La Belle Verte (1996)
Film review #719
Director: Coline Serreau
SYNOPSIS: On a faraway planet, a widow chooses to visit the planet Earth, since that is where her Mother came from. She finds a world disconnected from nature and suffocating under pollution, as she learns about the planet where her Mother was born...
THOUGHTS/ANALYSIS: La Belle Verte (The Green Beautiful) is a 1996 French film. The film opens up on an alien planet, where the residents gather for their annual get together, to share news. They remark that they have not sent anyone to Earth, which they believe is still much less advanced than themselves. Mira, a recent widow, volunteers to visit the planet and report on it's development, partly owing to her Mother being from Earth. the set up is very much your usual 'fish out of water' scenario where the main character is transported to modern day earth and all of the quirks that entails. The difference here though is that there's no real purpose or motivation: there's no impending catastrophe, big bad villain, nothing. It's just a trip by a woman with a bit of curiosity. Mira and her people have a special ability to 'disconnect' people from society, which removes any sense of societies structures and expectations form their thoughts to allow them to see and feel independent of them. Or something to that effect, it's difficult to explain.
Mira runs into a doctor named Max, who is in charge of midwifery who treats everyone around him as tools to further his career, and she disconnects him which makes him admit that because he cannot give birth, he compensates by treating everyone else badly. This also allows him to be honest with his family. The film goes through Mira disconnecting a number of different people including at a football match and orchestra performance, which lead to humourous outcomes, as well as Mira's sons coming to Earth to visit too, but there's not much of an overall plot as mentioned. What makes this film work is it just feels very warm and genuine: it's nice and comfortable, and a feel-good film that avoids the pitfalls of similar films by maintaining a down-to-earth sense of humour and style throughout. Even in the over-the-top moments such as the football match and orchestra scene, it still feels genuine. I would have liked to have seen more of people reacting to their disconnection and realisation that society's structures have clouded their own selves, but we only get that for the Doctor, and everyone else affected are just left pulling funny faces. There's a humourous scene where Mira recognises Jesus as one of her own people, and seems shocked that he was crucified; it's little scenes like this that help build enough of a story and atmosphere to settle the viewer into.
One of the criticisms you could level against this film is that the aforementioned lack of any real plot makes it feel a bit pointless, but honestly, that also feels like the point: the film is all about confronting societies purpose and structure and how we, as people, are made to be commensurate with it: the purpose of the structure replaces the individual's purpose, often without us realising. The film does not have a point because it would be antithetical to: the characters can just exist without society's goals or consumerism to drive them. Even with this, some might still find the film still too "preachy," critiquing all aspects of society that people might enjoy, but honestly, it never felt like that to me: one, the main character comes from a point of innocence, they're not really coming in with an agenda or opinion, only to explore the Earth. The beginning showing the aliens talking about Earth as somewhat barbaric still focused on industry and violence might play into that, but it's not really the point of the film, and doesn't factor to into it after. Second, the whole film really keeps everything mild and cozy: there's no big speech or dramatic exposition that is intended to persuade anyone of anything. you're just meant to sit and bask in the atmosphere and warmth that shines through. Honestly, I like this film a lot: it generates an authentic sense of warmth and friendliness through its characters, and drives its story through a sense of innocence, rather than any point. Not all are going to be convinced by the sheer absence of any real plot or purpose, but I am more than happy with what it pulls off.














