Daddy-Long-Legs and Dear Enemy
You know, epistolary novels* can be done really well or really badly. So it’s always a relief when they’re done really well, and Jean Webster’s little duo of novels about these two college friends and the John Grier House for Orphans’ impact on their lives is delightful.
Daddy-Long-Legs follows the story of Judy (Jerusha—the poor thing), an orphan of the JGH, as an anonymous orphanage benefactor sends her to college, with the caveat that she must write to him regularly of how her education is progressing. Her letters are charming in the style of an Anne Shirley (comparisons were drawn in other reviews to Jo March, but I don’t see it), and it’s difficult not to find yourself cheering for her and falling just a bit for Judy’s pluck and ability by the end.
Dear Enemy, the sequel, finds Judy’s college roommate Sallie McBride accepting a commission to make over the JGH into a better orphan institution than it was during Judy’s woeful childhood. Sallie is a society girl, and what she encounters in some of her misadventures at the orphanage definitely test her mettle. She’s not quite as likable as Judy, and had this nugget to offer:
Five other children have been sent to their proper institutions. One of them is deaf, one an epileptic, and the other three approaching idiocy... This is an educational institution, and we can't waste our valuable plant in caring for defectives.
Which, needless to say, is pretty wildly offensive. Though perhaps the audience of 1915 didn’t think so? It felt like a jarring misstep in an otherwise sensitive and compassionate novel about the lives of orphans in a system poorly designed to assist them.
Anyway, I’d recommend these to folks looking for some nice stories about (generally) nice girls.
*I generally assume my readers know basic literary terminology but just in case, an epistolary novel is a novel written using letters, telegrams, emails, and diary entries as the primary text to drive the plot and character development. If done poorly, it feels like cheap exposition. If done well, you feel like you’re spying on someone’s private correspondence and get a great story to boot. Dracula is another great example of this format done well.
The next book in A Penguin Class will be Early American Drama, an anthology edited by Jeffrey H. Richards.