Look I’m not one to really care about changing someone’s opinion but this chick was being pretty damn vindictive and anti trans. Like, to the point I’m honestly suprised a cis person could argue against that, let alone a trans person.
For context, there are these choice quotes:
“Well, no, you have a penis. That’s what makes you a boy.”
That’s not just cis logic, that is straight terf rhetoric right there. Like… the fact that she thought it important to say this at all, let alone to a large group of people as if she is some sort of gender authority is pretty gross. Especially considering she is saying this on a tirade specifically about trans people
“Unless you say that you’re transitioning and you’re transgender. You’re transitioning physically to the other gender, then you are not–you are not a girl or a boy.”
I have never in my entire life heard of a cis person thinking that trans people are just not a girl or boy because they are transitioning that’s just stupid. Like come on here this is ridiculous.
And you can’t be offended for people calling you what you are
This is what she says after saying that if you have a penis you are a boy and you are just nothing if you are transitioning. This is pretty damn malicious. I mean in what way can “well I say that you are this and you can’t do anything about it stop being offended” NOT be taken in a malicious, specifically anti how said group feel way?
But you can’t feel entitled for people telling you that you’re a boy because you have a penis. Like that just makes no sense because that is what a boy is. You have a penis.
Again this is not regular cis “I dont get gender” logic here because she keeps continuously insisting that penis equals boy vagina equals girl while going on a tangent specifically about transgender people.
You are born this way and your preference doesn’t like doesn’t change that unless you actually transition which in case you are scientifically converting to the other gender. In which case, you are a boy because you became a boy
Here not only is she invalidating any pre op people, who have a hard enough time because for whatever reason they havent or can’t transition yet, but she is also invalidating post op people because the only reason they are their gender is because they “became one” even though people can’t transition unless they are already that gender. I’m not a girl unless I surgically get a dick (and I specify genitals because she goes on to say that the genitals specifically are what make you whatever gender) according to her. Trans women who haven’t had bottom surgery are boys to her, and she thinks that they can’t be offended by her insisting that. And I’m sorry but that is pure and utter bullshit, The slightest barest most basic understanding of trans people tells you that unless you have a problem with them.
There are more parts that really bothered me but I’m gonna stop here. I see no reason at all to defend this asshole. She’s gross, and purposefully openly transphobic at this point. This isn’t something that should be defended. I didn’t care about the art, because it was a drawing that wasn’t attacking anyone. But this stream is really confirming their negative stance on trans people