any sam gets hurt/tortured/raped while dean is unable to do anything/forced to watch? i CRAVE physical angst
i have an odd number of these (: some are forced to listen instead of watch, i hope that works!
Cage Fight (No Way To Do This Right) by Dyed_Red [season 11, 5k, wincest]
Sam’s visit to the cage is already going awry, but Dean’s one-man rescue ends up skidding it sideways into territory neither him or Sam are ready for.
Please Don't Go (I'll Eat You Whole) by dimeliora [early seasons, 5k, wincest]
After an attack Sam begins to re-evaluate himself and his relationship with his brother.
Beneath the Skin by Varkelton [season 1, 52k, gen]
The shifter took one look at Dean and knew that it had finally found a skin it wanted to keep. This human was someone it understood. Someone it wanted to be. Someone that made it complete. When it looked at Dean’s brother, it felt a desire of a different kind, and nothing would stop it from taking what it wanted…
And All The World Drops Dead by mentholpixie [season 2, 11k, gen]
Gordon does more than just try and blow Sam to bits and pieces and he's a more formidable foe than even Dean realized. Much h/c with tied!up Dean trying desperately to save Sam.
The Hearts of the Fathers by keepcalmsmile [season 13, 5k, gen]
Prompt "Reverse Mystery Spot situation: Dean is the one who has to watch Sam die repeatedly, for whatever reason."
On the Breaking of Winchesters by Lise [seasons 3/4, 2k, gen]
Sam isn't supposed to be here. [idk if this one technically fits the prompt, but it's excellent and it's 2k. read it anyway.]
With this middle ground at the cost of my soul by Biromantic_Nerd [season 1, 4k, gen]
Her hand lifted and John and Dean struggled uselessly against the invisible force that now held them at bay. Dean's lips curled back from his teeth into a snarl. John closed his eyes for a brief, sorrowed moment as he registered how truly helpless he was in this. She then threw them against the wall and pinned them there. "Now where was I? Oh yes. Sam." She grinned as the drawled name ignited a more urgent need to fight in the two men. They again thrashed to no avail.
With These Rings by cosmic_medusa [season 5, 5k, gen]
An AU for Season 5. Dean's said yes, Bobby's paralyzed, Cas has defeated Pestilence, Sam thinks his brother is safe in the panic room, and God is about, but not where anyone's looking.
Wrecked by Lise [season 6, 13k, no actual/consensual wincest]
One step forward, seven steps back. Possessed!Dean/Sam, and the aftermath.
Demons Lie by foolscapper [late seasons, 10k, gen]
Dean never questioned where Sam had gotten this idea that he was impure; he figured it was just the demon blood in his veins, clouding his big dumb head with thoughts. Sammy always did think too much.
Worth by Mumble_Bee [season 10, 5k, gen]
Episode 10x01 "Black" where Dean is a human, and very, very, pissed off to hear someone has hands on his brother.
On the Side of the Road by jasmine island [season 5, 3k, wincest]
Prompt: Back in season 5, after Dean and Sam split up; Sam hitchhikes, thing is, the angels are out to tear him apart, now that they’ve got them split up; they recruit a demon or something to that effect, to do their dirty work. The demon ends up raping him on the side of the road, while or right before Dean ends up calling him to reconcile.
Bearable by ancastar [mid seasons, 3k, gen]
Sam is whipped by Crowley while Dean must watch silently.
Anywhere Else But Here by mentholpixie [preseries, 4k, gen]
Dean loses a game of pool against the wrong guy.
