Briefly coming out of "oh no I can't keep up with tumblr goodbye forever" retirement because I've been thinking a lot about what this post gets at recently. I don't think this is the main way we got here with shitty LLMs stealing people's work and destroying the environment but I do think there's something here:
People love the idea of Being A Writer. There's a kind of cultural cachet to it -- the idea that writers are intellectual and creative and talented. When you see writers in movies and on TV, they're usually rich and fabulous; they go to parties with influential people, their book signings have lines out the door, they're swimming in free time to have adventures or whatever the show/movie happens to be about.
People want that life. Heck, I want that life, and I know it's a fiction, that 99.9% of writers don't live like that. Most novelists have day jobs because writing rarely pays the bills, let alone gives you that lifestyle.
The thing is, not only is that not what most writers ever experience, it also lacks one big thing that all writers do experience: actually writing. The part where you have to translate what's in your brain to something on a page, which requires sitting down at a computer and making words -- lots of words -- sometimes when you don't wanna. Making those words into coherent stories. Learning how to finish a draft, which is hard, and then how to edit said draft, which means learning how to spot where your writing is borked and then how to fix it. That is all actually hard work, it's a skill that takes time to develop, and it's the actual job of being a writer. (Writing is skilled labor but that's a side rant.)
So when we pull it all together you have a job that takes time and effort to learn how to do well enough to be a professional, and then does not actually pay well or give you benefits -- and you only get that meager pay if you've made it through many flaming hoops, none of which are in your control -- and it's all still most likely a side hustle on top of your full time job. It doesn't give you the glam lifestyle it gets shown as. So why do people do it?
Because they enjoy writing. If you don't actually like doing the work, you're not going to practice enough to get to a level where you can become a professional at it. You have to love doing it. (That doesn't mean you love every moment you spend sitting at your computer; sometimes it's like pulling teeth. But on the whole? You'd rather do the work than not because doing the work is rewarding in and of itself.)
But that's not what people think of when they think about Being A Writer. The idea of Being A Writer has basically nothing to do with the actual art or labor of writing. So of course people who know nothing about writing figure ChatGPT can do it all for you. Why do all the tedious work of writing when you could just Be A Writer and get all the benefits they imagine exist? Heck, anyone can do that now!
Those people completely miss the point. People who try writing thinking it's basically a get rich quick scheme tend to fail out, because it really, really isn't. The people who stick around and keep doing it (I've been thinking of novelists, but tbh it goes for anyone who actually does the work, regardless of if it's for pay or for fun or what genre or format you're doing it in) ... they do it because they actually love writing. The labor.
All ChatGPT does is remove the fun part. But people who aren't writers aren't going to see that, because what they see is Being A Wrtier, not the actual act of writing.