CHARACTER RANT
Chad Charming wasn't really an asshole in the first movie compared to the 2nd. In the 3rd, he's honestly just kind of dumb, BUT in the first movie, he seems like an asshole when you first watch but as I've grown older and watched it more, I notice that he kinda has a point. While it wasnt cool of him to use Evie for homework, she was trying to use him for money and status. Sure thst was because her mom conditioned her to do so, but it was still wrong of her. On that action, both of them are at fault and both of them and in the wrong. Later, during parents day or whatever it was called, when he verbally attacked them he only insulted them in ways that were true. He called evie a gold digger, because that was true, she was digging for gold. He told Jay that he was violent/liked hurting people, because that's what Jay had shown to do when Chad was around. I do not remember what he said to Mal, but I do distinctly remember him NOT insulting Carlos. This is important because Carlos hadn't done anything wrong. He was the only one in the Core 4 that hadn't done anything to gain Chad's ire, and in response, Chad didn't insult him. While I don't know if this was a purposeful choice, I think it shows that, at least in the first movie, Chad isn't really a villian. He's just a bit of a douche (but only a little bit)
Sorry but I disagree with “what Chad said about Jay and Evie were not wrong” bc
1.”Jay enjoyed hurting people” comes from the way Jay acted in the tryout. But did he? Yes he was aggressive, but it’s what expected in the sport that requires protect gears on players and rules are the mix of football and lacrosse, with several cannons aiming at whoever cross the war zone. Look at cheers and coaches reactions that went complete opposite as Audrey and Chad. They’re cheering and smiling at Jay’s play, totally accepting it because that’s what expected. Even the coach Jenkins voiced it a raw talent, and when he mentioned that Jay needed a bit of help with rules and respect the teamwork, he did not mention that Jay was way too aggressive. Later, the coach also mentioned about “the team is a bunch of princes, if you know what I mean”. It implied that the team wasn’t showing their hunger for victory enough to win, which the coach expected Jay to change with his eagerness to win while trying to improve the teamwork. Also, the hostility came from Chad’s part first when Jay was called a raw talent instead of getting kicked out of the tryout(I suppose that’s what Chad expected).
2.”Evie was a gold digger” is also very biased accusation when Evie was interested in Chad’s princely appearance first. Which can’t be blamed because that’s what she’s been trained to see the appeal of. Still, Evie played her game fair. She did not manipulate Chad in anyway. All Evie did in the attempt to make Chad falling in love with her was to appeal her beauty and her abilities to cook, clean, sew, etc. Evie played it fair to appeal how she’s somewhat a Cinderella material in hoping Chad would want his own Cinderella just like his father. And did she lie? No. It’s sad that Evie was brainwashed to believe that she had to get a prince fall in love with her and marry him, but it wasn’t the act on Evie’s part when she liked Chad. Evie was truly ready to fall in love with him and most likely be a good wife material. Honestly, I don’t see much difference between Evie with Chad and Audrey with Ben. If we can see Audrey truly liked Ben and it really hurt her to be dumped over other girl was the reason why she acted the way she did, while she’s also brainwashed by her own family that she must be Ben’s Queen and her whole life was designed to be, we should be able to see Evie’s case as something more than just a failed gold digger attempt. Also, Chad initiated the relationship between them, and while Evie noticed Chad appealing first, Chad only saw Evie appealing when he realized that she’s probably smart enough to do his homework. Then he also started the hostility first when he stole Evie’s mirror and snitched on her when he’s benefitted from her cheating.
And the other problem of Chad framing Evie’s action as “gold digging” is, he’s not only trying to accuse her of what she did with him, but also trying to ruin the relationship Evie has built with Doug. He’s suggesting that she’s doing the same with Doug and when Doug tried to apologize for what happens earlier, Chad put the pressure on Doug. He’s not just stating his “fact” with Evie there but also fully intended to ruin Evie’s reputation and relationship with other people. That was, sorry for strong word, evil.
Also even before the VKs did anything to earn the hostility and grudges from AKs, it’s Chad and Audrey framed them as “bad news”.
And only when it’s justified for AKs to have the hostility was Audrey’s case when she’s got dumped for no reason, and Jane when Mal taken advantage of her insecurities and purposely feed into it by suggesting that Jane wasn’t beautiful enough.
Other than these moments, AKs couldn’t possibly known the intentions behind the VKs actions and Chad was making accusations while purposely cut the part where he’s at fault. Framing things in favor of him makes it not up for the discussion of right or wrong.
















