As I wait breathlessly to watch the final Bill Hader episode of SNL, here's an old draft I wrote in 2010 about Stefon and meta-comedy that never ended up going anywhere.
I watch Saturday Night Live because it's there, and so am I. It's kind of like that person you always ended up going home with because it was 2AM and you were too drunk to go home alone ... except this is also a story about marriage, adulthood, relative sobriety, and life in a city that makes a bad job out of "quality of life".
When I laugh, it's usually because the show is silly, not funny. When SNL does better than that, I get extremely possessive about it. I guess you could even say I'm proud of it. Will Ferrell's idiot-pure version of "Goodnight Saigon" tried, through mockery, to wring real emotion out of overwrought pap. It turned senseless cameos and a mismatched imaginary big band into something resembling community -- and from there, on to loss and redemption. It did all the work the Billy Joel original could never do today, and did so, at bottom, by making fun of the troops. I spent most of Monday and Tuesday trying to organize my thoughts on it. Jenny Slate's ethnic doorbell lady was just as good, and I wouldn't dare ruin it by trying to play critic with it.
I'm pretty sure that, when Bill Hader's Stefon first appeared on "Weekend Update" last April, I didn't think much of it the next morning. Stefon, the overgrown club kid with psychedelic long sleeves creeping out from under a tight green t-shirt with a dragon on it, was a lisp with a grocery list of non sequiturs. In his segment, Stefon hips Seth Meyers to a series of New York clubs sure to appeal to anyone visiting from of town. The basic joke -- the contrast between Meyers' plea for wholesome travel advice and the degenerate Stefon -- went stale before it started. The real meat of the character, if it makes sense to call it that, were his descriptions of the clubs. At once prudish and knowing, all of them involved some combination of sitcom figures, physical abnormalities, abjection, and various queer sub-categories.
Hader is poised, and all about selling this character, up through the "high-waisted midgets" and "Teddy Graham people". Then, when asked to explain "human fire hydrants", Hader just loses it. He starts to crack up, turns away from the camera, and sets off wild applause. Luckily, one of Stefon's mannerisms is to place his hand over his mouth, and by the end, Hader is relying on it for cover. That's when you wonder: what if the whole point of this gesture is to provide Hader with a safety valve?
As funny as Stefon has been—and let's face it, the repetition (and repetitiveness) really only strengthens the gag—this moment is the highlight. Whether or not you think Saturday Night Live, or this sketch in particular, is funny, it's heartening to be reminded that the performers do. A movie like Funny People, or to some degree, Louie, explores not only the intersection of comedy and reality, but also the fascination we have with comedians as people—and comedians as essentially engaged by their own jokes. It's affirmation that we are laughing at the right things. And we aren't laughing, well, it makes us happy to get that kind of authentic glimpse into the emotions behind the delivery system.
Stefon was back in May. This time, the audience isn't exactly jolted when he finally has to take a step back and quell his laughter. In fact, from the beginning, Hader has trouble holding it together. In October, not only did Stefon get some of funniest lines yet— I particularly like "a Russian guy talking on a pre-paid cell phone" and "Is that Mick Jagger? No, it's a fat kid on a Slip 'N Slide."—he also gave in and let his shakiness become part of the humor. That's the tenor of the exchange; we're laughing at his inability to do his job, but also with him. Hader himself laughs not only at the material, but also the meta-gag of comedy too potent for the comedian to handle. There's no joke without the performer; if the performer succumbs to his own tricks, is that the ultimate success or an amateur-ish failture? It depends, again, on how much you value professionalism. Or if it's sometimes reassuring, even sublime, to be reminded of the craft and the subject behind it. Meyers, the straight man whose job it is to anchor Hader, providing a foil and a steadying influence if need, erupts off-camera. Everything is falling apart, and what began as an vehicle for wacked-out imagery has turned into a bit of pomo theater that revels in its own dysfunction.
We got our latest look at Stefon on Saturday, and now, the bit itself has evolved into a vehicle for the controlled chaos of October. The lines have grown more spare, as if to give him less to choke on, or slow down the goofball momentum that makes it so hard to keep a straight face. Hader is also very clearly reading from cards, and now has Stefon periodically covering his whole face. The goal is to prevent a total meltdown, or perhaps the intent is to keep the unrest to a minimum, reaping its comedic advantage without risking collapse. Either way, it backfires.
The new rhythms are almost like an admission of defeat, and the way Hader reacts to the lines as he reads them makes you wonder if he's ever seen them before. When Stefon appears, the audience not only anticipates Hader and Meyers breaking character; they approach the whole thing as if it were a challenge to the performers, one that, when they fail, will allow them all to share a good laugh. It may not be as spontaneous, or fresh, and the sudden unity has been replaced by a more contrived collaboration. Yet the audience seizes on Hader's every missed beat, as if anticipating the crack-up. They seem to understand that the sketch becomes truly participatory, an inside joke from the beginning by virtue of their expectations (and those suggested by the new safeguards in place). What results is biggest mess of all the Stefon appearances, and despite the paucity of language, probably the most rewarding.