Opened Tumblr for the first time in ages and what did I find? Sherlock AND Linguistics AND Camus - am I in heaven? :)
So, the other day,Ā girls-youvegotanotheroneĀ and I were having a conversation that gave me an āIām an idiot! A blind idiot!ā Sherlock moment.
She was saying how the German version sort of prevents you from shipping Johnlock, because the translation of āyouā that John and Sherlock use when addressing each other is āSie,ā the polite form, rather than ādu,ā which would be more informal. That sort of interaction, first name + polite form of address, is something that would be used by, as she put it, āCo-workers who have worked next to each other for a long time but donāt actually know each other well.ā Definitely not two people who feel something more intimate.
Itās easy to forget, when English is your first language, that many other languages have both formal and informal forms of the word āyou.ā German definitely, and the Romance languages as well (unfortunately thatās where my knowledge stops). Itās easy to see why, if John and Sherlock are constantly addressing each other formally, it would be harder to envision them ending up together.
So, we had an idea. Weād like to find out how Sherlock is translated around the world, and what impact that has on the perception of their relationship. And we need your help!
This is a really interesting question, and the replies already collected onOperation SyntaxĀ are definitely worth a browse for the question of translation, even if you donāt particularly care whether Sherlock and John get together.Ā
Translating formal/informal pronoun use when one language doesnāt have the distinction is notoriously difficult in both directions. In the inverse case, Iām reminded of a scene in CamusāsĀ LāetrangerĀ where the French reads:*Ā
Literally, thatās something like āHe used the informalĀ tuĀ with meā or āHe addressed me withĀ tuā.Ā
But the English translation that I read had:Ā
He was calling me by my first name.Ā
Despite the fact that the narrator Meursault is never given a first name in the text, this was the closest the translator could get to the effect of the original.
*All quotes from memory, apologies if Iām a word or two off but the point remains.Ā