I have many thoughts on season 4 of Bridgerton as a whole. A lot of my thoughts aren’t positive.
I don’t know what these writers are thinking. I’ve always had a problem with them shrinking away from previous leads. I understand those couples won’t have significant storylines but…the side plots of other characters that are not Bridgertons takes bigger precedence when they could dedicate it to actual Bridgertons.
Here’s some other random thoughts:
1. Pacing - the longer episodes felt almost too long. The pacing once again was just off.
2. I feel like as much as people want Eloise as a season 5 lead I can’t ignore how much of Francesca was in part 2. Probably half of the second half was Francesca and they shied away from Eloise. I know they need to build Francesca a little bit a lot of what we saw should fall within her season (the grief process especially what we saw with Violet). I don’t know if it was a great idea to kill John this season I think it could’ve happened at another time.
3. Marcus and Violet. What a mess. Why why why would they spend so much time developing this for Violet to suddenly want to rediscover herself. Sorry. Make it make sense. I’m wondering if maybe the spinoff with be an Edmund/Violet or lady Danbury so maybe that’s why. But it’s just not great writing to me.
4. Polin. Pissed. Beyond pissed. There’s multiple things to talk about here. First - Polin as a whole. I’m glad we got to see them together and happy however it just felt disjointed. We should have been able to get Polin against the world. Why are they not writing together? Why don’t we see Colin sucking on Penelope’s neck while she’s writing a whistledown? Why don’t we see more of them being insufferable in their own home? They could have made a storyline about Portia wanting control of their household and Polin trying to manage the estate for their son.
Penelope - no no no no. I don’t have a problem with Penelope ending LW. I do have a problem with how they went about it and what happened afterward. Why in the world would the focus of Polins season for Penelope to want it all: the man, the job if she was just going to reveal herself and then end her column shortly after? She could have easily said she was done at the end of season 3 and season 4 could have been a different focus for her. The writers don’t know how to write LW and the fact Jess Brownell said that Penelope was Julia Quinn’s version of LW and they’re shifting to their own version. NO. There is one lady whistledown. How disrespectful is that to the character and to Nicola who put 10000% into Penelope. Even if Penelope decided she couldn’t do it and facilitated the change I would have preferred that to someone else just randomly taking Lady Whistledowns name which is what Penelope fought Cressida for last season. This is what I’m most upset about for this season.
Colin - they do not know how to write Colin. Kudos to Luke Newton for having developed Colin on his own and knowing the character so so well. Part 1 was atrocious for Colin. I think Luke Newton had another job or something so it makes sense he needed to be absent from some scenes but…they blurred him and cut off his head in shots. Part 2 was a little better for him. It’s made me want a spin off with the Featheringtons and the men going on their monthly food tour of London. But the fact that he barely had anything to do frustrated me to no end. It’s a repeat of his own season when he’s the Bridgerton and there wasn’t a whole lot of focus on him and more on Penelope. I got so mad at one point I shed a tear because I was so mad for Colin and Luke Newton. Like what a waste of his talent and his love for Bridgerton and his character.
They paraded Luke Newton out for promo when the man had about 10 minutes of total screen time. The character promo videos and a lot of what they put out early and consistently has been Polin. I am convinced they leaked the carriage scene themselves because season 3 pulled big numbers and they want to use them but not provide the characters with anything to prove it’s worthwhile.
At this point Colin and Penelope feel so ruined for me that I’d rather they not be in future seasons and I can create my own canon for them in my head. After this season I feel very done with Bridgerton as a whole. I feel too deep in it and have some unrealistic expectations for it to be a purely romance show with a tiny bit of drama. With Shondaland in charge it’ll never be that but I’ve seen other shows do it much much better.













