Blurring the Lines - Kuzu no Honkai/Scum’s Wish
Kuzu no Honkai, or Scum’s Wish centers around two high school students Hanabi Yasuraoka, and Mugi Awaya. Hanabi Yasuraoka has been in love with Narumi Kanai, her older childhood friend who is now her homeroom teacher, for a long time. Mugi Awaya is in love with Akane Minagawa, the new music teacher who was his tutor when he was in middle school. Soon after becoming Hanabi’s homeroom teacher, Hanabi notices that Narumi is in love with the new music teacher, Akane, and not her. Soon after, Hanabi meets Mugi and the two decide to make a pact and begin a fake relationship to satisfy each other's loneliness from their respective unrequited loves, both sexually and emotionally, by becoming replacements of their crushes. Their pact ends either if one of them falls in love with the other, or if their unrequited love is returned from the people they are in love with.
Characters: Hanabi Yasuraoka
Hanabi Yasuraoka is a high school student who has a crush on her homeroom teacher, neighbor, and childhood friend Narumi Kanai. She begins an unhealthy relationship with another high school student, Mugi Awaya, where both parties play the role of replacement for the other’s object of affection. Throughout the series, we see Hanabi use other people’s affection as a coping mechanism to fill the loneliness she has inside from being unable to confess and have her feelings reciprocated by Narumi. For example, outside of her relationship with Mugi, in several moments of weakness, she crosses the line of friendship with her friend Ecchan despite not having feelings for her in order to cope with heartbreak.
Sanae Ebato, also referred to as “Ecchan” by Hanabi, is a fellow high school student, classmate, and friend to Hanabi. Sanae Ebato also has feelings for her friend Hanabi, even after having formed a relationship with Mugi Awaya.
In episode three, entitled “Show Me Love (Not A Dream),” we learn the backstory of how the two met and started their friendship. While on the same train heading to their entrance exams, Sanae was being harassed by a man. Noticing Sanae’s discomfort, Hanabi took a photo of the man harassing Sanae, successfully saving Sanae from the man who was trying to sexually assault her. After the incident and off the train. Hanabi refused to let go of Sanae’s hand. Hanabi comforted Sanae, telling her she didn’t have to be strong when she said, “Don’t hold back. It was scary, wasn’t it?” Soon after, the two realized they attended the same school and became close friends ever since. Their meeting was also the same moment in which Sanae developed a crush for Hanabi. Sanae previously believed that she hated men, as she never had a crush before, but after meeting Hanabi, she developed a crush for the first time and stated that Hanabi gave her world color.
In the same episode, after Hanabi tells Sanae that she is dating Mugi, Sanae becomes suspicious of the two’s relationship. She overhears on campus in a conversation with Hanabi, Mugi, and another female character named Moca, Moca claiming that Hanabi is using Mugi. This makes Sanae question the authenticity of Hanabi and Mugi’s relationship, and also makes Sanae wonder if Hanabi is actually the one who is being used. One day after school, Hanabi asks if Sanae has a crush on anyone. Sanae doesn’t share who, but Hanabi deduces that Sanae does in fact have a crush on someone. Hanabi then suddenly invites Sanae over for a sleepover, partially to spite an earlier conversation with Mugi who claimed Hanabi didn’t have many friends who were girls. While at the sleepover, Hanabi and Sanae share a bed for the night and Hanabi asks Sanae again about who she has a crush on. Sanae, unable to hide her feelings any longer, responds by kissing Hanabi, nonverbally confessing her feelings for Hanabi. Sanae then proceeds to brings up her suspicions of Hanabi and Mugi’s relationship, having a hunch that the two’s relationships isn’t authentic, and also hoping it gives Sanae an opportunity with Hanabi romantically. Hanabi affirms Sanae’s suspicions were correct by sharing the truth of her and Mugi’s relationship, that she is only with Mugi because the person she likes doesn’t like her back. Sanae presses forward, asking Hanabi why she can’t be her replacement instead of Mugi, and asking if it is because Sanae is a girl. Hanabi almost gives in to Sanae, before denying Sanae’s earlier claim and further stating she can’t allow Sanae to be her replacement because she can’t use her friend. Now grounded back into reality, Hanabi decides to end their sleepover early.
As the series progresses, their relationship only continues to blur more and more. For example, in episode four, “Bad Apple,” after witnessing her crush Narumi confess to Akane, Hanabi is distraught and heartbroken. Unable to break the news to Mugi, and seeking a distraction from her pain, Hanabi runs into Sanae and the two end up back at Sanae’s house, paralleling their earlier sleepover, but this time following through. On her way home, Hanabi envisions her younger self scolding her for having manipulated and used Sanae’s love for comfort.
The two’s relationship eventually ends on a shared vacation. Sanae invites Hanabi on a solo vacation to a villa. However, upon arriving to the villa, Sanae’s cousin Atsuya is already there. He confronts Sanae one-on-one about her relationship with Hanabi, stating that Sanae knows Hanabi doesn’t have feelings for her aside from as a friend, and continuing things as they are is just preventing the inevitable deterioration of their relationship, as Atsuya points out, he knows Sanae is trying to just preserve their last moments as being more than friends. Atsuya also has a one-on-one conversation with Hanabi, asking her who she really likes, and elaborating that Hanabi needs to decide on her feelings for Sanae before the end of the trip.
Eventually the two have a conversation in the rain at the villa. Sanae confesses that she already made up her mind before the vacation occurred, that if Hanabi didn’t look at her in a romantic way by the end of the trip, Sanae would decide to end their friendship. Hanabi refuses, claiming to still want to be friends, and that she doesn’t want Sanae to end up alone. Sanae initially snaps at Hanabi, claiming that it’s impossible to continue on as friends after what they’ve done. However, Sanae eventually compromises, stating that it will take time for her to go back to being just friends again with Hanabi. The two seal their conversation with one final kiss, both not wanting the moment to end, however both knowing it’s best to end their relationship as being more than friends here.
At the end of the series, after some time has passed, Sanae and Hanabi meet again. This time, Sanae has cut her hair to a short length, signifying the passing of time, end to their past non-platonic relationship, and the start of something new for the two. It is implied at the end of the series, that the two do in fact become friends again and remain as so.
Scum’s Wish explores new paradigms of desire through the character Hanabi Yasuraoka. Through Hanabi, we see how a character’s own loneliness, emptiness, and heartbreak due to unrequited feelings can drive a person to desire physical connection from others as a coping mechanism, despite not loving the other person involved in return. Scum’s Wish showcases consumption practices of queer texts, by depicting straight-baiting, and the blurred lines of sexuality and desire an individual can experience. Scum’s Wish depicts the validation of queer lifestyles via media portrayal through the character development of Sanae Ebato. We see Sanae realize her sexuality through meeting Hanabi, but we also see her able to let go of potentially having a relationship with Hanabi, who doesn’t appear to be queer by the end of the show, which shows Sanae’s personal growth, as she is no longer allowing herself to be a replacement or queer experiment for Hanabi. The concepts of both realizing one’s sexuality through a first crush, and acting as an experiment for a ‘straight’ individual parallels the real experiences queer individuals face. Scum’s Wish showcases the construction of sexual identities via pop culture inclusion through the relationship of Sanae and Hanabi, as both individuals experiment and discover their feelings, or lack of feelings, for one another.