It's no longer that time! My bad! In line with what I've heard of Epic's questionable casting decisions due to its (however unintended but clearly not considered and is still, therefore,) racist connotations, I want to bring up my perspective of the important purpose of the white, western perspective of race in The Odyssey !
The narrative of a "strong, hardened strategist that committed violent imperialism and war crimes that was key to winning a long war, overcoming the treacheries and battles of returning home, so that he can reclaim the family, life, and land that were rightfully his" would sound very bold and adventurous and encouraging to white men that we want to encourage to become soldiers of imperialism! You went off to war, you struggled, and you came back a hero reunited with his family! Yeah!
1) The Iliad and The Odyssey are not innately "pro-war" "pro-adventure" stories. Odysseus didn't even wanna go 🤣 and he was not a jolly man when he got back 🤣 but that narrative doesn't sell you on what I want, does it? You might not wanna go if you agree with Achilles, or see the suffering of Odysseus, as it is actually told! So I have to find a way to sell you on it!
2) this sort of story told from the perspective of a non-white would have been HORRIFYING for a society like this. Imagine- and yes, I'm gonna do it: imagine the story of a strategic Black man who'd gone off and done the things Odysseus did, was intelligent, determined, traumatized and bloodthirsty enough to hack it back, returning to kill the men imposing on his land and take his life back. Imagine this version of the story told in a time where the White Western world was rife with the desire to colonize and kill and return victorious- imagine the implication that someone you've deemed lesser had the capability, intelligence, and anger to pull this off, and therefore against you. 👀 That's not as fun as when it was you in the hero's seat! This wouldn't have been a very popular story!
I could do the same thing with Epic. Odysseus being Black would have changed the game in terms of how the story would be perceived. Think of the implications of the social history of Black resilience, or of a Black Penelope at home trying to hold down the fort while white men try to undermine her! Or of a white Circe and white Calypso trying to keep him- of the unspoken power that white women oft have over men of color! That would have revealed a different story, even with the same narrative! And a lot of people probably wouldn't have liked it!
Right. My point here is that no matter what any of you say, the society you live in will always have an effect on how you perceive a story, and how that story is told. You can't always just shove diversity into a story and think that it'll be the same. It won't be. You have to deal with everything that comes with, otherwise you're just haphazardly telling something that you might not even think you were saying. And sometimes what you're enforcing... might be pretty bad. 😅