My boyfriend is a monster who likes to eat unripe bananas. Ok, that doesn’t really make him a monster, but I like my bananas freckly and ripe. He was complaining about how ripe the bananas were when picking one up for a snack, which gave me the brilliant idea to make banana bread, rather than have him eat the bananas that were too ripe for his tastes.
I have made banana bread A LOT in my life. Mostly it has been my southern grandma’s banana bread recipe that I grew up eating all the time. I went through a phase a few years ago where I tried to learn how to make banana bread muffins using healthier recipes that included things like whole wheat flour and honey, but they were never as good as grandma’s, full of fat and sugar and yumminess.
I decided to try a new recipe from The Complete America’s Test Kitchen TV Show Cookbook.
The first thing I had to figure out how to do was toast the walnuts. The only way to do this is to google “how to toast walnuts” and follow the instructions on the first website that pops up, conveniently named How to Toast Walnuts. I went with option number 2 on this site, toasting them on the stove. I might have had the stove set too high, because they seemed to turn darker than I was expecting and smelled a little more burned than toasted. But I took them off the stove before the time was up and moved on. Also, the recipe called for 1 ¼ cups of walnuts, but the bag came with 1 ½ cups, so I just used the entire bag. I figured they’d take up less volume once they were chopped using my Ninja Chopper, one of my underutilized kitchen accessories. And if you’re going to put nuts in the bread, why not just have more?
The mechanics of the recipe were pretty easy. You didn’t even need to use a blender since the butter was melted and allowed to cool, which I did as an after thought, so I’m not sure how cool my butter was and if it was cool enough, but everything worked! I will say, I was actually a little disappointed that I didn’t get to use my stand mixer, which was a Christmas present that I’ve had for a while and have only used once or twice. So many underutilized kitchen accessories!
One down side of this recipe was that it called for ¼ cup of plain yogurt. I could only find a huge tub of plain yogurt. Maybe I wasn’t looking closely enough, but I thought I scoured my Kroger shelves. Everything was either Greek yogurt or had fruit in it. Maybe plain Greek yogurt would have been ok, but I didn’t want to chance it. But the large tub of store brand plain yogurt was only about $2, which is probably not that much more expensive than a specialty small serving of yogurt. I just hate food waste, so I’ll have to see if I can find any other uses for it, or I’ll see if I can stomach eating it on its own (with some chocolate granola sprinkled in it). I usually eat vanilla yogurt and I don’t know if I’m quite sure what plain yogurt tastes like…
I got a little nervous watching the bread rise in the oven, picturing it baking over and making a mess in the oven, but it stayed contained the entire time! I also worried about over baking since some parts of the bread gave me a clean toothpick and another part came out banana-y. So far, I don’t think the bread has been too dry though!
I ate my first slice (an end piece) last night when I baked this and it seemed more crusty that I was used to from banana bread, but that could have been from the fact that it was an end piece and semi-fresh from the oven. I had another piece this morning for breakfast and it was good and the outer portion didn’t seem as crusty. Boyfriend gets back from his weekend trip later today, so we’ll have to see his reaction to the banana bread.
I named this post part 1 because at some point, I’m sure I’ll post about making my grandma’s banana bread for comparison. Also, the cookbook also included an “ultimate banana bread” recipe, which I’ll have to try. It required 6 bananas though, so I’d have to buy bananas specifically for that and not rely on excess bananas that my boyfriend didn’t eat.
I’d say this recipe was a success, but I don’t think it’ll replace my grandma’s recipe since it requires that small amount of yogurt. But now I might be inspired to add the walnuts to my grandma’s recipe to give it a little something extra! I could use another crack at toasting the walnuts to see if I can do a better job the next time around.
Edited to add: I actually used butter and flour to grease the pan as the recipe said. Normally I’d just spray Pam and be done with it, but I’ve watched all of Nailed It! on Netflix and I’ve seen that go wrong with contestants and learned I shouldn’t do that.