Isaiah Bradley did pretty much exactly what Steve Rogers did. He went against express orders to do the right thing; he broke POW’s that the top brass had written off as expendable out of captivity and saved countless lives. He was a hero.
When Steve returned to his superiors, what did he get? A round of applause. Total forgiveness and praise. His fake rank of Captain turned into a real one despite his total lack of experience and training. A new fancy shield. A special squad of his friends given carte blanche to go on secret missions. A media tour. His face on magazines. TV specials. A place in the history books as a perpetual hero of our times.
What did Isaiah get? 30 years of imprisonment, torture, experimentation. He was vilified for doing the exact same thing that Steve was lauded for. Separated from his family, treated as a criminal, dehumanised and degraded. A lifetime of trauma served to him by the very country that he gave everything up for.
His story mirrors not just the African-American victims of human experimentation in the US but also the treatment of black soldiers who had given up everything to fight for the US in WWII and returned to violence and discrimination, and the plight of African-American soldiers fighting in Korea immediately after desegregation of the army. His erasure from the history books parallels the real erasure of almost a million black veterans of WWII from the documentary evidence of the war.
Though Isaiah Bradley is fictional, his story and treatment are firmly based in reality. I have to applaud everyone involved in this production, but particularly Malcolm Spellman, Carl Lumbly and Anthony Mackie, for bringing this character and story to life in such a impactful way, on one of the biggest stages that they could. Millions of Americans will now be reckoning with a disgraceful part of their history (and present) that has been ignored and covered up for so long, and that’s truly powerful.
















