The Ones I'll Never Write #3 (Remastered)
So Iâve âremasteredâ this one because writing down that little ramble the other day made me remember a self indulgent totally random version of this idea Iâve had in almost every fandom I've ever been in.Â
I still don't know the entire plot, in some parts it doesnât even have one its just scenes that randomly live in my head now and then.
Again if anyone wants to write any of this for real please do, just tag me so I can read it :)
Ilya is an actor. Maybe it's a huge movie franchise, maybe a prestige TV show. Whatever it is, it's an industry where image matters, and he genuinely believes that being openly bisexual would cost him the career he's spent years building.
He needs this career to keep him in North America, he never wants to go back to Russia.Â
Shane works on the production.
I'm leaning towards him being a production assistant or another behind-the-scenes role. Somebody everybody knows, everybody likes, but nobody really notices.
He turns up and works hard. He's quiet. He goes home. He's just... Shane.
Eventually they become friends. Then they start sleeping together. No strings attached (yeah sure....).
The relationship stays secret because whilst Shane is out, Ilya is not.
Ilya is clear from the start so it's fair, "I don't do relationships, I'm not out and I'm not coming out, you get what you get with me and that's it....understand?"
At first that isn't really a problem. Shane understands why Ilya is nervous. He's never pushing him to come out, never issuing ultimatums, never making dramatic speeches about choosing between him and a career.
Then, somewhere along the way, they screw it all up by falling in love.
At some point Ilya ends up back at Shane's apartment - it can be for any reason, pre or post being together.
It's comfortable, understated and unexpectedly nice. Maybe nicer than he'd expect someone with Shane's job to be able to afford.
There's a piano. Stacks of notebooks. Pages of handwritten lyrics.
Maybe some recording equipment tucked away in the corner.
Ilya asks if he plays. Shane just shrugs. "Sometimes, when I can't sleep."
That's all he says. No dramatic reveal.
No explanation that he's been writing songs for years. To Shane, it's no different to telling someone he enjoys cooking.
Shane isn't secretly famous. He's not living a double life. He's simply a songwriter.
He sells songs quietly under a pen name.
He's respected enough that people in the music industry know his work.
The general public doesn't know his face. And that's exactly how he likes it.
He never wanted fame. He just likes writing. He sometimes struggles to say what he wants to say to people directly but this is his way of getting it out there.
The "reveal" comes later. It's an open mic night.
Shane goes fairly regularly. Sometimes to test out songs. Sometimes just because he enjoys it.
One night the cast and crew happen to turn up, a birthday, a night out just because.. whatever.
They didn't even know Shane would be there, maybe its a second job, heâs a bar tender and he sings every now and then if its a slow night to encourage the crowd to take partâŠ.
Everyone is kind of laughing and joking thinking like WTF is that Shane? What is he doing hereâŠ. Did we invite him, is he with us?.
They expect that heâs up there because someone dared him or something, that heâll either suck or be average.
Instead, he gets up on stage and completely silences the room.
He's incredible. Not flashy. Just effortlessly good.
Afterwards someone calls him over and says something like,
"Wow Hollander, youâve been keeping that under wrapsâŠ..â
Shane smiles and laughs it off, modest. "Yeah, thanks, I better get back to workâŠ..â
One of the group is like "you work here?"
Shane plays it off , like yeah, we can't all be movie stars. Ilya is watching this because of course he knows Shane works there but he doesn't know Shane can sing like that, this is still early in the "just hooking up" stage.
The manager or someone comes over to call Shane back to the bar, its busy,
"Shane.... we need you back..." Throws an off hand comment out there like, "Remember this moment guys, you'll want to know where you were when you saw him play for the first time after he makes it big,"
Shane just laughs it off and goes back to the bar, everyone else laughs too, but the manager is like "no, seriously, he wrote that song and a million more....he's gonna be big one day. I know it,"
Ilya just stares. Because he thought he knew this man. Turns out he only knew the smallest part of him.
That becomes the running theme of the whole story.
Shane keeps quietly revealing these unexpected parts of himself.
Not because he's hiding them. Because nobody ever thought to ask.
And Ilya slowly realises that the man he's falling in love with, and damn he is falling in love with him despite all of his internal protests, has an entire inner life expressed through music.
Every lyric notebook. Every unfinished melody. Every sleepless night at the piano.
Then itâs plenty of fluff and happy times.Â
Ilya spends the entire first half of the story encouraging Shane to share his music with the world. The irony, of course, is that Ilya keeps telling Shane he shouldn't hide his music from the world while hiding the most important part of his own life. Because by this part, whether they have admitted it or not, they are very much in a relationship.
I'd need to flesh this out as its not a a âSad Shaneâ story, I just havenât worked out the arcs for them both yet.
Then, eventually, the relationship begins to crack. Not because either of them stops loving the other.
But because one of them is slowly disappearing. Shane never wanted to be famous, itâs not about that.
He just wanted to stop feeling like the person he loved had to pretend he didn't exist.
That's what finally breaks them.
The scene I image is, Ilya is nominated for an award of some kind, he gets the call when heâs on set, or someone comes over, a producer and loudly announces it to everyone.Â
Its a happy moment, laughing, cheering, Ilya very nearly goes and hugs and kisses Shane but the movement is stopped short when he realises what heâs doing. Shane does his best to hide that that devastated him and joins in the celebrations.Â
Later that night at Ilyaâs apartment.
âIâm sorry,â (Ilya is apologising for earlier and them being a secret⊠again)Â
âDonât be. I get it, itâs ok. We should be celebrating, do you want take out?â Shane putting on a brave faceâŠ.
Shane now stops trying to pretend because he knows the tone and that they need to talk.
âNo, it isnât âŠ. What do you want me to say Ilya? This is how things are, I accepted that, we canât let it ruin thingsâŠ. It sucks but I get it.â
Maybe more conversation, eventually things get tense.
Ilya is like, âI donât want to keep hurting you Shane.â
Shane just replies kind of broken, âThen donât.â Itâs not an ultimatum, it's not a solution, it's just all he has left to say on it that night.Â
Shane stays up all night, heâs at his keyboard that he has at Ilyaâs place, headphones on so he doesnât wake him, heâs writing, heâs crying, Ilya is watching from the bedroom door hidden in the dark.
Instead of hopeful songs about falling in love from a distance Shaneâs songs become about loving someone who can only love you in secret.
Think âSecret Love Song.â type vibes, he doesnât let Ilya see any of those ones.Â
They break upâŠ. Iâm not sure if Shane calls it off, or maybe Ilya does because he knows it not fairâŠ.Â
They still work on the same production so itâs angsty glances across the set, people who didnât even know they were dating are starting to notice that they donât hang out and things are awkward.Â
Thanks @maplerosekisses for inspiring this part.Â
Post breakup an album comes out from a popular artist, full of all heartbreak songs about loving from afar, regret, loneliness. One that basically describes the last however many years they were together, as this wasnât a brief flirtation, it was real. I think maybe to Shaneâs parents and very close friends it wasnât a secretâŠ.
Ilya only hears about it because social media is melting down trying to figure out what this artist is talking about in their new album. (The artist is happily married and insists the songs are "fiction" that anyone can relate to and not recently autobiographical)
Ilya listens to the album out of curiosity. He finds it very relatable. *Suspiciously* relatable.Â
He checks the credits and finds Shane's name or usual pen name on nearly every song.
He realises and/or remembers the good times as not all the songs are angsty but also the depth of the emotions that Shane hid because he was trying to be ok.
Ilya wins his award, he takes Svetlana to the ceremony, he makes his speechâŠ.Shane watches on TV.
Heâs thanking everyone in his life, maybe opening up about coming here from Russia, missing his Mom, dedicating it to her and to someone elseâŠ.
âYou know who you are. Thank you. If it werenât for you I wouldnât be receiving this tonight. Before you I could never have played this character because I didnât understand how it feels to love someone like that⊠to be loved like that. Iâm sorry, you deserved so much more than what I gave you. I love you. I hope one day to be worthy of the love that you gave to me.Â
He just kind of trails off as he never meant to say any of that. Shane is in tears at homeâŠ.
Shane wants to reach out to Ilya, but he doesnât, because yeah it was a beautiful speech but it wasnât an invitation to come back. If anything it was an ending, closure.
Ilya is hoping to hear from Shane.. Basically they canât communicateâŠ.who knew?
The artist that has Shaneâs songs goes on tour, thereâs some kind of announcement party - this is the biggest break Shane has ever had as he normally sells a song here and there, they do well, but nothing like this.Â
Heâs invited to the event. The artist is mega famous, getting so much praise and they basically say well this album would be nothing if it werenât for the amazing song writer. Shane is off in the shadows, eyes pleading, donât say my name.
He and the artist have become good friends, they know all about the inspiration for the album, they saw Ilyaâs speech. They respect that Shane doesnât want to be in the public eye but also they want to matchmake a bit.
In the green room of the event they bring up Ilya, trying to convince Shane to reach out,Â
âHe clearly still loves youâŠhe said so in front of hundreds of people.â
âNo, he said he loved someoneâŠan anonymous someone. Nothing has changed.â
Somehow, we get to the point where Shane decides/is convinced to sing at the event, maybe he decides ok fine, Ilya made a gesture, let me make one too.
The artist is performing and calls Shane on to the stage.
âI have a special friend with me tonight, you donât know his name and I wonât be sharing it, but thereâs someone out there in the world who knows him and he has something he wants to say to you.â
Shane comes out and sits at the piano, tries to hide in the shadows as much as he can.Â
He plays a song, itâs him pouring his heart out, I heard you, Iâm still here, I still love you but I canât hide anymore.Â
He barely makes it to the end, heâs in tears, the crowd is blown away by his voice but also the song, the emotion, the mysteryâŠ
It goes viral, Ilya sees it. The comments are speculation run amok.
âIt must be someone famous.â
âItâs so tragic, poor guyâŠ. Who is he by the way because this song is amazingâ
âWe need to find who this is aboutâŠ.they belong together.â
Maybe some speculation that itâs Ilya because of his equally cryptic speech not that long ago.
Cue more angst and eventually they get back together but thatâs complex emotions/plot and I havenât worked that out yet - hence why this is half an idea and not a fic.Â
Songs I listened to when doing this:
And more, these are songs inspired by the show.