M is For Money, Not Morals
BY: Emily Chang, Section Editor
Over the years, China has come a long way in terms of economic and industrial development. Legions of skyscrapers and apartment complexes have materialized, and the air quality seems to have improved slightly from governmental measures. However, underneath this façade of progress and wealth hides a corrupted moral compass, one that has and continues to lead some Chinese citizens to prioritize money over morals. In Guangzhou’s recent double-hit-and-run of two year old Wang Yue, questions of China’s moral standards have surfaced.
On October 13, 2011, toddler Wang Yue was hit by a truck on the streets of Guangzhou. As the truck sped away, the child was left bleeding on the ground. In the seven minutes after the initial accident, eighteen passersbys ignored the bleeding toddler, and another truck ran her over without stopping. Finally, an old bottle collector arrived and moved the child to the side of the road. Despite efforts to save the child, however, time and additional injuries from the second truck caused her to pass away a week later.
This incident has since been broadcasted around the world, sparking anger and astonishment from both foreign and domestic audiences. Many believed that Wang Yue’s death could change the hearts of those immoral citizens. But less than two weeks after Wang Yue’s accident, five year old Xiong Maoke was killed in a similar accident. Walking home from kindergarten, Xiong collided with the side of a large truck and fell. Nearby witnesses attested that as Xiong stood back up and began to collect his belongings from the floor, the driver purposely drove forward and crushed the boy. When interrogated by the police the driver merely replied, “How much should I pay?” Witnesses speculate that, as the driver of the truck that killed Wang Yue infamously stated, “If she is dead, I may pay only about 20,000 yuan. But if she is injured, I may have to pay hundreds of thousands of yuan.” It seems that people are afraid of not only being sued for injuring others but also of being held responsible for paying lifelong medical bills, and may thus choose murder over morals.
The problem seems to stem from a recurrence of lawsuits that has happened over the past few years. In August, a report indicated that a woman who had been climbing over a fence near the street fell onto the road. The driver of the car behind her immediately stopped and proceeded to help the woman up, making sure she was safe. A few days later, the driver was sued for allegedly injuring the woman, and was forced to pay 100,000 yuan. Similar incidents have occurred in areas such as Nanjing and Shanghai.
Over the years, along with economic development, income inequality has heightened; China’s poor has become poorer as the rich become richer. Hence, it may be that in such desperate times, some citizens will take desperate measures to make money. While these individual citizens are responsible for their own unethical actions, an even larger issue rises to forefront. The desperation or desire for money has driven people to turn an accident into a crime in order to prevent a greater monetary loss. And although egocentricity is said to be innate to humans, does our self-centeredness really prime us to go as far as to take from others without substantial reason, or for that matter, commit murder?
Some believe that the Chinese judicial system provides more opportunities for individuals to sue, even without real evidence of the specific incidents, possibly increasing the likelihood of such events as Wang Yue’s death to occur. Others believe that the education system that focuses solely on academia and, in previous years, patriotism, does not seem to cover the aspect of ethics or morality that most schools teach from a young age. Perhaps for this reason, it is sometimes difficult for people to realize what is truly immoral, especially when judgment is clouded by self-seeking intentions.
Sources:
Richburg, Keith B. "Toddler in China Hit by 2 Cars, Then Ignored, Dies - The Washington Post." The Washington Post: National, World & D.C. Area News and Headlines - The Washington Post. 21 Oct. 2011. Web. 31 Oct. 2011.
Jiang. "Woman Perceived as Framing Man Jeered outside Court." CRIENGLISH. Shanghai Daily, 24 Aug. 2011. Web. 31 Oct. 2011.
Herrick, Joel. "In Wake of Yueyue's Passing, Another Child-death Tragedy Strikes in Sichuan: Shanghaiist." Shanghaiist: Shanghai News, Food, Arts & Events. 22 Oct. 2011. Web. 31 Oct. 2011.


