tate tries to concentrate on the conversation with a customer, but his eyes remain searching the towers of books for the blond head of hair between them. even after all these years, tate’s attention is always pulled to casey and even after all these years, he makes sure to look away whenever he sees her head turn. he thinks it’s silly, like a cliche romance novel but he’s convinced his version doesn’t have a captivating ending. it’s too risky to admit the way his stomach does flips whenever he sees her, and he’s convinced that casey would never speak to him again too. he’s thankful when the customer leaves and he hears her footsteps padding towards him, and tate glances up from the register as if he hasn’t been watching her.
“wouldn’t that make it an order if i can’t refuse? not an offer?” he teases her even though he is intrigued by her idea nonetheless. tate listens to her, leaning one hand on the other side of the desk as he does and sees her reveal the music books he ordered because they made him think of her. a smile creeps up on his face, his eyes getting lost in the sparkle of hers for a moment. “i think that sounds great.” he replies once she finishes and takes the music book off the top of the pile to flip through it. “but we’d have to practice, right? to make sure we’re like…not going to sound terrible.” he laughs and is excited that it could mean spending yet more time together. he begins scanning the pictures about different chords and melodies in the book, twisting his lips as he thinks. “maybe i could make the words rhyme?” he suggests, looking back to casey as he smiles again. “how do you come up with these ideas?”
Casey lives comfortably in her what ifs, and she has no tangible what if that’s bigger than Tate Stanley. He is a what if that’s always within reach, that seems possible when she thinks about it, that seems impossible when she thinks even harder. If there’s one undeniable, completely indisputable truth, it’s that he’s her person. They get each other, and isn’t that all that anybody wants? To have somebody who understands them and stays? All the good, all the bad, all of the little mundanes in between, she wants to share them all with him. Always has, even when they were both just little kids learning their way through a great, big world. But she looks at him now, inhabited with a private awe she suspects will never go away. “You do?” Casey asks, her excitement captured in her growing smile as she watches him flip through one of the books she’d picked up. She takes a moment to rest in her gratitude, to be able to look at him and take him in while he’s briefly preoccupied. She can hear it then, the sweet hum of a melody in her ear of yet another song about him. It’s nothing earth shattering, just a few words that’s too lyrical to be just another thought. “Yes, practice is a very good idea,” She nods in agreement, and not because she’ll gladly take any and every opportunity to spend time with Tate. “Let me tell you, kids are brutally honest, and they are the toughest critics. If we suck, they will have no problem whatsoever telling us we suck. I’m also pretty certain they can smell fear, so fair warning. I’ll tell them to be nice, though,” She teases, though there is absolutely some truth behind her words. There’s nothing quite like getting your feelings desecrated by a six year old with missing baby teeth. “You’d do that?” Casey asks, her heart melting. Of course he would, but it sends her brain into a creative spiral. “What if… wait, hold on,” She says, taking a second to put her thoughts in order. “What if we still read them a book, maybe one or two, and then the grand finale is a story you write about Miss Callahan’s music class?” Her eyes light up as she explains her idea. “Or, what if we take requests from the class right then and there and come up with little songs on the spot? Or do you think that’s too much? That might be too much. Also, I don’t want to put us both on the spot like that,” She reconsiders. It would be cool, but could they actually pull it off? “I mean, I am the greatest mind of our generation. It just sort of comes naturally, you know?” Casey shrugs as if it’s nothing before breaking into natural laughter. “Can you believe people leave me in charge of their children?”