Looking at ACOTAR a bit from a pedagogical angle and societal norms.
If you re-read chapter 16 of MAF, you'll read about how Rhysand tells about his childhood. It's a fragment where it's described how Rhys's mother sent him to Illyrian camps, where child abuse is normalized in an educational scope. We see how Rhys is highly defensive of his mother and her decisions:
âThat, too,â Rhys added drily. âWhen I turned eight, my mother brought me to one of the Illyrian war-camps. To be trained, as all Illyrian males were trained. And like all Illyrian mothers, she shoved me toward the sparring ring on the first day, and walked away without looking back.â
âShe abandoned you?â I found myself saying.
âNoânever,â Rhys said with a ferocity Iâd heard only a few times, one of them being this afternoon. âShe was staying at the camp as well. But it is considered an embarrassment for a mother to coddle her son when he goes to train.â
I flinched. Hitting childrenâ
âThey do worse, girl,â Amren cut in, âin those camps. Three lashings is practically an encouragement to fight again. When they do something truly bad, bones are broken. Repeatedly. Over weeks.â
I said to Rhys, âYour mother willingly sent you into that?â Soft fire indeed.
âMy mother didnât want me to rely on my power,â Rhysand said. âShe knew from the moment she conceived me that Iâd be hunted my entire life. Where one strength failed, she wanted others to save me.
And at some moment, my mind made a connection of how this concept of "tough love" is normalized in the ACOTAR community and story. Especially, it's an interesting parallel when you think of Nesta's story, who also was sent to train in Illyria without much thought. At least, we didn't see the thought process on the page except: she needs training to burn out her emotions.
I think looking at how teaching is described in these books is an interesting subject, and I would like to ask people from the educational field to react with which moment stands out to you the most. It doesn't matter if it's in a bad or good way. Which techniques have you observed and how much do you agree with them?
Disclaimer: This post isn't really structured, more of a chaotic thought train, but I swear everything is connected.
I would like to hear more opinions because I have had this thought ever since reading some dark academia books. How certain types of behaviors are "romanticized," especially those of teachers who are harsh and mean but want what's best for you. And, without a doubt, I can see how sometimes a more rigid attitude is needed, but there are so many factors to take into consideration.
To offer an example, recently I rewatched a fragment from "Desperate Housewives" where Gabrielle Solis wanted to lose some weight. She asks her friend Enid for help, and this way she gets enrolled into a group with a very, very strict regime. Physical training even if you can't anymore, everyone doing the same set of exercises, punishing the group for the mistake of one, and so on. Basically, army training just to make sure she can wear an old dress. And this type of training is seen as good and a sign of solidarity.
Reminded me of TV shows about extreme weight loss, criticized by health experts for promoting dangerous and unrealistic practices. However, the image of someone pushing you to great achievements is more impressive. After all, what can be bad about the idea that you need to work hard for great results, and if you can't, there will be someone who will ensure you don't get lazy on your path.
As we are on this topic, I'll make a short personal remark regarding weight loss: prioritize your health and choose moderation.
Moving on, the examples I gave are very popular in our media. Some people take this as an example of what is normal, and often when talking about these books, people will point out how "yeah, what IC did to Nesta maybe wasn't orthodox, but it worked," or "how good and funny Rhys taught Feyre to read," or "Feyre is actually competent to rule because she read books on geography and history." Things we see in media are getting normalized, and that's why it's important to talk about them.
Did Gabrielle Solis need to lose weight when she already had a stunning body, and it's normal for a woman's body to have some changes? Was physical training the best solution for Nesta, or were there other ways to help her? Is it a good choice, from a relatively feminist world-in standpoint, to make the women train in Illyria? And why is the same regime of physical training and barbaric traditions being preserved in Illyria instead of trying to change society?
To conclude, don't take the outcome from the page or screen as a good sign that the things described are a good idea. This is fiction, and while it means it doesn't follow the same rules of the real world, it does form and at the same time already shows things we consider a norm.
And making the circle back to the fragment of Rhys's childhood: obviously SJM didn't mean that child abuse is a good pedagogical decision. What I see is the idea that his mother loved him, wanted him strong, and she knew he needed to work hard to be self-sufficient. It's also a popular idea in the real world, with parents forcing harsh regimes on their kids to make them better, beating them, signing them up for a lot of additional stuff without asking the kid, sending them to religious schools or troubled teen camps.
We often see this kind of thinking, popularly named "tough love," sometimes with worse or better representation. For example, how Azriel taught Feyre to fly, Nesta's entire time at the House of Wind, Nesta's and the bat boys' childhood, and how Rhys taught Feyre to read and write. I'm not saying all these moments are bad; what I'm suggesting is to see the bigger picture and think more (not about something specific, just think more).