I watched Children Who Chase Lost Voices
I agree with other people who say that it is visually stunning and has a fantastic music score. I don’t think the creators could have done better. The film was done in a similar style to a Miyazaki film.
Because those two aspects are really good, I am disappointed that the story has so many plot holes. I am not a fan of the director who created 5 centimeters per second or the film. I had to watch it sped up just to get through the film. I don’t think I finished watching it the first time because it was so boring. As someone who looks forward to well written universes, someone with poor vision, and someone with slow and expensive American internet service, attention to details in a movie is not what I look for. While it is important, I would much rather have a plot that makes sense.
Plot hole 1: Shun’s death and song
It is revealed later that quetzalcoatl sing their song when they die. They did not mention humans. Shun’s song is the one that Asuna could not forget and wanted to hear again, but Shun was never describe as someone with musical talents. Where is the character development? Shun seems to have psychic powers because he apparently wanted to meet the person who heard his last song before he died and he has always wanted Asuna to live. If this was a translation error during the english dubbing, I would be very angry.
Plot hole 2: Tainted blood
The izoku monsters come at night to take and eat those with tainted blood. The movie shows only two people with tainted blood, Asuna and Manna. Manna is mute which is supposedly the reason for being tainted. The izoku are constantly chasing Asuna at night, but the writers did not give her any strength to combat them. Her companions needed to fight for her.
Plot hole 3: Equivalent exchange
The myth that the teacher, Ryujii, speaks of in the beginning is not similar to the ending of his own quest. That is failed foreshadowing.
Not a plot hole 1: Asuna’s scarf
During the end credits, Asuna’s scarf is seen tied on Shin’s right arm, the exact same place where Shun had her scarf when he was last seen. Some people who have noticed this did not notice other things, such as the fact that the scarf was usually kept tied around her neck, under her collar. She really did get another one from her school, because she has the scarf around her neck again when she starts her journey to Agartha. Some people shipped AsunaxShun so hard that they thought Shun never died, and that Shin is actually Shun in disguise. Desperate. The scarf was probably a parting gift, since Asuna has no way of coming back to Agartha.
Not a plot hole 2: Asuna’s character
Asuna is, in my opinion, a well thought out character. Her biggest issue is that she cannot live her life fully. After her father passed, a large part of her happiness was gone, and she only has the clavis to remember him by. No details are given about his death, only that he was happy that Asuna was born. While she doesn’t seem to be stricken with grief, she is not interested in being with other people. Instead, she listens to the ethereal music on her radio and dreams of being in a different place.
After facing death multiple times, Asuna has her life flash before her eyes, reminding her of the things that she had or should have cherished. It is because of her adventure, that she is able to live her life happily, and safely, above the ground.
Creepy thing 1: Asuna’s teacher, Ryujii, acts more as a cautionary tale and glimpse into the future. Ten years after his wife’s death, he sacrifices Asuna and his eye to get his wife back. Though that is already immoral, people, namely myself, may also be revolted at the idea of him loving his wife’s soul through a young girl’s body. We only see his wife through Ryujii’s failing eye, so we don’t know if her body had transformed or if it was a trick of the eye, but it’s very possible that Asuna’s body did not change while going through possession.
Children Who Chase Lost Voices was not as melodramatic, simple, or obvious as Makoto Shinkai’s other works. That is probably the only reason why I like it more than his other works.
I don’t know if Makoto wants to become the next director of studio ghibli but this movie was basically his audition. Some ghibli films also have plot holes so I don’t think he is far off from ghibli’s trademark features.