hear my battle cry (flashback) || ivy & florence
florence-wilson:
While Florence understood what Ivy was saying – logically, at least – she couldn’t help her visceral reaction to the older woman’s words. The Aversio members and the Death Eaters were technically the same. Ivy said it herself. Skull, organs, bones. They were human beings, each just as fallible and mortal as the next. But that was all on a physical level. Beyond that, the members of the two groups couldn’t be more different. They both stood for their ideals. But one group’s ideals advocated for the massacre of the other’s members, while the other group struggled to simply survive. “I refuse to accept we’re the same as them. Just because we’re all a pile of skin and blood and bones doesn’t mean there’s value in comparing myself to… to them.” The words came more from frustration than anything else. She didn’t believe them. At least, she didn’t want to. There would always be value in seeing similarities between people, even if they were disgusting excuses for people at that. That was the whole point of going against the Death Eaters, wasn’t it? To prove the value of humanity, regardless of blood status and familial ties? “Because they were raised to think differently. Their entire society is based on the fact that we are different – that Muggles and Muggleborns are abnormalities, mutations from what the natural course should be. They find us to be a threat to their status and their significance. It’s really not that hard to understand.” Ivy’s comparison was a bit weaker than she might think. “If someone’s no good at your bar, you have the right to kick them out. It’s your place of business. You make the rules. They have the power to make the rules, but they aren’t willing to accept that they don’t own literally every aspect of Wizarding society. That kind of thinking – it scares them.” Florence shrugged. At the mention of the Order of the Phoenix, though, she froze, unable to react in any way. Kingsley was a part of the Order. Kingsley, her childhood friend. Didn’t he see how little good his organization was accomplishing? Didn’t he see that there was a better way? “I … I don’t know what to think of the Order. They have the right intentions. But the right intentions can only get them so far. It’s only a matter of time before someone gets hurt because of their inability to act. I just don’t see how they’re making the difference that they think they are in the world.”
Having been around so many different people at her bar, Ivy did understand where Florence was coming from. Perhaps that is exactly why she disagreed in some points, though - the fact that, given her experience with all sides and ideologies, by the time they were speaking Rosmerta had already known people from all sides whose thoughts differentiated from one another. She could see none of them were ‘one’, not at all aligned because whether or not they wanted a final, more important goal, many didn’t see eye to eye on how to get there. She could even see why Aversio was seen in such a guiding light for Florence: as opposed to the order and the de, they fought for humanity entirely.
Speaking about the last one, the owner of the Three Broomsticks had her own suspicions. She’d heard many talks about muggles, some considered them disgusting, others cared more for those involved in their world. Whereas a few wanted an abrasive, radical approach, there were those who thought going step by step was a better way to get ‘there’ - there, in a world without a type of wizards. She was good at keeping quiet, noticing everything and showing no reactions to it, but even she couldn’t keep from realizing it was all repulsive. Which is why Ivy understood when Flor said they were scared; they turned fear into anger, intolerance, prejudice. Aversio wanted to fight that? So why were they so ready to cause fear as well?
“I can’t see it either.” Shaking her head, Ivy aligned her thoughts, made them have some sense before exploiting. “It’s a difficult balance and not one I’m certain I’m ready to be a part of. I do see some value on how the Order act, but… I can’t believe they do think their acts will have a certain impact. Will they help? Maybe. Will they end everything that is happening for good? I don’t think so.” Sighing, she got her wand and let a bottle of water come her way. “The thing is, if there is an organization fighting fire with fire, where is the sense in using completely the same tools? I’ve always thought it’s just as bad to use of fear and forced respect. We know from History this never ends right, Flor. I’m not sure we’re anywhere near changing this.”
Funny how they all had a point, wasn’t it? Ivy could see where all organizations were coming from, no matter she disagreed with two and had difficulties in seeing the better part of the third. Even then, she knew staying neutral was only good until a certain point; maybe aligning herself could mean she would only help from time to time, or with certain bits of information. Maybe not. The war was everything but safe, she could call it a game even - and good at strategy as she was, it seemed she was lacking on reference. “And what would it be? A different strategy, I mean. I’m not on the inside but Merlin knows I don’t intend on giving information without first knowing how and what I’m helping.”












