So, Iâm finally near the end again of SNS 1 (who needs sleep anyways) and I already have thoughts when comparing it to later stories he has written, be it in the SNS series or entirely new ones. Iâll provide a more thorough in-depth analysis once my notes are organized and I donât have to deal with my day-job, but hereâs a huge observation that I already see in book 1:
Rob is way in over his head.
From the get-go, we see a feminist character who is not as inclusive as many readers would like to think or feel. Repeatedly, she body shames herself, as if this is all women think about when considering their appearances, and judges other women for their ideals. She defies expectations of women, yet bows down to a man, ignoring that strong pillar of her personality. She preaches inclusivity yet shuns other women in the story who are bound by society and literally have no choice. There is something strange about her, as if she is a hero, but not one who knows the depths of the problems she faces, or the consequences of what her actions might bring.
In laymanâs terms: throughout the story, there is just something off.
Eventually, the plot dwindles into some far-off abyss (letâs be honest, since book 2, the plot has gone south), and we get a more and more superficial character who appears to be all over the place in her ideals and morale, and less and less a strong woman. As a consequence, we see that core pillar of her personality, being a feminist, disappear.
This is when as the reader, if you take a critical eye to it, you realize what that âsomethingâ is. She reminds you of your brother, father, uncle, grandfather, boyfriend, husband, and male friend. She knows the issues exist, she sees them, she can critically assess them, she even constantly makes light of them, but she doesnât truly experience them fully as all women do.
Now, Iâm a clown myself who often tries to make light of situations; however, I know even I will break sometimes because being a woman sometimes really sucks. I know Lilly hasnât experienced sexual assault like have, but she has experienced restrictions and worry over what will happen to her if she doesnât conform to the expectations. Iâm living in an very open society, and I still feel anxious, nervous, and upset over that. I still sometimes feel sad because there will always be a man saying I canât. This happens to her too â repeatedly â and she barely bats an eye. But, she is a female character, so why doesnât she?
The reason for this is simple: Rob is a man, and can never fully comprehend the true worries, fears, and issues women faced now, let alone then when they were much more severe.
As you read on, you begin to wonder as a reader: whose voice is this? Is it the authorâs or Lillyâs? It is normal for an author to put a little bit of themselves in a character, sometimes even more so! But there is a problem when it is a man doing it to a female character. We start to see the mix of ideals and experiences; we start to see the boundary where a male writer cannot grasp what women go through on a day-to-day basis.
That would be fine initially, perhaps, for any new author. Why should we limit artistic expression? But it starts to blur into the readerâs perspective as to whether Rob himself feels this way. Because in this story, it is one single âjokeâ, and is never dealt with - not once - properly. We donât know for an absolute fact if he himself feels this way, heâs never made it clear! But it starts to look worse and worse as the stories go on and women are less and less powerful except when they are needed to bring the reader back in from the lost plot, as if to say âHey look! I do care sometimes!â
The result is an author writing about inclusivity, but instead, it comes across as discriminative. We have a single flat tone, as if someone is pressing a C note throughout the story, and never progressing. I donât know about you guys, but if Taylor Swift played one single note for her entire career, none of us would be listening. It stays there the entire time, a ruler-straighter tonality of constant comedy, turning and warping the inclusivity into cheap plot devices, and mental walls for the readers that he has to shakily try to break every so often.
With that in mind, after a few books the authorâs âcoloursâ start to show if this continues.
I started this series way back in the age of the dinosaurs, and adored it. I still do! I have nothing against the stories themselves or characters, I love me a good Victorian romance, but my goodness â the way the subject matter is dealt with is practically insulting of late!
I decided to go back to SNS 1, and look at it critically, as if Iâm back in uni trying to dissect Shakespeare. Worryingly, itâs already visible in book 1, and is excused repeatedly with commentary by the author using what I like to call âfalse empathyâ. Â An Instagram commenter recently mentioned that A/Ns are unprofessional, and I agree, I think theyâre dangerous. It is better to be upfront in the Prelude or Foreword, or shameless about the fact that you donât care (G.R Martin, anyone?) because this starts to add the authorâs view. With Rob constantly trying to excuse things, it makes everyone question things more and more â although perhaps in light of recent events, this is a good thing.
The fact of the matter is, at the end of the day, âThis was how it was in the timeâ is not an excuse to have the main female character constantly beat her appearance and dismiss other female characters whilst her own personality is diminished. It tricks readers into thinking a male author cares - but does he? Can he? Will he ever truly understand?
Probably not, itâs impossible.
However, this doesnât mean he needs to stop, and that I despise his stories (okay, maybe a little bit đ). It means he needs to change. It canât be âthis is what happened and this is how it wasâ. It needs to be this is how it was, this is what happened, this is how it felt, and this is itâs impact. It means he needs to read a book on feminism and issues women experience. It means he needs to ask women to gain a view as to how these things actually feel, and to gain insight into how itâs not something to make a 24/7 joke out of for multiple years. He needs to read up on how those who do not fit the particular âboxâ of discrimination he is dealing with tend to not like it when you constantly make fun of it tactlessly. There are ways to go about it, you can be funny and deal with serious issues.
Instead, Rob has chosen (and I mean chosen, the OG fandom has been trying for years to message and help this get fixed) to continue on this flatlining path where the star of our story is turned into a joke and a male stereotype of women. It is a shame, because Lilly is pretty damn cool, but he conveniently plucks that core principle out of her as the books go on, until she is eventually a husk whose only purpose is to be funny. Â
In case you guys ever wondered why the OG fandom stopped reading, stopped being active on the content, and why we only post memes and have turned these two into a running joke, but still keep original Lilly in our quotes, this is why.
yousharknotpass
discoholicmusic
origamiaround
vaporwave
s-u-f-j-a-n-s-t-e-v-e-n-s
pixelskylines
