Prompt- What high school âmonsterâ is featured in this episode?
The entire episode âSurpriseâ serves to set up the Angelus story-arc that will round off season 2. âInnocenceâ begins the arc and jolts the audience with the sudden change in character dynamic. However, looking beyond that, the episode gives us the underlying themes of growing up, maturity, and how it all will affect us and our identities. Joss Whedonâs âmonsterâ is not so obvious as The Judge. Rather, itâs the looming monster that is the future when your young and still figuring out how to grow up and what that will mean.
Letâs start by analyzing where our characters are already. The episode begins, as many have and will, with a dream sequence. Of course, since its Buffy, a dream is never just a dream; itâs always symbolic or prophetic in some way. In this case, itâs both. Everything in this dream serves a purpose in connecting to some part of the episode- the location, the Bronze, is where Buffyâs surprise party happens; Willow is with a monkey, showing her growing relationship with Oz and calling back to their interaction in âWhatâs My Line, Pt 2â; Joyce dropping the plate is like a cue- Buffy thinks something will happen to Angel because thatâs the order of the dream. Even the music that plays is connected to Buffyâs current identity and her relationship status with Angel. The lyric âIâll do anything for you, now that Iâve found this loveâ in particular reflects the depths of their emotions for one another. For Buffy, Angel, and Willow, the dream places them at a moment in their identities when theyâre ready to move forward romantically.
The conversation Buffy and Willow have about moving forward with her relationship with Angel is obviously about sex, specifically whether or not Buffy should have her first time with him. Even though the whole episode is centered around maturing, I think itâs important to note here that Buffy is very much affected by her circumstances being the Slayer and aware of her destiny. Sheâs turning 17. Even though everyone is probably worrying about growing up right around then, I have a feeling she wouldnât feel quite certain if she didnât know death was a possibility every time she left her house. This is another aspect of the âmonsterâ. For some people, it comes after them too early and pushes them into making hasty decisions. Buffy especially wants to face the monster of growing up, probably especially because sheâs afraid if she doesnât take control, take these steps, and experience these things like love and sex, she wonât get the chance to.
Xander and Willow also display signs of maturity in their attempts to move their relationships forward. The âmonsterâ is real for them too, but without the fear of impending doom all the time, theyâre free to experience love at a more reasonable pace. Â
Whatâs important to note here in the main reason growing up is a âmonsterâ or something to fear, is often because it means change. Buffy doesnât know how sleeping with Angel will change her, or them. Her fearâs come to fruition when itâs not her that changes after their night together, itâs him, in the worst way possible. Both literally and metaphorically speaking. Metaphorically, Angelâs transformation brings to life this every-girl fear that sex will change the way a man sees you, and afterwards he will no longer want you.
Maturity is of course part of growing up. Despite these episodes displaying romantic relationships in a way that closely ties them to maturity, an important moment is near the end of âSurpriseâ when Buffy displays maturity and strategy by coming up with a sound plan. I want to mention this especially because Buffy doesnât need her relationship with Angel for her to mature. Sheâs still her own person, and will continue to grow despite Angelâs involvement.
Moving onto the plot of âInnocenceâ Angel (or Angelus) himself actually becomes a sort of high school monster feared by regular girls and Slayers alike. Yes, heâs technically a different person, and the actions of Angel and Angelus are considered separate by the characters in the show. But Buffy at first doesnât know this. She experiences her first time, then wakes up to find sheâs seemingly been abandoned, and when she sees him again he treats her like a child. He makes light of this important moment for her. Losing her virginity, to Buffy, was an important part of growing up. By treating her this way, Angelus basically yanks that feeling of maturity away from her. Every girl is warned, even before high school, that something like this could happen. The high school monster is the boy who treats you like he loves you, who gets you to give him something as valuable as your heart (or virginity) and then uses it as a way to hurt you. This same monster actually appears, to a much lesser extent, in the character of Parker in season 4.
Overall, Whedon portrays two possible monsters besides the obvious Judge, regular crew of vampires, and reappearance of Angelâs demonic alter ego. The fear of the future is almost universal among high school students, and Buffyâs and her friends approach to it reflect how we all have to take on that monster differently. The monster Angelus represents is also a common fear, and I believe Whedon purposefully chooses to portray Buffy reacting the way she does (âHeâs making it easier [âŠ] I have to kill himâ) to show that despite her anger not completely working out for her, itâs still better to react, and take action, than sit around and mope. Buffyâs maturity and experience growing up is showed once more at the end. She has matured to the point where she recognizes Angelus is not Angel; the man she loved didnât really hurt her in that way. However despite defeating him in battle, she doesnât kill him. Her line as she walks away from him though, âGive me timeâ, shows this is a step she has yet to reach, but she promises to continue growing up and maturing to the point where she is capable of this. We see this milestone in her maturity several episodes later, when she kills Angel in the finale.