The sight of Jim—slightly flustered from stifling a chuckle—sends a fizzing warmth up Pam’s neck, pooling in her cheeks. The white envelope seems to taunt him from between her delicate fingers, but she’s not sure who’s more affected by its presence: him . . . or her, for getting to watch his reaction.
She bites the inside of her cheek, willing away the telltale blush. Her eyes dart to the stereo in front of them, as if its knobs and buttons might offer some kind of escape from the way Jim is looking at her.
Maybe, just maybe, Jim will be too focused on fumbling with the cassette tape to notice the way her pupils dilate or the way she’s probably grinning like an idiot. But no, she should’ve known better. The moment his lips twitch into that signature smirk, her stomach flips. He’s definitely going to tease her about stealing the stereo.
She clears her throat and sets the envelope on the table in front of them. She perches her elbows on said table and looks at him with a grin: “Well . . . I wouldn’t call it stealing, necessarily. It’s more like borrowing. Duh, Jim.” She rolls her eyes, but her smile lingers for a second too long. “I think everyone here’s so busy buying Dwight’s contraband dolls that they didn’t notice your crime.”
She pops open the grape soda he bought her, takes a sip of the sugary drink, and raises a questioning brow at him.
“Well, are you gonna play me my present, or do I have to do it myself? Let’s have a little office concert.”
maybe if he'd been successful in taking back that white envelope with her name written on it he could have ignored the topic of dwight and his latest antics. instead, jim uses the opportunity, and topic, to try to buy himself a bit more time.
"i have. . . so many questions about that but they basically boil down to: what is up with that? and, do you think i should invest in one of those dolls?" his face contorting in intrigue and indecision.
of course his plan doesn't work as intended. which he knew it wouldn't. he knew pam would see right through it. and he couldn't blame her, if their roles were switched, if he'd been the one waiting to figure out why she'd wanted to keep that card from him so bad he wouldn't have fallen for it either. no amount of dwight shenanigans could have kept him from that card.
another smile creeps onto his expression as he watches pam take a sip of her soda. then his eyebrows playfully pinch together.
"whoa, concert? i hope you don't expect me to sing along with this." he shakes the tape before putting it into the stereo. his finger moving to hover over the play button. "me singing was definitely not included in your present, we are definitely not at that stage in our friendship." a grin flashes in her direction before he finally presses down and music begins to fill the space around them. "besides, if you're focused on my terrible voice you won't be listening to the songs and they pretty much speak for themselves."
his smile falters just slightly, a fresh batch of nerves flutter in his stomach. with all the focus he'd been giving the card, he hadn't stopped to consider the mixtape until now. the card was his feelings in his words, but the mixtape— that was his feelings in someone else's words. and either way, how he felt about pam was about to be exposed.

















