The girl next door - Sam Monroe
MeanGirl!Reader x Sam Monroe
You’re the popular mean girl, a fucking bimbo that Sam hates but loves to spy on through his bedroom window until you catch him and decide to play a little game with his head until you both give in and fuck.
It’s a long one but idk how many words
Enemies to Lovers in a way
Sam leaned against the hood of his truck with a cigarette balanced between his fingers, one boot pressed against the bumper as his eyes roamed the parking lot.
It was still a few minutes until the bells rang for first period so majority of the students were only gathering now. Sam took another drag from his cigarette, exhaling slowly through his nose as he watched the usual crowd gather near the front entrance.
The jocks and their slutty cheerleaders. The girls who acted like the hallways were runways.
He noticed your car before he noticed you from the girly music blasting through the speakers of your baby blue BMW convertible your daddy got you for your 16th birthday not long ago.
Your two best friends were already laughing before the car had even fully stopped. Winnie and Britney, aka your little worshipers who copied everything you did.
“Ah, here we go” Sam muttered to himself
One of your friends climbed out, tiny purse hanging from her shoulder while she fixed her hair in the side mirror. While the other one climbed out from the backseat as her boyfriend greeted her immediately.
Before your heels even touched the pavement, Brad the school quarterback and resident asshole appeared beside the car with that arrogant grin Sam wanted to punch off his face daily.
“There she is” Brad said loudly, like he needed an audience for every sentence that came out of his mouth. Brad grabbed you under your arms dramatically and lifted you clean out of the driver’s seat like you weighed nothing at all.
Your head tipped back with a giggle while your skirt fluttered.
Sam grimaced “Jesus Christ”
Everything about the scene irritated him. The way your friends squealed over it like it was the cutest thing they’d ever seen, those douches taking every chance to show off their muscles. And you, who looked exactly like the kind of girl he couldn’t stand.
Tiny little white top that barely covered anything, short pink skirt, heels completely impractical for school, sunglasses pushed into your hair and of course accessories.
Your purse really was ridiculously small. What the hell even fit in there? A credit card and lip gloss?
Sam took another drag from his cigarette, eyes narrowed. He should’ve looked away already. But he didn’t because the unfortunate truth was…you were gorgeous. Annoyingly gorgeous. The kind of gorgeous that made people stupid around you.
You smoothed your skirt with manicured hands while your friends kept talking over each other, and Sam rolled his eyes hard enough to hurt himself.
Then you looked up, right at him. Your smile faded just slightly when your eyes landed on him leaning against the truck as you seemingly examined his appearance. Before you could give him a smile, you were interrupted.
Brad wrapped an arm around your waist possessively, pulling your attention back toward him as your group started toward the school entrance.
“What are you looking at Donnie Darko?” Brad laughed as they passed by Sam
“Freak” one of your friends added as she swayed her hips almost as perfectly as you
The clicking sound of your heels echoed across the pavement. Sam watched you walk away despite himself and swore under his breath and crushed the cigarette beneath his boot.
By lunch time, it was clear enough that Sam regretted showing up to school all together.
He had his headphones on but only covering one ear and a notebook open in front of him, though he wasn’t really writing anything. Mostly just sketching absentmindedly in the margins while trying to survive the hour.
Then your laugh cut across the room and caught his attention. Sitting on the table with one leg crossed over the other as you sipped your drink and laughed with your friends.
He hated mean girls and you were the poster girl for it, always gossiping about people and humiliating the less popular ones.
“Omg I’m so embarrassed for her” you pressed a hand to your chest theatrically
Sam shook his head and looked back at his drawing.
“Right? I’m like so embarrassed for her” Winnie added
Sam scoffed as he laughed to himself. Those girls had no thoughts or opinions of their own whatsoever.
What made it worse was that you were the girl next door. He has seen you in your room or with your friends by the pool countless times.
When you got your car a few weeks ago, you ran out to the driveway in your tiny shorts and sports bra, jumping up and down in excitement. When you and your friends tan in the backyard in the most minuscule bikinis.
The houses sat close enough together that he could see straight into your upstairs bedroom through the open curtains. He saw you countless times, getting ready and doing your makeup or hair, in your slutty pj’s.
His bedroom light was off, the only illumination coming from the glow of his desk lamp and the streetlights outside. Music hummed softly through his headphones while he half-finished an English assignment he’d already procrastinated three days on.
The light switch on in your bedroom caught his attention as he propped himself up on his elbows on the bed.
You just walked in, taking off your heels and throwing your purse onto your bed.
Tiny denim skirt sat low on your hips while your top clung tight to your body, delicate lace catching the warm light from your bedside lamp. Your perfect blonde hair fell loose over your shoulders and his brain short circuited.
“What the fuck” he muttered under his breath and stood up, going closer to the window
His face felt hot and he ran a hand down his face aggressively, annoyed at himself for looking longer than he should’ve.
You were shimmying out of your skirt, pretty pink lace panties on full display as you turned around so your back was facing him. Sam gulped as you reached for the hem of your top, pulling it over your head and revealing the matching bra.
“Holy shit” Sam whispered as his eyes widened but he couldn’t stop the little smirk that was tugging at the corner of his mouth.
You suddenly turned and made eye contact with him. He quickly leaned away from the window.
“Fuck, shit” he cursed, praying that you didn’t see him.
You quickly grabbed a zip up hoodie and matching micro shorts and switched the lights off before you stormed out of your room.
By the time Sam gathered the courage to peek again, he saw you slamming your front door shut. His stomach dropped.
You walked over to their house and the bell rang.
“No, no, no. Shit Sam you fucking idiot” he panicked because there was no way you were here
Then he heard your voice.
“Oh my God” Sam whispered in horror
You were downstairs in his house. You saw him looking and now you were telling his mom. He could already imagine how this was going to go, he could already hear his mom’s voice.
Samuel Monroe, were you spying on the neighbor girl?
Humiliating, actually humiliating. He stood abruptly, pacing once through his room while muffled conversation floated upstairs.
“Sam?” his mom called from downstairs
He closed his eyes briefly as he gripped the door handle.
“Can you come down here for a second?”
He considered jumping out the window. Instead, he dragged himself out the bedroom door like a man heading toward execution.
He could see you as he slowly walked down the stairs, stopping midway. His mom and one of his brothers were also by the front door, talking to you.
“Y/N came over and she just told something very interesting” his mom said, hand on hip
Sam’s eyes flickered between you and her, fingers curled tightly against the railing. Your face was stern and he was beyond panicked.
“Oh yeah?” Sam cleared his throat
“Yeah, the maid let their dog outside and now it’s missing” she said
“Yeah. How could she even let that happen. Y/N came over to ask if we’ve seen…uhm…” she explained
A small smirk appeared on your face before you tore your eyes from Sam and looked at his mom.
“Prince. He’s a teacup pomeranian” you smiled softly
“Prince, what a cute name” his mom smiled
“Uhm, yeah no. I haven’t seen it” Sam said
You bit your lip to stop a laugh as he relaxed for a second now that it was obvious that you didn’t tell his mom.
“Hey, maybe you can help Y/N look around the neighborhood” his mom said
Sam’s eyes widened immediately and your smirk grew.
“Absolutely not” he blurred out
“What a great idea” you gasped at the same time
She turned to face you and put an arm on your shoulder.
“Come on Sam, do something nice for once” his mom argued
You lifted an eyebrow at him as you shrugged and he rolled his eyes.
“Fine, yeah. Whatever” he said and stomped down the last few sets of stairs
“Thank you Mrs. Kimball” you said politely before you looked at Sam again
He knew you were messing with him now.
You turned around and walked outside and he followed as his mom shut the door.
Sam watched your ass as you walked ahead of him, the scent of your perfume lingering like a cloud.
“Get in” you looked over your shoulder as you walked over to your car and got in.
Sam opened the passenger seat door and slid into the leather seat, watching you from the corner of his eye as you back up and turn the wheel, speeding off.
You stayed quiet for a few minutes, driving with one hand as the gentle breeze blew your hair.
“So uhm…” he began and you slammed the breaks, pulling over to the side and killing the engine
“Did you like what you saw?” You asked as you turned to face him
“W-What? I didn’t see anything” he said
“Yes you did” you crossed your arms
“Okay, but it wasn’t a big deal” Sam explained
“Hah!” You scoff offended
“No, I mean it was a big deal. But like, I-“ he rambled and you smirked “Sorry” he sighed and leaned his head against the headrest, looking out to his right
“You saw me. Now it’s my turn” you said and after a few seconds of his brain progressing your words, his head snapped towards you
You bit your bottom lip and shook your head.
“Right here? Fuck that, no way” Sam scoffed
You tilted your head towards the road and he shook his head.
“Fine, I’ll go tell mommy then” you sighed dramatically
“Fine, fine. Just…okay fine” he said and got out of the car.
You watched him as he pulled his shirt over his head, ruffling up his black hair and making his chains rattle.
He threw the shirt towards you and you caught it laughing.
Sam rolled his eyes and fumbled with his belt before he pulled his pants down and put them in the car seat. He leaned his elbows onto the half rolled down window and liftedq his brows.
“I’m not really seeing you” you said
He rolled his eyes and walked toward the front of the car.
You giggle and shake your head.
“Take it off” you said, nodding at his boxers
“No way, show’s over” he yelled and walked back
“Fine, I guess we’re even now” you said
“You’re fucking crazy for making me do this” he said and pulled his pants back as you began driving
“Yeah right. Like watching me get naked from your window is so much better” you said
“I apologized” Sam said as he rugged his shirt back and reached for the cigarettes in his pocked, lighting one
By the time you pulled back into the neighborhood, Sam was in a genuinely terrible mood. Mostly because you wouldn’t stop smiling.
“You’re enjoying this way too much” he muttered
You glanced over innocently “Enjoying what?”
You pulled up to your house and he got out immediately.
“You’re the most irritating person I’ve ever met” he pointed a finger at you
“And you’re the biggest pervert I ever met” you laughed, leaning against your car hood
“Great, now we can go back to pretending we don’t know each other at school tomorrow” he said, throwing his cigarette bud onto the floor
“Wanna come upstairs?” You asked
He stopped and looked at you confused and shocked.
“Yeah. Come on” you said and reached for his hand
Sam looked around to make sure nobody saw you two. The second you stepped through your front door, you looked back at him over your shoulder with that same dangerous little smile.
Sam was already suspicious.
You laughed softly while shutting the door behind him. The house was quiet, warm light glowing from lamps in the hallway while somewhere deeper inside a television played faintly.
“Parents asleep?” Sam asked
“Convenient” his eyes rolled
You turned toward him, leaning back against the door for a second.
“Are you always this paranoid?”
For somebody who acted constantly irritated, Sam Monroe looked unfairly good standing in your foyer. And the fact he clearly had no idea made it worse.
The staircase creaked softly beneath your heels while Sam followed a step behind you, his hand still in yours. Your hoodie slipped slightly off one shoulder as you climbed, exposing smooth skin and a tiny gold necklace resting against your collarbone.
Sam looked away immediately but then looked back.
At the top of the stairs, you led him down the hallway toward your bedroom, your fingers absentmindedly tracing against his knuckles as you walked.
It was subtle and probably unintentional. But Sam felt every single movement anyway.
“You know” you said lightly “People at school would lose their minds if they saw us like this”
“They’d assume you lost a bet” Sam said
You snorted “Please. They’d assume you kidnapped me”
You stopped outside your bedroom door and turned toward him suddenly, still holding his hand. Up close like this, Sam could smell your perfume again.
Sam studied your face for a second, he really didn’t trust whatever you were thinking right now.
“Come on” you guided him in before softly closing the door
This room up close was exactly what he expected your room to look like.
Soft pinks and creams everywhere, warm fairy lights draped along the walls, glossy magazines stacked neatly across your desk beside scattered makeup products and perfume bottles. Your vanity mirror glowed with little bulbs around the edges.
Sam glanced toward the overflowing closet visible through the cracked door and snorted quietly.
“You own enough clothes to survive an apocalypse”
You tossed your hoodie onto a chair “Thank you”
“That wasn’t a compliment”
“I accepted it as one anyway”
Sam shook his head, wandering farther into the room while you moved casually behind him.
His eyes caught on the wall above your desk. Photos, dozens of them. Polaroids pinned everywhere of you with your friends at parties, football games, beach trips and birthdays.
Sam studied one picture in particular. You sat on the hood of your convertible wearing oversized sunglasses while your friends posed around you dramatically.
“You really are obsessed with yourself, huh?”
You gasped behind him” That’s memory preservation”
“You’re rude in my own bedroom” you laughed
“You brought me here voluntarily”
You grabbed a pillow and threw it at him immediately. Sam bent down to grab it and throw it back at you but when he turned towards you, he nearly forgot how to breathe.
At some point while he’d been distracted looking around, you’d climbed onto the bed behind him. Now you lay stretched across the blankets on your stomach, legs bent upward lazily behind you, watching him.
Your chin rested against one hand while the other traced absentminded circles into the comforter. The position looked entirely too intentional.
“What? Cat got your tongue?” you giggled
His jaw tightened slightly at the amusement in your voice. The problem was, you looked ridiculously good sprawled across pink sheets under soft lighting like this.
“Ha ha” he rolled his eyes with a smile
“Was that a smile?” You asked
“Stop tracking my facial expressions”
“Make me” you laid on your back with your head hanging down the bed slightly
The words hung in the air immediately and both of you paused.
“Or you’d rather just stand there and look–“ before you could finish his hand was around your throat and his lips were on yours
You gasped a little as he wasted no time in sliding his tongue into your mouth and slowly kissing you. Upside down like this, your shirt had slipped slightly, your glossy lips curved into that same teasing smile that had been driving him insane since the parking lot and he couldn’t take it anymore.
You made another soft sound against his mouth that nearly destroyed his self-control entirely. When he finally pulled back slightly, your lipstick was smudged and your eyes looked dazed. Sam’s breathing had gone uneven too.
You stared at each other for a second before you smiled.
“You’re obsessed with me” you whispered
“Do it” you leaned up to kiss him again as you reached for his hair
Sam had no idea what was happening but the next thing he knew was that he was on top of you on your obnoxious bed between a sea of pillows, hungrily kissing you.
But the way you were so hungry for him was mind blowing because the two of you were polar opposite and he was certain that you found him a loser.
“Sam” you moaned out as his lips kissed your neck and collarbones
Your hands played with his hair and scratched at his back as he rubbed himself against your wet entrance
“Shut up” he moaned into your mouth
“Better start asking me nicely you little whore” Sam scoffed as he leaned up so he can get a better view at you
Fuck you were really pretty. No fucking wonder you were miss popular and every guy wanted to get with you. You had it all, the perky tits and perfect ass, the long blonde hair and blue eyes.
“Sam please” you bit your lip as your hands played with your tits, arching your back off the mattress “I want you inside me, please”
Ans suddenly, your voice wasn’t annoying anymore as you begged him to fuck you. He grabbed his cock and rubbed the swollen tip against your clit.
He still had your pussy juice all over his face from a few minutes ago when he was deep between your thighs, licking your clit and fucking you with his tongue as you were moaning his name like a damn prayer.
“You want it?” he grinned and you nodded, watching him stroke his cock
Sam gripped your cheeks with his orher hand and your eyes snapped up to his.
“Look at me when I put it in” he said as he aligned his tip and began to slowly push in
Your eyes widened and your mouth fell open.
“Holy fuck” you moaned out satisfied as your eyes began to flutter close
“Keep your eyes on me” Sam warned
It felt too good, the way he stretched you out.
Sam couldn’t believe your reaction, the way you couldn’t keep yourself from crossing your eyes like a slut at the feeling of his dick inside you.
“You’re so fucking tight holy shit” Sam moaned as he began to thrust into you
He grabbed the back of your knees and pushed your thighs against your chest, watching the way your wetness coated his length.
“It’s in my tummy holy fuck” you gasped, putting your palm against your lower belly
“Yeah? Good enough for you?” Sam smirked as he leaned down to kiss you again
“Yes, yes fuck” you bit your bottom lip as you closed your eyes
He spit on your pussy and watched it drip down to his cock and then be pushed inside you.
He picked up the pace and you began to moan louder which made him smirk.
“Get on all fours, wanna see your ass” he said and pulled out
You jumped up, getting on your knees and arched your back for him, spreading your legs.
“Fucking shit that’s hot” you heard him say
His hand made sharp contact with your ass cheek and you moaned out. He was back inside you and this position allowed you to feel him even better.
“That’s it, fucking let me heard you” Sam said as he pounded you fast
You were completely out of it, face smushed in the mattress. He leaned down and wrapped his hand around your throat while the other gripped your hair.
“Like getting fucked like this?” he whispered into your ear
“Yeah? Like getting your pretty makeup ruined from sucking cock and then stretched out like this like a little slut?”
Fuck he had no idea where all this came from.
“You feel so good Sam, I’m gonna cum again” you whined
“Fuck Y/N stop, stop clenching like that”
He let out the neediest whines and whimpers when you began to clench. Your orgasm hit you and you couldn’t stop yourself.
“I’m cumming Sam, I’m cumming” you cried
Sam squeezed his eyes and pulled you up, bending you backwards by your jaw and kissed you as he felt himself at the edge.
“I’m cumming” Sam moaned into your mouth as he filled you
A few seconds later, he let you go and you fell back on the bed. He slowly pulled out and collapsed next to you, panting.
“Fuck” he sighed and turned to face you
You giggled and leaned your elbows on his chest, laying your head down and looking up at him. Sam swallowed and reached up to tuck your hair behind your ear. Even with your makeup messy, you were such an it girl.
“You’re fucking huge you know that?” You said and he burst out in a small laugh, shaking his head
“What? That was a compliment” you smiled softly
You leaned closer and kissed him again slow and deep. God he was such a good kisser, you couldn’t get enough.
“I’m fucking tired” he said when you pulled away
“So just sleep over then” you offered
“What about your parents?” Sam asked as he got up to grab his cigarettes and open your window
“It’s not like you can’t sneak out early tomorrow” you said and sat up, grabbing his shirt to put on
Sam watched you in his black shirt. He was convinced you didn’t own anything black. He put on his boxers and then lit his cigarette as he sat by the window.
You watched him blow the smoke out and you walked over, sitting in his lap. His hand wrapped around you immediately.
“Have you ever smoked before?” Sam asked and you shook your head no “Here” he said and took another long drag of the cigarette before he leaned in and blew the smoke into your mouth before he kissed you
You smirked and kissed him back, playing with his hair.
“I like your piercings” you said
Sam nodded and remained quiet as you studied his face like a love struck puppy.
“What?” he asked, caressing your face gently
You kissed his jaw and neck, behind his ear and back to his mouth as he finished the cigarette and threw it outside.
“Wanna shower with me?” you asked
“You’re not so bitchy now after getting dicked down” he said and stood up with you
“Just your luck” you said and pulled him into your bathroom
Weird thing was, you and Sam stayed yo until 3 am. Talking, kissing, making jokes.
24 hours ago, he bated your guts and everything about you and now he was smoking in the same parking spot at the same time as yesterday.
The students were one again gathering, Brad and his idiotic teammates were loud as ever and your baby blue car pulled up in your spot.
You didn’t have friends with you today, Winnie and Britney rode with Brit’s boyfriend.
You stopped the music and grabbed your purse as you stepped out of your car.
Sam’s eyes were on you since the second he saw you coming. Your hair and makeup were back to their annoying perfection, unlike the messy locks that greeted him this morning when he woke up with you on his chest.
Your heels made your legs look more toned, your plaid mini skirt that had him wondering how many times someone’s got a glimpse at your panties underneath.
“Hey Y/N” Brad called out from a few feet away
You smacked your gum, blowing a bubble as your purse was swinging in your hand on your way to him.
Sam eyebrows shot up and he smirked as he watched you strut past Brad.
“Morning” he said as he threw the cigarette bud away
His hands found your hips and Sam pulled you into a kiss. Your tongue slid into his mouth and his hands found your ass. Even with heels on, he towered over you.
You knew everyone was watching and you couldn’t care less.
“Did you put on eyeshadow?” you asked
“Yeah” Sam said and you kissed him again
Hw smirked and you giggled.
“Y/N, what the hell?” Brad walked over
You glanced over your shoulder and gave him an unimpressed look.
“What are you looking at, asshole?” Sam grinned
The way Brad’s face fell was priceless.
“I’m busy, Brad” you said and he snorted
“You’re kidding, right? What you’re into emo boy now?” He asked
You rolled your eyes and Sam wrapped an arm around your waist.
“See you later” you said to him and you and Sam began to walk towards the door
“You’re having fun?” Sam grinned
“Don’t know what you’re talking about” you giggle
“Okay, fine. Have it your way, princess” Sam put on his sunglasses and kissed your temple as his hand slapped your ass.