Banksy in Palestine
A cursory analysis of Holiday Snaps
If you’ve ever looked at a train through a frame of metal beams you’ll have noticed how curiously reminiscent the carts of the train, enveloped in a linear frenzy of silver momentum, are to a strip of film passing through a projection light box. The appropriation of this tremendous effect is a testament to the agonizing urban Brooklyn youth of the 60’s, whom armed with nothing more than a few spray cans made true the metaphor of the subway-train film strip. This was the inception of graffiti, an art form conceived in reaction to a New York that had given up on the youth. Curiously, this reaction came in the form of “tagging” - where the artist writes a highly elaborate variation of his pseudonym on a public space with the aid of spray paint. It is a cultural response inherently devoid of any content. These were the early days of graffiti - deliberately non-social. But these forms, like the film strips they first imitated, were not static. Soon a small group of artists branched off of the graffiti movement, choosing to push the form away from a simple culture of visual input based on symbol systems, and towards the realm of representational visual material. This new movement was quick to detach itself from the practice of tagging, espousing the term “street art” to describe their precise and non-symbolic style of public intervention. The street artists adopted techniques akin to muralism, as well as wheatpasting and stenciling to incorporate messages sensitive to their social and political contexts. Early adopters like Keith Haring paved the way for the contemporary masters of street art - the likes of Blu, JR, and Banksy.Â
Banksy’s career began in the early 90’s, as part of Bristol’s DryBreadZ Crew. By the year 2000, Banksy had reverted completely to stenciling, taking advantage of its ease of production and precision compared to tagging or muralism. Soon Banksy became a popular sensation through word of mouth - his stencils had managed to perfectly condense pop culture and the sociopolitical contexts that surrounded it. By 2002, Banksy was pioneering the street-art gallery seen, debuting at the 33 1/3 gallery in Salt Lake, and eventually appearing at the Westbourne Grove gallery in London in 2005. By adopting the style of Blek le Rat (considered the father of stencil street art in France), Banksy quickly became the world’s most renown street artist, easily working his way into the fields of film, installation art, and gallery art, all while maintaining a fervent and witty political tone in his works. His highest grossing piece, Space Girl & Bird, fetched $576,000 at Bonhams in London. Banksy’s most political work to date is probably his 2005 intervention at the Palestinian Segregation Wall in Qalqiliya, where he created a series of stencils with undertones of strong criticism towards Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories.Â
Upon completion, the Palestinian Segregation Wall will run along the Palestine-Israel border for more than 700km. The barrier, known to Palestinians as the “Apartheid Wall”, measures more than 8 meters in height and half a meter in width, regulating the flow of Palestinians in and out of occupied territories. According to Israeli authorities the wall is a fundamental national security tool, despite being deemed illegal by the International Court of Justice. This was the canvas chosen by Banksy in 2005 to create his holiday snaps, a series of nine stencil-based art works selectively placed along the segregation fence. The images are prevalently well-tailored to the context onto which they are imprinted. What makes them truly spectacular is that all of them make direct allusion to not only the wall, but its psychological and social effects on the people subject to it. Many of the stencils feature paradisiacal landscapes framed by windows (Window on the West Bank), or visible through cutouts on the wall (Cut it Out). Many of these also include children (Art Attack, Balloon Debate, Escapism, and Unwelcome Intervention), a recurrent motif that seems to allude to the innocence of a generation born into inescapable (and illegal) repressive conditions. The children look for a way through the wall and into a better life while maintaining the innocence that makes them such powerful symbols. All in all the images are tremendously controversial, drawing attention to questions of escapism and subversion by presenting them on the very canvas that generates these questions. While holiday snaps poses more questions than it answers, the motivations behind the piece are clear after no more than a cursory examination of Banksy’s philosophy. His manifesto, as replicated on his website and a series of publications, is a quote from Colonel Mervin Willet Gonin, one of the first soldiers to liberate the Bergen-Belsen concentration camp in 1945:
“It was shortly after the British Red Cross arrived, though it may have no connection, that a very large quantity of lipstick arrived. This was not at all what we men wanted, we were screaming for hundreds and thousands of other things and I don't know who asked for lipstick. I wish so much that I could discover who did it, it was the action of genius, sheer unadulterated brilliance. I believe nothing did more for these internees than the lipstick. Women lay in bed with no sheets and no nightie but with scarlet red lips, you saw them wandering about with nothing but a blanket over their shoulders, but with scarlet red lips. I saw a woman dead on the post mortem table and clutched in her hand was a piece of lipstick. At last someone had done something to make them individuals again, they were someone, no longer merely the number tattooed on the arm. At last they could take an interest in their appearance. That lipstick started to give them back their humanity.”
Banksy’s work thus deals in the realm of dehumanization as a result of modern governmental and social systems. His art can be understood through the metaphor of the lipstick - an element that both returns proprietorship and individuality to the individual, as well as actively disturbing senses of place and appropriateness by twisting popular icons and symbols. All issues of motivation aside though, his work had a mixed reception. While conducting his stenciling he was repeatedly harassed by Israeli troops, who more than once held him at gunpoint while instructing him to halt his work. The images spread virally, and internationally the reception was one of applause to an event that created an enormous amount of awareness and incited a significant amount of dialogue regarding both the purpose of the wall and the nature of the Israeli state. And yet where the project failed was the lack of local documentation conducted both prior to and after the installation of the pieces. It was an interesting case of exterior furor and interior indifference. A short exchange between Banksy and an old Palestinian passerby makes this point quite clearly: “You paint the wall, you make it look beautiful... We don’t want it to be beautiful, we hate this wall, go home.”Â
  The question that seems to hover over any discussion of both street art and foreign intervention (particularly in the Middle East) is bifold - it is a question of postcolonialist theory as well as of fine and applied art polarities. Can an external agent effectively provide commentary on local issues? If so, then must this commentary (if artistic in nature), live in the realm of “useful” or “applied” art? It is important to understand that the notoriety of Banksy’s work in Palestine is both a factor of his individual international fame and the significant absence of potent (and well documented) traditions of public installation art in the Middle East (relative to Europe, and North and South America). The latter factor is one for concern, seeing as by definition the world of street art is fueled mainly by reactionary forces to oppressive or denigrating conditions. The closest example of a Banksy-esque character in Middle Eastern street art is El Seed, a notorious (albeit new) Tunisian street artist working mainly with Arabic calligraphic styles. I say “the closest example” to highlight the incredible lack of large names in regional street art pushing political agendas in the Middle East. This should not be the case. The Arab Spring is the sociopolitical event that should have functioned as an inexhaustible source of fuel for dedicated local street artists - where is this art? Perhaps the issue is one of poor documentation, but if this is the issue, then it must mean that the art itself was not potent enough to merit documentation.Â
In these conditions, is it acceptable for a foreign voice to be made as present as Banksy’s was in Palestine? The answer could be yes, but then the discussion would be over. The true problem lays in the relationship between process and installation, as process is the main avenue towards useful and applied art. Banksy’s piece is the perfect example of a failure in this process. His very methodology (complete reserve regarding identity, no pre and post-processes of dialogue) makes the holiday snaps series a work at odds with the context he seeks to intervene. Process must exist - if nothing more, to at least begin the inception of movements of social change. Without process the result is unexpected, uncontrolled, and often misinterpreted; interesting from the artistic point of view, but meaningless to the social contexts it feeds from. Without process the result is nothing more than a somewhat arrogant expression of Western intention; art detached from its context and regional roots. What Banksy created in Palestine was beautiful, insurrectionary, and most of all, ballsy. But it was not useful - it was not applied - and therefore, fundamentally meaningless. In many ways, Banksy resembles a Che Guevara of the arts. His revolutions worked and meant something so long as he stayed in South America - the second he left for Africa with the same intentions, the game was over.Â
"The Art of Revolution." The Atlantic. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
"Banksy 'The Palestinian Job'" Banksy 'The Palestinian Job' N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2013. http://www.briansewell.com/artist/b-artist/banksy/banksy-palestinian-tag.html
"Banksy at the West Bank Barrier Index | | Guardian.co.uk Arts." Banksy at the West Bank Barrier Index | | Guardian.co.uk Arts. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
"Banksy." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 25 Feb. 2013. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
"Graffiti." Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, 25 Feb. 2013. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
"Primer of Visual Literacy [Paperback]." Primer of Visual Literacy: Donis A Dondis: 9780262540292: Amazon.com: Books. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
"The Seven Wonders of the Revolution." The Seven Wonders of the Revolution. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2013. http://www.jadaliyya.com/pages/index/4776/the-seven-wonders-of-the-revolution
"Ways of Seeing: Based on the BBC Television Series [Paperback]." Ways of Seeing: Based on the BBC Television Series: John Berger: 9780140135152: Amazon.com: Books. N.p., n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2013.