It’s no surprise that Paul Simon selected Aretha Franklin’s gospel cover of “Bridge Over Troubled Water” to be on his Songwriter compilation. Aretha carries the song from start to finish in true songstress manner, and honors its gospel roots. After all, the song title originated from a line in a Baptist church hymn.
Released on January 26, 1970, Simon & Garfunkel’s “Bridge Over Troubled Water” shot up to #1 on the Billboards Hot 100 chart within a month. A year later in March 1971, Aretha’s rendition was released, and also achieved the #1 and #6 spots on the US R&B and Pop music charts, respectively. Both versions earned their performers Grammys.
“(Don’t trouble the water) I won’t (leave it alone) (Why don’t you, why don’t you, let it be?) (Still water run deep… yes it do) I know that (Whoa-o-o-yeah) If you only believe… Just like a bridge over troubled water I will lay me down”
What are your thoughts of Aretha’s cover? Which version do you prefer?
–
About the Uncovering Covers series.
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery, such that this music series aims to spotlight musical gems as well as new and familiar artists. Cover songs will draw from the grand discographies of Paul Simon and Art Garfunkel, including both the duo’s and their solo works.
This year’s series will focus on the Simon & Garfunkel catalogue.
