Okay so one of the reasons why the whole ‘Everyone being surprised that Ron was made a prefect’ thing pisses me off so much is because I can think of one very good reason right off the bat, Ron is approachable. Harry and Hermione are not.
It’s no secret that Ron is the most social of the trio. He’s the only one who always has a group to fall back on, to hang out with whereas Harry and Hermione exist in limbo when they aren’t a trio. Before making Dumbledore’s Army , When Harry couldnt hang out with Ron or Hermione he had no idea what to do with himself . When Ron and Harry are fighting with Hermione, Hermione is absolutely alone but when Ron was with odds with Harry he pretty much melted right in with the other Gryffindor boys. Ron is never on his own even when he can’t hang with Harry or Hermione. He also grew up in a big family. He knows how to act around people and for someone whose supposed to help younger students, that’s VERY IMPORTANT.
So he’s social and he knows how to connect with other people and that makes for an ideal older role model. I know we forget this because we only had Percy as an example but being a Prefect is not just a reward but a job that puts you in charge of young children who should be able to approach you and seek your guidance and guidance includes asking for help outside of academics and if you want kids to approach you, you have to first be approachable.
Harry, as a celebrity, would be really intimidating for a younger student to approach, not to mention how public opinion changes on him every year so you can never tell when he’s going to be a idol or a pariah. A younger student would take one look at him and their train of thought would range from “I can’t bother Harry Potter with my problems” to “ He’s a celebrity so he’s probably too stuck up to even try and help me” to “My parents say he’s dangerous so I should stay away from him.”
Hermione, well we know how she is. As a prefect, she’s basically Percy 2.0. I can imagine her trying but coming off too much like a professor which would turn kids away from her. Making students into Prefects is supposed to take away the filter that would make them hesitant to take problems to an adult authority figure. It kinda defeats the purpose when you basically act like a junior professor.
Ron, on the other hand, is funny and social and easy going. He’s grown up around tons of kids and has a little sister so he knows how to handle kids and is a perfect mix between an authority figure whose not too serious but can still keep the younger kids in order. He’s the quintessential big brother authority figure. The kind that won’t slam you with the rules if you mess up , the kind that’s funny and easy to come too. And contrary to fandom opinion, he’s also emotionally sensative. He’s a professional when it comes to dealing with other people’s problems. He knows what Harry and Hermione needs more than they do. Not to mention HE IS NOT STUPID and nearly every great feat Harry has achieved Ron has been right there. Not to mention he acts as a balancing aspect to Hermione’s more intense take. They make a better team than Harry and Hermione would.
People inside the books and out only looked at Harry and saw ‘guaranteed prefect’ because Harry is the main character. Not to be down on Harry, but because Harry is the main character and he stands out the most and is a hero and famous and a quidditch Star, people thought him getting the honor of being prefect was the natural course of action. And if that was the case than James or Sirius would’ve been made prefect over Remus but that didn’t happen. Ron was a candidate from the beginning and not just a backup for Harry. He deserved that badge and the fact that no one , not his best friend, the girl who loves him or his damn family could come up with a reason as to why he was chosen over Harry is quite frankly, bullshit and they should all be ashamed.
There are plenty of reasons that Ron deserved that badge and this is just one of them.


















