LOTF ice cream preferences hc’s:
Ralph: Chocolate, he likes the second most basic but what can he say, Ralph’s a simple man. He does tho like to get it in a waffle cone if he can help it but he’s quite neutral when it comes ti toppings, he did however start leaning more into vanilla flavors after his mom passed since they’d always get chocolate together, it kinda hurt for her not to be there and vanilla was his second favorite anyway.
Piggy: I think piggy would get old people flavors like butter pecan or sm, sometimes he’ll order it with the rainbow sprinkles but not if he’s around someone he doesn’t want “looking down on him.” Such as Jack,
Simon: Honey lavender. It’s odd, but it’s less outwardly sweet and poppy than some of others. Ofc it’s homemade so if he were to get it from a store it’d have to be an ice cream store not just Walmart or sm, but Simon ofc isn’t the ultimate consumer, I don’t really think he cares. I think he’s a messy eater but he really doesn’t mean to, he stares off into space and gets distracted then his ice cream melts, that’s not really his fault? And he can’t help it if staring at Jack or Ralph distracts him a bit more.
Jack: I think Jack lovesss strawberry, he likes fresh strawberry the one with the little chucks of the fruit in it, he doesn’t realllly like to eat it in front of others cause “strawberry is girly.” So if he’s around others he’ll just settle for chocolate just like Ralph gets, around people he trusts tho he’ll lowki just get his strawberry and I think he’ll kick his feet happily while getting it. He prefers cake cone to any other.
SamNEric Neapolitan they insist on sharing the tub or the container every time they get some. To bed honest Sam much prefers chocolate to the other flavors and Eric himself even likes strawberry but neither will admit they’re opposing preference to each other so they just end up mixing the Neapolitan together.
Roger: Roger likes blueberry or cherry ice cream but his favorite part of ice cream is the whip cream. Roger lovessss whip cream, if he could he’d buy a can and spend the whole thing on himself, Jack and Maurice. He doesn’t care for sharing with the rest of the choir..MAYBE Simon can get…SOME. Roger might let that slide. He likes the tarter flavors though as Roger doesn’t have a MASSIVE sweet tooth.
Maurice: Maurice likes unique flavors he likes to sample different ones but his favorites are bubblegum, Superman, sherbet, birthday cake. But his all time favorite his banana. Maurice can’t get enough of banana, one time when eating it he pretended to be a minion but Roger made fun of him and Jack ignored him while he did so so he kept his minion antics to himself. He likes to put rainbow sprinkles and strawberry sauce on it and likes to purposefully get some on his nose so that Jack wipes it off of him. Maurice giggles at that.
Robert: Robert gets rocky road with chocolate sprinkles and fudge dressing. What can he say? He’s a chocolate lover. Plus he’s the messiest eater there, Jack says he eats like a pig and Robert just sticks his nose up and snorts at that. However he does like when Jack gets chocolate and he thinks he matches with the head boy and chapter choister.
Bill: bubblegum, honestly I don’t know exactly why and it could just be the blue and pink colors that remind me of the trans flag I think bill. (Or..Billie in my mind) likes very sweet flavors and bubblegum itself is very sweet and feel goody, lots of nostalgia right there. I think bill would get chocolate sprinkles ontop of it but Robert always makes fun of him for it cause “chocolate sprinkles don’t match with cotton candy.” Buttttt bill gets the sprinkles to match with Robert in this first place so.
Sheraton: with a name like Sheraton he’s gotta like something classy right? I think Sheraton likes coffee flavor, it’s smooth and it’s creamy and it’s caffeinated, he needs that to keep up with most of the choir boys energy since in my mind Sheraton is veryyyy low energy.
Rupert: Rupert eats salted caramel ice cream, its sweet but salty, and it makes him feel grown up eating it, (bro IDFK I’m really making stuff here here) he usually will sit quietly without making much of a fuss while he enjoys this ice cream, laughing at the antics of the other boys.
Harold: dude idk anything about this dude BUT ima make some stuff up, Mint chocolate chip I think, obviously someone’s gotta like it and I think it’s Harold. I think Jack has made fun of him for it and said they Harold’s “eating toothpaste” but little does Jack know. Harold doessss like toothpaste, the kids toothpaste. Not that the ice cream much tastes like toothpaste, it doesn’t.
