hi! i just recently stumbled across this project and first off, massive fan of what y'all are doing here! (linguistics <3)
but i was wondering if there was any particular reason you've only created the one pronoun for second person, as opposed to separating the singular and plural as you've done with the rest? it just reads a bit funny to me as an ESL speaker, so i was curious as to your thought process ^^
i hope you all have a good day! (and that i'm making sense, it is... rather late here oops)
Hi! Assuming youâre referring to âkeelâ if I inferred this correctly?
We chose this to be representative of community. I have a half finished essay on our pronouns floating around (but as you can tell, weâre all not really into Star Wars anymore) and the section on that is pretty much:
This sense of community is also mirrored in the use of the singular and plural second person pronoun keel. The reason why Dai Bendu has only one word for those two pronouns is highlighting the role a single person plays in a community. As a culture that abhors leaving people without support, and has made it their very mission to improve the galaxy, the idea of a person being alone is absolutely terrible. Their grammar reflects that. Addressing a singular you also always means addressing the plural you, the community they stem from. This is also something the Jedi practice themselves. In Rogue Planet, after Anakin got into trouble, it is not just him that has to attend a disciplinary hearing but Obi-Wan too.
Mace was unrelenting. "I ask again, what was your error?"
âI brought shame upon the order and the Temple," Anakin responded quickly now, his voice high and soft.
"That is hardly precise. Again, your error?"
"To break the laws of the municipality, and. . and..."
âNo!" Mace declared, and his smile vanished, replaced by a stern expression, like the dark underside of a cloud heretofore painted by sun. Anakin flinched.
"Obi-Wan, explain to your Padawan his error. It does, after all, arise from the same roots as your own." Mace regarded Obi-Wan with a lifted brow.
Obi-Wan considered this intently for a long moment before answering. Nobody tried to rush him. Inner truth was a perilous journey, even for a Jedi.
"I see it," he said. "We both want certainty."
Anakin stared at his master with a puzzled frown.
"Explain to us all how you have failed your Padawan," Mace said, gently enough, considering the turnabout in the proceedings.
"He and I are far too young for the luxury of certainty," Obi-Wan began. "Our experience is insufficient to earn us even momentary peace. As well, I have been more concerned with his growth than my own, distracted by his obvious flaws, rather than using his mirror to guide me, so that I may in turn guide him."
Your actions and the way you behave reflect upon your entire community as they brought you up and raised.
From Power of the Jedi Sourcebook:
"When a Jedi behaves badly in public, an observer might think, 'If this Jedi is a representative of the whole Order, then plainly no Jedi is worth respect.' On meeting a second Jedi, who behaves better than the first, that same person might think, 'Does this say that half the Jedi are good, and half bad?' On meeting a third Jedi, who behaves as well as the second, the person thinks, 'Was the first Jedi an exception, then?' In this way, only by the good behavior of several Jedi can the public be certain that the poor behavior of one Jedi was unusual. Thus, it takes many Jedi to undo the mistakes of one."
When considering all these passionate notes, it only seemed appropriate to us that the value system for our pronouns is community based to give the Jedi a chance to express how much they love their Order via grammar. Encoding information about social categories into pronouns is also nothing new and can be found in various languages across language families.
So, in that sense, that but of Dai Bendu is rather artificial instead of following a natlang development, but we thought it was neat
