Brand New Draws a Lively Crowd to the Cabooze Plaza
The Cabooze Plaza, an open lot with a stage between a bar and the Cabooze’s indoor venue, was as full as I’ve ever seen it. For one band, the number of dedicated fans packing the area was unbelievable. People were pressed against one another from the stage barricade to the patch of lawn in back across the blocked-off street. Cars flying by on the highway must have thought there to be some sort of festival underway. What band could have drawn such a crowd? Brand New.
Having formed 15 years ago in Long Island, New York, those unfamiliar with band are bound to think Brand New has outlived their glory days. However, the show’s turnout proves this is hardly the case. The band currently consists of Jesse Lacey (lead vocals/guitar), Vincent Accardi (guitar), Garrett Tierney (bass) and Brian Lane (drums), all in their 30s, just like the majority of their fans. With a cult-following who grew up with the band, most members of the audience were at least a decade out of high school, though several groups of younger fans could also be found amongst the crowd.
As the sun began to set, openers Cloakroom started the show as people mingled about, seemingly not paying much attention as the band droned on. Next up, Manchester Orchestra, a band clearly known by many in the crowd, was met with enormous enthusiasm. Fans joined in to shout lines from “Shake It Out” and “Everything to Nothing,” loud rock songs that livened the audience. By the time their 40-minute set was over, everyone was eager for Brand New, though the buzz began to fade and the crowd grew restless after waiting nearly an hour in the hot sun. After a far-too-long wait, the headlining band appeared on stage and the sun quickly faded. At the sight of the band, the start of the music and relief from the hot sun, the Plaza was filled with a new wave of energy as the band opened with their latest single, “Mene,” followed by the intense cuts “Sink” and “Gasoline” from 2009’s Daisy.
Somewhere between alternative rock and punk, Brand New possesses a sound as heavy and full of angst as their cutting lyrics. With songs that are meant to be quietly sung and then screamed at the top of your lungs, the audience did their part to shout along. The band played a good mix of songs from all four of their albums, each song showcasing frontman Jesse Lacey’s impressive vocals and his sadness, anger or disbelief. “Seventy Times 7” from the band’s first studio album Your Favorite Weapon (2001) was a definite crowd favorite as everyone screamed with Lacey, releasing any and all pent-up anger. The crowd continued to sing along to other old favorites including “I Will Play My Game Beneath the Spin Light” and “Okay I Believe You, but My Tommy Gun Don’t” from 2003’s Déjà Entendu.
During the quieter, yet still incredibly heavy songs like “Jesus Christ,” “Luca,” and “Millstone,” Lacey’s distinct voice crooned the songs’ clever lyrics in a way that felt strangely personal despite the massive crowd. It was during “Luca” when a girl next to me yelled at her drunk and giggling friend, “Shut up, we’re trying to feel something!” And feel something we did. Song after song, Brand New brought back old memories and unveiled long-suppressed emotions amongst the audience members. After “Sic Transit Gloria… Glory Fades,” the group of 30-somethings behind me even laughed about “being brought back to high school.”
Other than the fact that I was finally experiencing one of my favorite band’s live performances and each song was just as good as the last, the highlight of my night was their performance of “Degausser.” The audience swayed slowly to the intro before the guitar melody took over and everyone was jumping and screaming the chorus. The song left me hyped up and ready to scream my way through anything, as I’m sure it did to everyone around me. That is, until the concert wound down to the dark and doleful lyrics of “Jesus Christ” before the band walked off stage.
All bands make their understated exit before returning for an encore – and Brand New was no different. After a few minutes, a buzz of excitement pulsed through the crowd when the band returned on stage, though the mood darkened as soon as the band began “Play Crack the Sky.” The crowd nodded along to the slow melody while contemplating the lyrics “This story’s old (this is the end)/but it goes on and on/until we disappear,” seemingly reflective of the show’s imminent end. For their final song, Brand New built the angst back up by performing “Sowing Season.” With guitar riffs echoing on, the band’s screams melded into those from the crowd and the show came to an ironic end with the song’s final line “It takes a while to grow anything/before it’s coming to the end.”
For such depressing songs, Brand New’s incredible performance made me feel so alive.
lily HANSEN













