Oooh a fic in which Neil is rlly flirty?? Or really oblivious? Bonus points if he's BOTH flirty and oblivious (I've only ever found one fanfic like that so i don't have very high hopes :< )
Anonymous said to aftgficrec:
hi!! asks are finally open so I hope you have something with neil and andrew being flirty and cute, I just need them to be healthy and in love with each other. thank you!!! i love this blog!
We’ve decided to combine these 2 asks, since there are some fics featuring a mix of these traits. Below we also have a list of previous recommendations for flirty, oblivious and cute Neil/Andreil (please see the notes at the top of the posts for further recs). Enjoy this fluffy collection! - S
Previous recommendations:
Flirty Andreil in front of the foxes here
Flirty seductive Neil here
Oblivious ace-disaster Neil here
Pretty oblivious Neil here
Jealous Andrew one-shots here
Cute adorable Andreil here
‘Neil Josten the Sex God’ here
‘the shuffling of cards’ here
This Modern Love by Mystrana [Rated E, 10997 words, complete, Aftg Mixtape Exchange 2021]
Andrew's been bartending for a few years now. He's pretty good at reading people. So when Matt brings his roommate Neil out, Andrew's pretty sure he knows the score. Neil's scorching hot, but there's something dark in his eyes that Andrew recognizes.
So Andrew keeps an eye on Neil. Chaos follows.
tw: explicit sexual content
Natural Attractions by orphicthoughts [Rated M, 20523 words, complete, 2020]
Andrew is content with passing through college and having minimal interaction with other human beings, and he was succeeding. That is until his brother has him go out of his way to stop by the library, where he meets the smart-mouthed, redheaded, attractive barista named Neil who seems to be able to handle Andrew's passive-aggressive quips and fires his own right back. It's fine. Totally fine.
But when this said Neil keeps appearing seemingly everywhere Andrew turns, when he realizes they seem to hang around the same people yet have somehow never met, when Neil bakes him dessert and makes him sugary drinks and asks him to paint his nails and wears eyeliner with lip gloss, Andrew realizes that, no, this is not fine.
Who You Gonna Call? by lemonicee [Rated T, 2705 words, complete, Aftg Winter Exchange 2020]
It’s never hurt anyone. Well, not seriously. And sure, it’s annoying, but Neil has dealt with worse.
Until Jean brings his new boyfriend over and suddenly everyone has “concerns.”
I Caught Fire by Willow_bird [Rated M, 14830 words, complete, 2020]
Andrew Minyard; he is dangerous and vicious and the leader of his own small criminal empire, which he runs out of the private rooms of an elite night club. He is not the kind of man you would ever want to fuck with.
So why the fuck are so many people getting in his way when he's got a hot fucking date tonight?
Take Me Home by 5a5b5p5 [Rated T, 9289 words, complete, Aftg Mixtape Exchange 2021]
There’s a faint huff of breath from across the line—silence followed by an incredulous “…you’re asking me to role-play meeting up with you.”
“Yep,” Neil confirms. He lowers his voice a little, effecting a teasing tone. “Andrew, if you were here with me now, what would you do?”
Neil is only joking, but he’d be lying if he said Andrew’s slight hitch of breath didn’t cause something within him to soar with pride. It’s times like these when he wishes he knew what Andrew looked like, if only to see if he’s blushing as hard as it sounds like he is.
“Shut up,” Andrew says, sounding a little breathless. “Are you serious?”
or - Neil and Andrew are online best friends who have never progressed past talking in voice calls. Despite being an ocean apart, Neil wants nothing more than to go home to Andrew.
tw: implied/referenced abuse
Sometimes (I Like You) by AgentCoop [Rated E, 2902 words, complete, Aftg Winter Exchange 2020]
“I like you,” Neil mumbled, as soon as they were in the bedroom, as soon as Andrew locked the door, as soon as everything was dark and it was Neil and Andrew and Andrew and Neil and nothing else existed in the universe.
Nicky hosts the gang at the Columbia house. Truths are told, chaos ensues, and Andrew and Neil like each other. A lot.
Band AU by @j3mwrites [tumblr, 2020]
are you kidding me??? have i ever thought of a band au? bruh i breathe band au’s
also, i wanted this to be soft, so have some childhood friends starting a band out of their mum’s garage :DD
Andreil wedding by @djhedy [tumblr, 2020]
They get married, because Neil had asked.
Andreil holding hands by @alioszas [tumblr, 2019]
Affectionate Andreil by @colourofmagic [tumblr, 2020]
Cute sleepy Andreil by @augustmystic [tumblr, 2020]