you asked for our slasher imagines I think?? I can’t find it but I wanna share it so- ghostface, right? Just, (adult, obvi) Billy & Stu developing an “interest” in some geeky n shy darling who’s new to the group, they do the whole phone routine but it’s flirtier than usual. Like “you’re so pretty when you’re trembling” and “hey it’s ok, don’t cry baby, i won’t do anything you don’t ask me to~” with some window/door knocking ending with “see you soon, doll face~”.
I imagine they make each phone call more and more lewd, to the point it’s straight up phone sex (albeit one sided).
You’ll be sobbing into your hand as you pick up the phone, listening to the gravelly voices tell you how they want to ruin you and how they’re one step closer to getting you all alone.
Your friends are all dead besides Billy and Stu, and you turn to them one night sobbing and needing to just be with your last remaining friends so you wouldn’t go off the deep end. That night they console you and agree that shits been going absolutely horrible, all while barely hiding a smirk.
You’ll be curled up on the couch, sniffling before slowly drifting off to sleep, thinking maybe you can get some sort of peace of mind in your subconscious. Couldn’t hurt to try right? All while the two men sit beside you and chitchat casually. A little too casually.
Something was off with the boys all night long actually. Ever since the murders have been happening it’s as if their responses have been scripted and planned, but you felt that saying so would make you out to be a bitch. Who are you to say how someone acts during a tragedy? But there was always that nagging feeling that they weren’t truly as devastated or as impacted as the rest of your group.
While this thought becomes more passing, you let your eyelids fall shut to the sound of the increasingly quiet room. A gentle brush of your hair behind your ear stirs you slightly, but you don’t show much attention to the action.
Your heart leaps into your throat however when a voice asks, in a deeply amused chuckle “Hey Y/N, do you like scary movies?”.
-Mommabean
