AMC Just Connected Daryl's Tape Recorder, "Diverged", and The Military Storyline. Thanks, AMC!
This seems to be our first official hint from AMC, imo. Thanks to @obidala2 for pointing out this post. Thanks also to @atrumreginablue for tagging me on this post about Norman's recent Instagram posts that reminded so much of Diverged!
I theorized here that the tape recorder might lead Beth to Daryl, and here AMC is reminding us of the recording and telling us that it is going to be important!!!
I also theorized in that post that Codron may be our "Noah" connecting Daryl and Beth's paths and guess who is back ??
So, this post by AMC could mean that some of the things we have theorized might finally coming together.
Notice the emoji at the top is saluting?
THE MILITARY. So, AMC is connecting the military base storyline in DD4 to the words Daryl spoke into the recorder in DD1x1.
If the recorder does end up in the hands of this group, why would they care about a random American in a recording that could have been made at any point?
Unless someone who hears it KNOWS Daryl Dixson........
When Norman said in an interview that the spin-off was always going to end "in a very specific way", many didn't believe it.
While I do think they planned on more seasons of the spin-off, the ending was always going to be Daryl's "happy ending" with Beth.
What was presented in the most boring episode of TWD ever............. Diverged................... clearly shows that this military arc was being planned when the extra episodes for season 10 were written.
Let's take a look at it again with some hindsight and try to predict how the spin-off will end.
In season 10's Diverged, which I am now seeing as an allegory for all the whole spin-off, the bulk of the episode, at least for Daryl, is him trying to fix his motorcycle to make it back home.
Back in 2023, we had no idea what direction the spin-off might take. However, some of our theories have been correct while others have missed the mark mostly due to the assumption that the spin-offs would have more connection. You can read the 2023 post I sent to @twdmusicboxmystery here.
I believe we were correct on most of the basic symbolism presented in the episode.
The knife=love interests.
The bike =Daryl/his journey/his life
The rat in the walls= Something in the subconscious/mind troubling the person.
The railroad tracks=A crossroad in life.
The hose and correct knife are what Daryl needs to fix his bike/life.
Let's take a quick look at some of the elements in Diverged again.
The beginning of the episode parallels the end and coda of season 11.
First, Daryl gives Carol Leah’s knife so that she can get water out of her canteen.
This is symbolic of Daryl's working with Maggie and killing Leah. He uses Leah to help Maggie, eventually killing her for Maggie. Here, in season 10, he "gives up" Leah via her knife to help Carol.
Then, Carol asks him to come home with her, but he says he wants to keep looking for a while.
This foreshadows Daryl wanting to keep looking for "something" in the coda for season 11.
When the path diverges, Dog goes with Carol even though he obviously misses Daryl. Dog looks back and whines but seems to know he can’t follow Daryl. Just like Judith in the coda. At the time, I thought Dog must be symbolic for Judith.
I think I was right and that taking care of Judith in the Commonwealth, a little girl around Sophia:s age, is part of what stirred up and brought Carol's guilt about Sophia scratching at the walls of Carol's mind.
DD2 and DD3 have clearly shown us that even though Carol was staying in Daryl's house(his spin-off) the walls were Carol's mind and the rat symbolized her guilt over Sophia. At the time I thought the rat might be Rick, but now it's clear that it was symbolizing Carol's guilt over Sophia.
Carol picks up the scarf and throughout the episode contemplates trying to fix it but ultimately decides not to, even though someone obviously once loved it.
At the time, I thought this may symbolize the Hilltop because of DD2. Now, I see that scarf represents the past. At the end of the episode, Carol realizes you can't fix the past(scarf) you just need to let go of it and move on. So, she throws the scarf in the trash.
Next, Carol goes into Daryl’s house. She picks up a book Daryl is reading about pirates.
I was right in my predication that Daryl would be "pirated" away on a ship.
Initially, I thought Jerry symbolized Ezekiel who would help Carol move on. Now it is clear that it is Antonio who will finally help Carol move on and laugh again. As the rat is leaving at the end of the episode, Carol and Jerry laugh together.
The writers even helped us with this one in DDS3 by having Carol state directly to Antonio that he reminds her of her friend, Jerry!
Now, to the Daryl/DD/Beth part!
Daryl rides off away from Carol like he does in the TWD Coda, and his bike breaks down just like it does in Maine.
The bike clearly symbolizes Daryl himself and his journey.
There is a hole in the hose on the bike. There is a hole in Daryl’s life. He must fix the metaphorical hole to continue on his life journey and find his way back home. Fixing the bike symbolizes fixing his life and getting his happy ending as stated multiple times at the beginning of the spin-off.
First, he walks for a while and finds some cars. I believe the cars represent the first two seasons in France.
Car #1 There is nothing there to help him fix the hole.
Car #2 is a place where walkers almost kill him, but he gets part of what he needs. Just as I originally speculated, Laurent is the hose, which is part of what he needs. It's in season two that Daryl becomes Laurent's father.
However, the hose or “child” alone will not fix the bike/Daryl. In fact. the knife(Isabelle) he uses to try to put the hose on the bike doesn't work. Symbolically, Isabelle as a love interest would not work out.
Next, Daryl goes back to the bike and has to walk/push it to the train tracks(where his path diverged from Beth in Alone).
He sees some walkers(one looks like Beth). Then, for some strange reason, he starts to limp. I wonder if that is mirroring Beth’s limp in Alone, or it could represent him being hurt as reported in DDS4 spoilers before he is taken in by the military group.
He then comes across a military walker in a tree(aka trunk of the tree).
Perhaps there will be a connection between the CRM/military group and how Beth survived after being left in the trunk.
On the military walker, he finds ammo, food, and THE KNIFE(Beth) HE NEEDS TO FIX HIS BIKE(LIFE).
I had more analysis on how he would have to fight this group multiple times because the military walkers come back in Diverged. I also theorized that putting the hose on the bike with the knife would take some time before he could ride the bike back home because Daryl needed all night to fix the bike, even with the hose and the knife, in Diverged.
Those elements may not come into play because, as Norman admitted, they were NOT initially expecting the spin-off to end with season 4!
However, Daryl finds the knife/Beth in his FIRST encounter with the military, and he can't fix his life/bike without it!
What do we hear as Daryl is fixing his bike/life with the knife/Beth he found on the military walker? A wolf howling! A clear call back to "Up the Wolves" from Still.
What can we take from this?
I think it is another confirmation that Beth will indeed be with this military group and that the combination of Laurent and Beth are his happy ending. The recorder will be back in play, and it will be connected to the military group.
I should also point out that Diverged ends with Daryl and Carol going into separate houses to "hit the sack" or go to bed. I think this clearly symbolizes they will be going to bed but not with each other!
It also indicates that they will end the spin-off in separate locations because at the end of Diverged, they go into separate houses.
Does this mean they will be separated forever? Not necessarily. I could see them bringing Carol back at surprising point during a reunion series sort like at Terminus.