He stopped breathing. âSo Iâve been told,â Alex finally replied with a careful move that avoided her getting the check mate. He swallowed and cleared his throat, watching the crowds stumble around as the air between him and Thia remained stagnant. To pass the time he sipped on the cider, once, twice, half a damn cup â anything to release the tension from his jawline. A yearâs worth of unspoken emotion choked at the bottom of his throat, unable to release itself from a countering battle that raged beneath his skin.Â
Alex didnât want to hurt her, but did he owe her an apology? Yes. The venom of which she oozed tonight though wasnât being satisfied with one, not now that he had lost count of the number of ciders he had consumed. He was exhausted, he didnât want to fight. That wasnât something special about tonight, but his life as a whole. Alex hated the weight of their break up, but he hated even more how she managed to push down on it further.Â
If she wanted to break him, she was going about it the right way. âFor someone who doesnât care, you have an awful lot of opinions. Not just about me, but my parenting too.â It was the little jabs that stung the most, the ones that put into question his skills as a father. Purposefully pushing her away, or her decision that Rosa would stay with her. He needed to put his foot down at some point, but tonight wasnât the time. âI donât know what hurts more, Thia.â The male opted for a calmer, more adult approach. âThe fact that I know youâre lying, or the way you keep bringing Rosa into this. Every time we see each other, you pull her inââ
Lowering his eyes meet hers, Alex caught the inside of his cheek between his teeth to slow down the speed at which his mind wanted him to talk. âWe did this to protect her, so why do you keep taking these shots?â Alex asked, breathing out slowly. âIâm tired, Thia.â He whispered, rubbing his eyes. âI canât do this anymore.â Rosa was leaving with Carmen, they had already hung out. Alexâs plan tonight hadnât been to be here, but at the request of his daughter he made the effort.Â
Thia wouldnât know that though, because she had already drawn her own conclusions. Her mind wandered to the most callous of places, thought the lowest of him and it hurt. Even the cider wasnât enough to fully paralyse the pain he felt being around her, âFor the record, you look incredible. You always do.â Alex wouldnât lie to her, not anymore. âAnd I miss you, but I donât want to do this anymoreââ Swallowing through the burn in his chest, he shifted his weight to the other foot and nodded towards the manor. âSo Iâm going to try and enjoy myself with some colleagues.âÂ
There wasnât much capable of breaking through to Thia when sheâd worked herself up into a tangled, insecure mess of jealousy and thriving resentment, but Alexâs accusationâ that did the trick. âI wasnâtââ trying to question your parenting... but she had. Rouged lips hung wide open to let a shaky inhale pass as that realization sank in. Intentions be damned, with each careless jab sheâd done exactly that.Â
And for what? No matter how she felt about Alex, about their breakup, about his aversion to actual commitment, she believed to the depths of her soul that he was an incredible dad. Itâs one of the many reasons why sheâd fallen so helplessly in love with him.
Which meant maybe heâd been right. Maybe she was like Carmen. Selfish and impulsive to everyone elseâs detriment. Maybe she was like her own mom. Because striking out where itâd cut the deepest, where itâd hurt the most? Nobody pulled that off better than Sofia Morales. Sheâd all but invented emotional warfare and trademarked the victim card.Â
Where her mother did it simply for the sake of it, though, Thia lashed out in response to her own crippling pain. It was hard being around him. Harder to watch time move on and realize that each day, each lonely week only solidified the obvious: they were over. Their future gone, and yetâ with Rosa between them there was no actual escape. Some days it felt impossible to contend with that truth - especially when Alex seemed fine while she was slowly dying inside.Â
Thia wanted him to hurt as much as she still did. She wanted to see him seethe, wanted to see him break... if only so that she could believe what they used to have did mean something.Â
Didnât make it right, but she never claimed to be.
Her mouth finally closed around a heavy swallow. Eyes cast for the ground, hands shaking, she did the one thing she swore she wouldnât anymore: she opened her heart to let him another step in, to recognize his pain instead of dwelling on hers, and she apologized. âYouâre right. That was uncalled for, and Iâm sorry.â
Thia wanted to reciprocate his admission, too, but she couldnât bend that far. To admit she missed him in a way that suffocated, to admit that attraction was still there, even through a surface level compliment to his ever-disputed-costume hit too close to the truth. She made to finish off her drink instead, but, realizing sheâd already drained it dry, she just wrapped arms beneath her chest - crumpled cup and all.Â
âGo and enjoy your night, Alex. I shouldnât have stopped you in the first place. You deserve to be having fun, not... dealing with... this.â With me. Her jaw clenched tight, all in an effort to button up the breakdown looming over her head like an ominous cloud. She was halfway to drunk, but she would not cry. Not in front of him, not again. âIâm justâ Iâm gonnaââ
She never finished that sentence. The ability to speak with any shred of composure or dignity had already fled. Dampening her lips, ignoring the burn in her eyes, and nodding more at the packed dirt beneath her feet than Alex, himself, Thia just turned foot and headed into the crowd.