suzie--craine:
As Suzie looked around her table to see if she’d had the foresight to grab napkins, it was then she heard that voice she knew all too well. She froze, hearing those familiar words and just like that, her heart broke. Guilt and shame washed over her because of course, it wasn’t an angry voice. It was soft and caring, just like it always was. She bit her lip, closing her eyes and then looking up as she opened them to gaze upon the face of the man she’d essentially spent her entire childhood with as well as part of her young adult life.
She was absolutely frozen and soon, the entirety of the café and it’s patrons melted away and all that existed now, in this moment, was her and Ben. Her heart was pounding so hard against the inside of her chest that she was sure he heard it. She was stunned and with all her might she tried to hold back the inevitable tears that were bound to come. “H-hi,” was all she could say.
As he sopped up the mess of her drink, she took some napkins from him and sopped up the liquid that had soaked into her clothing as well, smiling politely and taking a deep breath. “Fancy seeing you here,” she bit her lip, looking back up at him, the most guilt ridden expression on her face. She wanted to tell him everything, pour her heart out, apologize profusely. She knew she’d hurt him all those years ago.
Suzie looked him over a bit, admiring the signs of aging that had developed on the boy she loved; more facial hair, wrinkles at the corners of his eyes, shorter hair, less skinny and more filled out. He’d, of course, only grown more handsome and was still so sweet. She half expected him to be angry and dismissive with her when and if they crossed paths. She knew how small the city could be and she knew it was only a matter of time.
“How, um… how have you been? Congrats on all the music stuff. I’ve been trying to keep up.”
--
Don’t do this, Ben wanted to say. Don’t tell me you keep tabs on me, like you care.
If Ben hadn’t known where to look, he might have believed that Suzie hadn’t aged a day. It wasn’t fair that the years refused to add up on her the way they’d added up on him. Wasn’t fair that looking at her was like time-traveling. Seven years.
He passed the gross wad of napkins from one hand to the other, then turned so he could throw it away – so he could have a moment to breathe. But then he looked back at her, and he saw the corners of her mouth turn up in a smile, like this wasn’t the worst thing that had ever happened to her, and he wanted to die.
“I’ve been good,” he finally said. If someone had asked him that mere minutes ago, he would have believed it. Now he wasn’t so sure. He didn’t want to lie to Suzie, even now, but what good would the truth do?
I’ve been looking for love in the bodies of strangers like some drunk teenager, Suzie. I let a man spit in my mouth because I thought I deserved it, Suzie. I wake up alone every single day because letting someone else move in would feel like cheating, Suzie.
“Why –” he swallowed. Why did you do that to me, Suzie? “– Um, what brings you back to New York?”















