He winced at the sigh. Here he was, trying the best he could to avoid the elephant in the room, only to end up tripping over the trunk. So much for his attempt to continue tromping on about the school. This was about Kate. In a way, it was all about Kate. There was all that time from before and after; it had really come to that, hadn’t it? He’d made a list of everything he’d done since she left, as if waiting for the right thing to show up so he could… well, he could do something. Even if he couldn’t help but feel the right thing would be to play copycat and hit the road. But he couldn’t.
There wasn’t time for that.
A hand landed on his, and he finally sighed - a surrender to the conversation to be had. He didn’t move his hand under hers, but placed his other over hers. He opened his mouth to protest. He was already shaking his head. But then she was already encouraging him to his feet, and - well, he always had a hard time saying no to the women in this bloody family. Left standing for a moment, he remained still, looking a little baffled. Belated, he glanced down at his plate when she mentioned leaving the dishes. He watched for a moment as she crossed the room, heading towards a door that Logan hadn’t ever bothered to open. Still, she told him to follow. After a moment, he did.
You don’t belong here, captain.
Logan’s hand went over the other, as if to hide his knuckles from such a… revered place. He didn’t have to be told to assume it was this was a room for her husband. It was tidy… but unused. It looked how holding your breath felt. Like waiting.
He felt the word as if he’d been struck, though there wasn’t pain. Perhaps he was recognizing the monumental weight of taking the chair. Taking a place in a home that wasn’t his. Of the pair one was long dead, and yet Logan could feel the weight of two gazes on him as he obeyed Gretchen’s request. Sinking into the seat with his hands on the desk. Men in interrogations were required to keep their hands above the table, and even they would seem less stiff.
Fuck you, something vicious inside him suddenly spat. Logan turned his head away from Gretchen, acting as if he was looking to the other side of the desk and not hiding what might have been a snarl. I get this whole shitty life, I lose the girl, and now you sit me down like I was always meant for this domestic bullshit? Goin’ through old photos, reminisce about the good ol’ days? Look back to look forward, is that what this is? As if there’s any forward at all for you?
Logan reached out, not with tension or hostility. But just a careful hand, so afraid of leaving bruises on such a sacred place. His fingers touched the frame of a photo, curving as if he was about to pick it up, but he didn’t. His thumb smudged in the dust, leaving his print. He had been here. Whether he liked it or not, understood it or not, he had been here.
His voice was gentle, though perhaps not for Gretchen’s sake. Perhaps he deserved just as much as a quiet in the answer as he put in the question. “Why we down here, huh? This ain’t…”
Finally turning to her, there was a sense of giving in when his eyes landed on her. He gave up his questions, his reasoning, for her sake. His gaze dropped slightly, looking like a child that’d been reprimanded, and he finally answered, “I see it, Gretch.”
Gretchen nodded, standing at Logan’s side, her eyes on the pictures. “She and her uncle were two peas in a pod. Pulling pranks, laughing, living... loving life and all the joy it had to give. But I thought I’d never see that smile again after that... that piece of shit attacked her when she was sixteen. Kate had become this sullen, melancholy, and serious creature... one I hardly recognized. She spent her free time finishing up her schooling, working with the animals, and training with Thomas. He wanted her to be better prepared.”
Gretchen paused, shaking her head. There was a hitch in her breath, emotions nearly overwhelming her, but she pushed it back down, knowing she needed to make her point before she lost him. “And then... she disappeared from our lives. I didn’t see her again for probably twelve years. Even upon her return, there was no smile... there was no joy. There was hardly any emotion at all that was visible to the naked eye. Then she started coming around more and a year later, she was telling me about a school for mutants... and after a while, YOU became a regular topic. And for the first time in thirteen years... that smile,” she said, pointing at the pictures on the desk, “was there on her face again.”
Gretchen took a small step back and leaned down, opening one of the drawers on the desk. She carefully rummaged around inside until she had found what she had been looking for. The drawer was shut again and she reached inside the envelope, pulling out another image, which she then handed to Logan. It was a candid shot of Kate with him, a grin on her face that matched the one in the older pictures.
“I know you’re probably angry with her... as you should be. She left when she should have stayed... But I want you to be angry with her for the right reasons, Logan. Don’t ever think she left because she didn’t love you. She loves you more than she loves anything else in this world. She loves that school and those children. But YOU... you were everything to her. Leaving you was the hardest decision she’s ever made... however misguided it was.”
Kate had told Gretchen her real motivations for leaving but in Gretchen’s opinion, it wasn’t really her place to explain it to Logan. The only one that should be doing any explaining was Kate herself, only she wasn’t here to do it.