Since moving to Mystic Falls, Buffy did her best to keep the fact that she was a slayer from Jenna, Elena, and Jeremy. If they knew, they would automatically be dragged into this part of her life and she didn’t want that for them. Especially not for Elena and Jeremy. They were still in high school. She didn't want them to be worrying about vampires crashing Parent-Teacher night, swim team monsters, or devil dogs at the prom.
However, Elena's life was growing similar to Buffy's. Her best friend was a witch, her boyfriend, Stefan, looked like Angel or at least like they could be related, and to top it off, Stefan and his brother were vampires. And poor Jeremy's girlfriend was transitioning into a vampire and ran away. Her brother, Matt, and Stefan were out looking for her while Buffy stayed with the teenagers. Elena was doing her best to comfort a very worried Jeremy, but nothing was helping.
"What about you?" Buffy asked Elena, taking her aside as they cleaned up the literal mess Vicki made. "How are you doing?"
Elena answered, "Well, in the past twenty-four hours, I found out that my boyfriend and his brother are vampires, one of my cousins is a vampire slayer who died TWICE, and everything that I thought was made up is actually real except for leprechauns."
"So, peachy with a side of keen, then?" Buffy joked, earning a smile from Elena. "I'm sorry you found out about all of this."
"It's not even remotely your fault," Elena said. "I'm glad I know the truth about you, though. If anything, it's the reassuring element of all of this.....But, is there anything else I should know?"
Elena went to answer the door followed by Jeremy with Buffy close behind. Elena only opened the door only a little bit, gasped, and then immediately tried to shut the door, but then it was pushed open revealing Damon Salvatore. Immediately, Buffy started to grind her teeth in anger as she approached the door. When she first met Damon, she thought he was okay. A little annoying and arrogant, but they had a few pleasant conversations here and there. Plus, he was the only other person in town close to Buffy's age, so she tolerated him. But, after finding out what he really was and everything he'd done within the past week and seeing him standing in the doorway right now, Buffy wanted to shove a log through his chest.
Buffy bit the inside of her cheek.. There was Dawn. A billion-year-old ball of energy turned nineteen-year-old human, but only alive for five years. Was Elena ready to know that? That all of her childhood memeries with Dawn were fake Jeremy?
Luckily, she didn't have to decide because Jeremy once again voiced his concern for Vicki. Both girls told him that they had to wait and that Matt would call when he found her. They did their best to reassure him that everything would be fine and then the doorbell rang.
"Jeremy, Elena, get away from the door," Buffy said glaring at Damon while maneuvering herself between him and the two teenagers. Jeremy went upstairs after Elena whispered to him to go. Buffy wished Elena would follow suit, but she knew that wasn't happening. She kept her eyes locked with Damon’s, hoping he would take the hint and leave, but she had a feeling that wasn't going to happen.