Trey was starting his freshman year of college, when he got there, he discovered that there was a recreational wrestling team. When he heard that he got excited, he had always wanted to try wrestling but his highschool didn’t offer it. Trey went to the open tryout for the team, which he made, if only barely.
Now because he was both the new guy and the worst guy on the team Trey became the new team cum dump, a role he was more than happy to fulfill because unlike in his close minded high school in Mississippi, there was no stigma here, he was free to be himself and go crazy. Trey slept with more than half the team in his first 2 weeks, he loved how they were all so fit and physical, he loved the roughness they had when they were doing. In fact there wasn’t an aspect of this that he didn’t love. That was until a few weeks later when Trey’s physique started to change. He pecs were hurting and his nipples were sore, he had a fatigue that just wouldn’t go away, and then there was the sickness, there were times where he couldn’t keep anything down at all.
As time drug on, he also noticed his belly which was usually flat and toned, nothing crazy or anything had started to push outward. Eventually his belly became distended enough to where his teammates took notice, until one of them Etienne asked him if he was okay. Trey told Etienne all that had been happening and all Etienne could do was laugh as the nursing major quickly put 2 and 2 together. Etienne had heard the rumors of how Trey was the new team cum dump and how he had slept with half the team, and now it was all coming together for him.
Etienne: “You know you’re pregnant, right?”
Trey: “Be serious, there’s no way I’m pregnant, I’m on the pill.”
Etienne: “You should really stop taking that until you know for sure but bro, all the symptoms fit. Let’s finish up practice and I’ll take you to the clinic, one of my good friends who graduated last year is a nurse there, we can settle the debate once and for all.”
Trey: “Whatever man, I’m not pregnant.”
After practice they made their way to the clinic where Etienne’s suspicions were confirmed, Trey was indeed pregnant.
Trey: “Holy fuck, what am I gonna do?”
Etienne: “I don’t know bro, but you better figure something out, oh and you can’t wrestle anymore, you can come support the team, I mean you can come support your baby daddy but you can’t wrestle anymore, it’s not safe for you or the baby!”
Trey: “What the hell, oh god I’ve got to tell the team.”
Etienne: “Yeah you do cause I’m not explaining this one, do you even know which teammate is the father, if the rumors were true you slept with at least 5 of them.”
Trey: “Fuck bro, you’re right, think they will go for a DNA test?”
Etienne: “I don’t know man, you’ll have to ask them. Anyway I’m late for class hate to leave you on your own but I have to go. You should go back to your dorm and think about all this!”
Trey following eN’s advice returns to his dorm and begins to weep. With all the usual questions filling his head everything was all too overwhelming for him. Finally, after a few hours of hyperventilating, he managed to fall asleep. When he woke, he decided to send a text to the five possible baby daddies. “Hey guys, y’all want to meet up and hang out tonight?” he sent try not to ring any alarm bells just yet. in response, he got a cacophony of “Yes” and “Hell yeahs”. He and the team met up in one of the student rec rooms, where he nervously told them that one of them was the father to his baby.
Lance (22, Senior, History Major): “What the fuck man, not cool, I thought you were on the pill?!”
Colton (22, Senior, Psychology Major): “Oh god, no this isn’t happening!”
Theo (21, Junior, Computer Science Major): “You’re sure it’s one of us?”
Calvin (20, Sophomore, Education Major): “Shit bro are you for real right now?!”
Silas (19, Freshmen, Undeclared): *To stunned to speak*
Trey proceeded to answer each of their questions and tried his best to keep his composure, but halfway through the noise of all of the guys got to him and he broke. When he started crying the other guys all stopped their bickering and asked if he was okay, all remembering that as bad as it is for them, they aren’t the pregnant one. They tried to console him and calm him down, eventually Trey did come back around and they had a discussion.
The guys all decided that they didn’t want to do a DNA test when Trey explained that there is some risk to the baby at this stage. They all agreed to help Trey out, and would submit a DNA sample now and that when the baby was born, Trey could have it compared to the samples to see who’s baby it actually is. Trey while hesitant did eventually agree to the plan.
As Trey’s pregnancy progressed the guys, true to their word did all that they could to help him and potentially their baby. Trey’s belly really started growing around week 20, though he had been showing for many weeks by now as he was extremely lean and fit to begin with. Trey was finally able to book an appointment for an ultrasound, where he found out he was gonna give the world another great wrestler, at least that’s what all the guys said. It’s about that time that the team as a whole but especially the baby daddy brigade started to rub Trey’s belly for good luck before their matches, even go as far as to make Trey wear his singlet to the matches to support the team.
As weeks turned to months there was still the massive question about what to do with the baby. Trey wants to keep it while all of the baby daddies think it would be better to adopt the baby out to someone who can really afford to take care of it and who is ready for that level of responsibility. To that end, Lance had reached out to his brother and sister-in-law who he knew had been trying unsuccessfully to have a child of their own for years and were considering adoption. When he told them about the situation, his brother initially scolded him for his recklessness and his brother Kurt and wife Maria did agree to adopt the child when he is born.
The season was nearing its end and there was no denying it to anyone anymore, Trey was definitely pregnant. His baby bump, now 31 weeks along was getting big. At this point the guys were squabbling over who did this to Trey, each one jokingly claiming that only they could make him swell this big with their baby. Trey found the guys jokes endearing and far better than the actual bickering and shouting they did in the beginning.
Finally with the wrestling season over, Trey had more free time which is good because he was so pregnant at this point that all he wanted to do was lounge around as finals season approached. Trey hoped he could make it through finals before having the baby though given his tentative conception date, it was gonna be close. But Treys fears seemed to be just that fears, as he made his was to his last final of the school year, helped by 2 of the baby daddy brigade, he felt what could only be a contraction. Alarmed, the boys told him that he should just ask the professor for an extension and go to the hospital, but Trey was insistent.
Trey: “It takes hours for a baby to arrive, I’ll be okay, I can finish this last final and then go.”
Colton: “Are you sure, what if something happens?”
Trey: “You’ll be there won’t you?”
Theo: “Yeah we’ll be right by your side the whole time”
As Trey enters the auditorium style classroom, and finds his seat, he is hit with another wave of pain. As the professor slowly goes over the rules of the exam and finally begins to pass out the tests Trey feels a wetness in his pants. He instantly knows what’s happening, but he does his best to hide it from Colton and Theo. Another few minutes go by and is trying to focus on the exam when he’s hit by the hardest contraction he’s had yet, he does his best to breathe through it and not let anyone know what’s going on.
This pattern continues throughout the rest of the exam over the course of the next 35-ish minutes other students begin to turn in their exams and finally he manages to finish his against all odds, having Theo turn in the exam for him. Trey not wanting to move and fearing the worst of the situation waits another almost minutes for everyone to clear out including the professor whom he tells he just needs a few minutes to catch his breath.
When everyone is finally out of the auditorium, he turns to Colten and says “ the baby’s coming” with all the urgency he could muster.
Colton: “I told you this was a bad idea!”
Theo: “We need to get you to the hospital ASAP!”
Trey: “There’s no time, my water broke at the beginning of the exam, and my contractions are only a few minu…. Ughhhhh oh god… they are only a few minutes apart, the baby is coming now!!”
Theo: “Oh my god, what do we do?”
Colton: “Theo call the rest of the guys, now, tell them to meet us at the clinic!
Trey: “I can’t make it to the clinic, I can’t walk, the baby is so low, he feels like he is going to bust out of me at any momen…. Aghhhh oh god, he’s coming like he’s coming coming!”
Colton: “You don’t have to walk, I will carry you!”
And just like that Colton scoops up the pants soaked Trey and begins to carry him to the clinic. As they rush in the door, they are met by Lance and Silas who look terrified.
Colton: “Hey can we get some help over here?! Anyone?!”
Nurse: “Oh my goodness is he in labor?”
Colton: “Yeah, his water broke about 45 minutes ago and his contractions are only about 3 minutes apart.”
Nurse: “We aren’t equipped to deliver babies here we are a basic clinic.”
Colton: “Well he is having this baby here whether you like it or not, can you get him a gurney or a bed or something?”
Nurse: “Uh yeah, I’m on it” As she runs over opens an exam room door which has a bed inside. “Put him here, we need to get his clothes off!”
As the nurse reaches for some scissors Colton steps up and rips Trey’s pants off showing his soaked underwear which he gently removes. The nurse closes the exam room door just as she is about to latch it a very sweaty and out of breath Calvin comes running in.
Lance: “It’s about time, you almost missed it!”
Colton: “It looks like he is probably about ready to push, the baby’s head is pushing down the birth canal and against his cervix! I need some gloves!”
Trey: “God you’re so… ughh oh god ohhhhhh god he’s ripping me apart… you’re so fukcing hot right now Colton.”
Colton: “Save it tough guy you are the reason we are doing this here.” He says as he puts the gloves on, he says “This may not be so gentle and probably won’t feel very good.” as he pushes two fingers up into Trey’s rectum. “That feels right, seems like you are good and dilated, you should be okay to start pushing any time now Trey, you don’t have to try and hold him in any more.”
Trey: “How do you know so…. Ughhh” as he bears down and tries to push.
Colton: “Don’t worry about that right now, you just focus on bringing that baby safely into the world.” he says in a calming serene voice.
On the next contraction Trey grits his teeth and pushes as hard as he can at which point the rectum begins to bulge outward and a tiny bit of the babies head can be seen on the other side.
Lance: “You’re doing so good Trey, keep pushing, I think I can see the head!”
Silas upon seeing the head begin to emerge from Trey passes out, Calvin and the nurse begin to check on him.
Another minute passes, and once again Trey tries his hardest to push the baby’s head free. This time his hole begins to open and the baby begins to fully crown.
Colton: “That’s it, you’re doing it, the head is almost out Trey, you can do this.”
Theo: “Come on Trey give it everything you’ve got!”
As another contraction comes Trey’s face turn red with effort as the blood vessels in his head all begin to bulge, he pushes harder than he thought possible and with the force of that push the head, shoulders and the rest of the baby all shoot free in the awaiting arms of Colton. Trey let’s put a wail of pain followed by a sigh of relief and some deep labored breathing.
Colton: “You did it Trey, you did it, he’s here and he’s perfect!” He says in a quivering voice, as he wipes the baby off a bit before placing him on Trey’s chest.
Theo and Lance also begin to tear up at the sight of it all.
A week later, Trey gets the results of the DNA test and though it doesn’t really matter to him who’s baby it was, since he gave him up to Lance’s brother and sister-in-law. Trey knows that there would be no better father than Colton, who proved that he was the superior man when the time came and someone needed to step up. The guys however were partially curious and partially competitive, after all they needed to settle their bet. To the guys surprise but not Colton or Trey, the baby’s father turned out to be none other than Colton himself.