, and I may be able to help. If you’re worried about
having complete secrecy, then let me tell you that it’s not necessary. She
is a doctor and I…I simply have no time for idle gossip.”
He leaned back in the chair, still studying their facial expressions. The first reaction of a person was always the truth, and he wondered if they would attempt to continue with their farce or come clean. he was curious about the events that caused them to remain youthful, but that information was paling in comparison to the prospect of finally solving a case that had stumped Scotland Yard for DECADES.
She had been right. Irene hid her breath of relief as Sherlock began to point out all the things about them that had given them away, besides the fact that apparently her photo was attached to a missing person’s case. The picture was a close up from the photo taken at her and Bucky’s wedding, the same that was at the museum. It was still shocking to see herself from that time, her hair wavy and just brushing her shoulders, a smile easy on her face, eyes bright and looking at the man next to her like he was her whole world.
Will I ever look at him like that again...? Will he...?
These questions were shoved away. That wasn’t an issue at the moment. Finding out her past was. However, Sherlock’s query about who took them was a loaded one, and she looked between him and Bucky, unsure about how much would be safe to say. Neither of them wanted anyone else put on HYDRA’s radar because of them, it had been the number one worry about consulting Holmes and Watson. She just hadn’t anticipated exactly how fast Sherlock would put it together.
Johanna flipped to a new page in her notebook. Given that she wasn’t in the presence of a couple siblings looking for an ancestor anymore, rather the ancestors themselves, she thought it best to start over. As crazy as it seemed, it was easier to believe now that Captain Rogers himself had been found alive after being frozen. It was possible the same thing, or something similar, could have happened to them. Quickly she jotted down everything that Sherlock noted.
Bucky lost arm, possibly from his fall?
Irene kidnapped, Bucky was as well, by the same people
At that revelation, she remembered back to her classes on WWII history. The Howling Commandos, while taking part in many of the major battles, mostly worked on taking down one particular branch of the Nazis. A rogue division that the developer of Rogers’ serum had escaped from.
The way the younger (if she could be called that) woman’s eyes snapped to hers, Johanna had to assume she was right. Somehow they’d managed to survive past the destruction of the Valkyrie and the death of their leader. What was the saying that was always attributed to them...?
Cut off one head, and two more shall take its place.