You just met Sam and Colby through one of their giveaways. You are on one of your first ever ghost hunts with them. All of the sudden in the middle you have a huge panic attack. Colby and Sam immediately stop and Colby takes you outside while Sam stays with the others. Colby helps you calm down with lots of tight hugs and rubbing your cheeks.
I absolutely adore this request!! It’s adorable! Thank you so much for reaching out, I’m extremely excited to help create your idea! I’ll tag you when I’m done 💜
(A/N) I would love to make this into a full-blown story if anyone is interested.
I could see Sam roll his eyes at me as Colby gave me the rundown of today's video. "Aye, Colby... I left the good camera in my room. Do you mind grabbing it?" Sam requested. Colby obliged. Instantly Sam's attention turned to me. "You need to tell him..." He began. I looked at him feeling dumbfounded but before I could speak he continued. "Don't give me that look..."
"I don't know what you're talking about." I concluded. "(Y/N)... I promise you, If you listen to me right now everything will turn out exactly how you want it to... If you wait you will regret not saying anything." He reasoned. I nodded knowing he was right.
Colby wandered back into the kitchen causing Sam and I to go quiet. "Did I interrupt something?" He questioned with a smirk. "No. No... We were just talking about today's video." I answered quickly.
The boys and I played a few rounds until Sam informed the viewers that Colby and I would be playing the final round. In return that was my cue to conjure up all of my bravery. Sam could see the look of concern on my face, So he sent me a quick heartfelt smile.
Colby placed the headphones over his ears as I placed myself in front of him. Sam was in charge of making sure the music continued to play as well as the volume of the music. Once we got the thumbs up I began.
"I like you..." I admitted quietly feeling my heart rate increase. "White milk?" Colby announced loudly. Sam began to laugh as I shook my head no. "I... Like... You..." I tried again feeling my body begin to shake. I looked at Sam who could see my nerves begin to take over. He quickly gave the signal of "deep breaths" I nodded understandingly. "I like glue?" Colby tried again. After a few deep breaths, I stated a little louder. "I like you." This time I allowed myself to use some gestures so all he really had to do was put everything together... and he did. "Oh! I like you!?" He exclaimed. My eyes grew wide, I knew Colby would eventually guess correctly, But I didn't plan what I would do or say after that. At this point, Colby took off his headphones and was looking at me for confirmation. "I... Uhm... Yeah." I murmured unable to keep eye contact with him.
"Is this a part of the game? Or?" He questioned as he looked from me to Sam then back to me. I shook my head as I fiddled with my thumbs, My head tilted down towards my feet. "I'm confused... I thought you liked Sam?" He admitted. I finally looked up at Colby confused. "Why would you think that?" I pondered back. "Because I always catch you two whispering." He returned quickly. "The only time we whisper is when we are talking about you..." I admitted. Colby stated a simple "Oh." which in return caused me to spiral. "It's okay that you don't feel the same way... I just figured you should know." I quickly jumped out of my seat and ran into my room. I couldn't think clearly. It was fine that he didn't like me back, I knew that.
I continued to pace the floor of my room until the sound of a knock broke me from my trance. "Hello?" I asked, Not fully believing what I had heard. "Can I come in?" The voice requested. I could barely decipher whose voice it was over the sound of my beating heart. "Yeah..." I murmured.
Within seconds of the door opening, they admitted. "I like you too." It was Colby and he was quickly coming my way. I froze it was now my turn to not know how to react. His hand quickly found the nape of my neck which he used to pull me closer to him, His free hand was placed carefully onto the side of my face our lips connected for what felt like not long enough, To be fair eternity wouldn't be long enough. "I am so sorry for not reacting the way I am sure you would have preferred... I was afraid... I thought that was a prank." He explained. "I'm not a part of the prank wars though." I vocalized. "No, I know that... I thought Sam put you up to this. He's known I have had feelings for you since the first day we met." Colby admitted. "Wait... How did you figure out it wasn't a prank?" I wondered out loud. "Sam... I would have been up here sooner but between talking to him and trying to figure out my next step... It took me a while to figure things out." He concluded. "I think you reacted perfectly." I admitted as I pulled him in for another kiss.
