What 2000s pop culture taught me about self-perception and nonconformity.
The first time I thought I ever fell in love, I was drinking a strawberry slushie on the way home from school. I watched the icy romance-red liquid slosh around in the white plastic cup, and that was when it dawned on me: I had it bad for Ricky Watkins (not his real name, obviously, but doesn’t that just sound like such a middle school crush name on a tween TV show?), the guitar-playing, hair product-overusing new boy in class.
That’s as much as I’ll say about Ricky, because ultimately this isn’t about him, and now he pretty much means as much to me as a swing set on a playground, except sometimes I still want to go on swing sets.
See, that thing with Ricky got me writing in a Winnie the Pooh diary. The entries, written from February 2006 to March of the same year, were detailed in the kind of cringe-inducing prose only a past self could ever muster. Somehow, not long after I finished writing in it, I lost it and couldn’t figure out where it went.
Last year, after eight years of ignorant (mostly due to having grown up and changed and forgotten) bliss, I finally found it among old pirated DVDs and Childcraft books.
I re-read it, of course, with prerequisite trepidation and expectant amusement. In my eleven-year-old handwriting I’d anticipated finding high-quality cringe comedy and secondhand embarrassment, which I did, but what I didn’t foresee was that I would feel sorry for the girl who documented her days and thought she wasn’t good enough and made something out of nothing.
She was like me now in some ways: She had a small, close-knit group of friends, she loved hitting the library to borrow Fear Street and Mary-Kate and Ashley books, she got really excited and passionate about things she loved. Unlike present me, however, she was unsure of herself (I mean, I still am, but that’s more due to paralyzing cluelessness re: adulthood) and absolutely desperate to fit in, subscribing to imaginary and bogus ideals like belonging with “the in crowd.”
Her efforts to reach out to said crowd (and Ricky) were painfully awkward and mildly disappointing at best, but the whole thing is not anything to fucking despair over, thank the Universe. Fortunately, the main thing that I felt after reading my old diary was relief and this sense of self-actualization. Because although I may have once been insecure and confused about who I was supposed to be, letting myself be defined by standards set by people whose opinions I shouldn’t have given two shits about, I got out of that rut and now refuse to be bothered by the superficial things I used to worry about. By the time high school rolled around, I was under the radar and I knew how to pick ‘em. I was completely socially bulletproof, just the way I liked it.
Realizing this, I started trying to map out how I turned out this way. As with many things, I found that such movements were rooted not only in key experiences and people, but also in the books, movies, television shows, and music, etc, that I was exposed to.
There are so many aspects to who you are that even you don’t know yet.
Even now, One Tree Hill’s Peyton Sawyer is everything I aspire to be--unflappable, strong, loyal, smart, independent, and unbelievably cool without even trying or caring what “cool” is (more on that later). She’s not afraid to cry or be afraid, either. Peyton just is. Minor drug and cheating problems aside, she’s completely comfortable with who she is, whether it’s a not-so-secret artist or a Tree Hill Ravens cheerleader or a music geek-turned-record label founder. Over the course of the show, she changes drastically and grows, and she discovers a lot of things about herself (particularly big are the identities of her birth parents; her mother is a music journalist and her father is a quintessential rock musician, because of course). Her friends Haley James and Brooke Davis undergo loads of character development, too, and they’re all kickass women by the end of the series (I could write essays on all of them, but I’m already rambling as it is!). Still, for some reason I identify with Peyton the most, because she’s got a certain loneliness and angst to her.
Point is: A lot of people can be pretty good at hiding their depths, but the truth is, nobody is one-dimensional. No one is ever just one thing. I decided early on that I wanted to be a writer and that hasn’t changed, and I can be pretty set in my ways, but things within me are always shifting--interests, attitudes, preferences, skills, ideas, emotions. When I look back on the last few years, I sometimes have to struggle to understand why I liked some things I liked and did some things I did, and I know everyone does. I don’t know where I’ll be or even who I’ll be in due time. Knowing this sort of thing can really make you indifferent to labels and what other people think of you.
Fascination is out there!
I developed a deep interest in magazines near the end of 2004, when I was in fourth grade. In the 2000s, the world was so small. So small! It was difficult to find “alternative” anything for those of us who didn’t have direct access to that subculture because we didn’t know where to look or even that looking was an option. I did not know how to use the internet for shit like that then--I was probably too busy doing my Neopets dailies. Long before Rookie ever existed and before I discovered the joy of culture publications like Status, Wonderland, and AnOther, I had to make do with mainstream teen magazines: Candy, Meg, and Seventeen in the Philippines, as well as my all-time now-defunct trifecta ElleGirl, CosmoGIRL!, and Teen People. (Among many others.) By the late ‘00s I added Teen Vogue and Nylon.
Now I spend approximately 40% of my time on the internet opening tab after tab of pages on TV Tropes, Goodreads, Wikipedia, what have you, looking for new music, movies, shows, books, and more. Back then I had to clip out my favorite actual paper pages from magazines and take note of the cool stuff I found. In 2008, I tried to replace the Jonas Brothers as my favorite band (I KNOW. OKAY. SHUT UP.) and went on a massive hunt, scouring my mags for every music feature I could find, making a looooong list of bands I wanted to check out. ElleGirl’s December 2005/January 2006 music issue with Emma Watson on the cover (to tie in with the release of Goblet of Fire, what else?) was particularly promising, introducing me to Sleater-Kinney, The Strokes, Arcade Fire, etc. It led me to this. It also led me to this.
The best thing was getting to see that there were so many interesting products of human creativity out there, that what was being fed to me didn’t have to be enough, that I could explore and play around and have options and see the world from another perspective, and that was comforting. Since then I’ve always lived by the idea that there’s always more, and more, and more.
People aren’t collectibles.
Let’s talk about Friendster. (Then let’s never again.) Everyone seemed to agree at that it was important to have as many friends as possible on your profile, because it meant you were ~*popular*~ or some shit. I don’t remember how many “friends” I had by the time I quit using it, but I do remember going along with this idea and actually getting some sort of satisfaction from adding strangers. Then again, I also seemed to get some sort of satisfaction from tYPinG liKe ThiS and listening to Avril Lavigne, so--Anyway.
In The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants, Lena, Bridget, Carmen, and Tibby weren’t tied together by this vintage pair of Levi’s that somehow magically fits all of them, they were tied together by history and experience and growth and love and words. Other characters came and went, but they always had each other. The first three Sarah Dessen books I read (Just Listen, This Lullaby, and The Truth About Forever) each featured a character deciding that some people are worth keeping and others are better left out, whether it’s because they were made to feel inadequate or because they were betrayed or because it just wasn’t working out anymore.
It occurred to me that it's healthier and the effect on my life is more positive if I cut toxic, stagnant people out of it and only stayed in touch with the ones who have the same interests as me and who are funny, nice, supportive, kind, and altogether wonderful. If you are going to “collect” people, it’s best to make sure you’ve got the precious rares. (It became obvious right away that the ~*popular kids*~ were not precious or rare or wonderful.) I made a point of staying away from Facebook and only made an account out of necessity for school, and I’m glad to say I have a total of 127 friends. Not that I’m keeping count!
Mold, schmold. (or: Don’t apologize.)
My local mall had a music store called Radio City, and even at ten years old I liked visiting it and browsing through the lone CD rack that spanned the entire length of the shop. On one of these visits I chanced upon an album with an auburn-haired, pouty-lipped teenage girl on the cover, a green heart sketched around her eye. Chaotic letters spelled out her name and the title: Skye Sweetnam, Noise from the Basement. She was pretty. She looked edgy. I had never heard of her, nor did I know a single song of hers. Nevertheless, I walked out of Radio City with Noise from the Basement wrapped in a dark plastic bag and gave it a listen on my CD player.
I haven’t outgrown this album. I still listen and play air guitar to it from time to time. I’ve been figuring out lately that I owe Skye Sweetnam quite a lot when it comes to finding myself and feeling my way through my adolescence. She wrote songs about crushes (”Tangled Up in Me,” of course! As well as “It Sucks” and “Fallen Through”) and school (”Billy S.”), but her favorite topics seemed to be empowerment, exploring differences, and not caring about opinions from other people (best documented in “I Don’t Care,” but poignantly, sweetly, and sometimes tearjerkingly seen as well in “Sharada,” “Hypocrite,” “Unpredictable,” and “Smoke + Mirrors”).
What’s wrong with me, you say? I say nothing, I was meant to be this way.
Do the unexpected, or you’ll never know.
Don’t let them know they get to you. Put on a brave face, and you’ll get through, on your own way.
Because of Skye’s music and lyrics, I chose to stop trying to squeeze myself into all these archetypes and molds in a contrived effort to make people like me and accept me. I have been made fun of for using “Norah Silverberg” as a Secret Santa name and doing an impression of Forrest Gump for English class, but so what. The only mold I needed to fit into was the one that embodied the goals and standards I set for myself, the one that would make me into the person I wanted to be, the best version of who I am, and can be, and will be.
Coolness, conformity, and “cred.”
Good Filipino YA exists. You’ll have to look hard for it, and no, not in the [begrudgingly] Wattpad section of bookstores, but it exists. Titles by Marla Miniano and Ines Bautista Yao and Mina V. Esguerra, a couple of others. My favorite example to mention, however, is the 2002-published gem that is Una & Miguel. One of my favorite things about this book is that it’s so charmingly and firmly rooted in the year it was written. These sixteen-year-olds watch movies on VCDs, have crushes on Josh Hartnett and Mandy Moore, listen to John Mayer (of Room for Squares fame) and Dido, shop at Beauty Bar, and wear toe rings. The premise: She’s the harmonica-playing film-obsessed village outcast with a gay best friend (David Levithan would be proud), and he’s the Vespa-driving pretty boy cousin of the resident jerk jock, so obviously they can’t make it work with each other--or can they? (They can, obviously.)
Miguel is reluctant to fall for Una because he fears being ostracized, since she calls people who blindly follow trends “sheep” and is fine with her outsider “weird girl” status, thankyouverymuch. She lets herself enjoy dorky things too and is never holier-than-thou about how she chooses to live her life, and that’s what makes her the coolest of all. When I first read this novella, I was in the middle of my...thing with this guy who kind of ran with the “it” crowd at school and I saw the parallels between the words on the pages and my reality. It made me feel better about the whole situation, because Una never had to compromise and Miguel started being true to himself. (That was Leo Borlock’s main problem in Stargirl--published in 2000 and now a classic book about differences and identity--and that’s why it never worked out.) Of course, my own story anti-climactically went nowhere, but that’s not the point.
I like going against the grain. I like having something that’s all my own. I like pretentious shit like movies in languages I can’t even speak and comedy albums on Spotify and that yellow Helvetica-adorned book by Miranda July, but I also love Teen Beach Movie and One Direction and I closet stan Ross Lynch and I read old-school Simon Pulse Romantic Comedies on my iPad, activities and leanings that might “lower my cred,” so to speak, because one probably ought to be too cool for all of that, and everybody wants to be cool. Except that’s a bunch of crock! True cred is not minding your cred and just going for what makes you happy. Life’s too short not to admit you actually kind of like that overplayed Top 40 song.
No, really. Who gives a shit?
Time to wander out of 2000s pop culture territory: In my first year of college I did a lot of stupid things and got into a lot of embarrassing situations, ranging from botched reports in front of class to falling into a space three feet deep in an elevated classroom. It’s never easy to brush it off and keep going. I still want to wear a paper bag over my head and die (mostly die) every time. But somehow a thought came to me that’s been very helpful in the quest to be a well-adjusted person: People will laugh and think you’re a dolt, and you haven’t seen the last of your mishap for a long, long time after it occurs. That’s a given. But those thoughts of you are fleeting, and at the end of the day, everyone’s too busy thinking about their own stomach-churning humiliation to contribute to yours. Not to mention, generally, they can be too kind (really) and forgetful of the ephemeral. You’ve got nothing to worry about or overthink. And tripping over your own feet at the AS-CAL steps in front of over fifty students doesn’t make you a lesser person. I promise, self.
So, that’s it. Ran a little long, as usual. I couldn’t enumerate every piece of entertainment I inhaled and adored from 2000 to 2009, but I think that just about covers it. I don’t know if this made any sense to you, Reader (if you even managed to get through the whole thing), but it does to me, and it was interesting and enlightening to pinpoint particular viewpoints and ideas that contributed to the way I see and present myself now. And what a relief it is to find that this shy, misguided 11-year-old has evolved into a (still shy, sorry) twenty-year-old who sees through B.S. and values honesty, fun, real friends, and self-worth over mass admiration, “social acceptance” (whatever that is), and fruitlessly trying to keep up with trends.
(I just hope I don’t make Future!Fiel flinch with shame when she finds this post and reads it in 2023.)