Hopefully here's a quick one! Answer whenever you like, I'd love to have your opinion on this :)) What would you say are the best live versions of: seventh heaven, kimi ga hikari ni kaete iku, hikari no senritsu, and storia?
How have you been? Haven’t seen you around in a long time. I am really happy to see your name on my dash again (=^・^=)
Phew, that’s actually a tricky question because there are so many things to consider but I will try to do my best!(ง’̀-‘́)ง
Since I love “seventh heaven” and “Kimi ga Hikari ni Kaete Iku” so much I have decided to rank every single official audio/video version of those two songs. I am not really ranking these based on technical aspects (at least not entirely) because I am not knowledgable enough in that regard. It’s more of a gut feeling XD HIGHLY subjective. I don’t think a single person in this fandom would have the same ranking as me. I would be curious to see other rankings though. So everyone, feel free to share your personal rankings! Anyways, let’s get to it! 〈(•ˇ‿ˇ•)-→
“seventh heaven” is one of my favourite Kala-songs but to be honest, I didn’t properly fall in love with it until 2015. Not sure why it took me so long, I guess the song takes some time to grow on people because it’s rather slow and inconspicuous. XD We actually have a lot of official audio/video footage even though I always considered this to be one of their “rarely performed” songs.
Kalafina LIVE TOUR 2015~2016 “far on the water” : I am biased. I was there in the second row. It was honestly a great experience. The vibe was just so special, I don’t know how to explain it. The girls were in a great mood and their vocals were also pretty on point.
Kalafina 5th Anniversary LIVE SELECTION: Slightly toned down compared to the other versions but overall the harmonies are quite amazing in this rendtion from their Closed Premium Live (audio only).
Kalafina LIVE THE BEST 2015 "Blue Day": Not sure what it is about this version but this was the first time the song really touched my heart. We all know that Hikaru was struggling a bit during the BEST lives but she did a well-enough job here, so did Wakana. Keiko’s vocals in “seventh heaven” are honestly always flawless.
TYPE-MOON Fes.: The very first time we got video footage of them performing "seventh heaven” so it’s special. Back then it didn’t leave a lasting impression on me but today I can look back on it and really appreciate this rendition.
Kalafina 8th Anniv. Live Album: A really nice acoustic rendition from their LIVE TOUR 2014 (audio only).
Alleluia Single ~2012 Christmas LIVE ver.~: Another acoustic rendition. Hikaru is a bit too loud for my taste here but aside from that it’s lovely too
~Lisani! LIVE-4 in January 2014~: Probably my least favourite version of the song. I don’t really like the acoustics in this one. And the mic-volumes seem to be a bit off. Wakana is too loud I think.
Kimi ga Hikari ni Kaete Iku
We all know that this is my all-time favourite Kala-song. For most fans this is a “Keiko-song” and while I do LOVE her in the verses I have to admit that it has always been Wakana’s parts that touched my heart the most (especially in the acoustic ver.). I guess at the end of the day it’s a WaKei-song, both of them shine here (which is probably one of the main reasons why I love it so much)
~Yuki Kajiura Live vol.#3 footage~: So nostalgic, so good, they were still babies back then. This almost sounds like the studio version, pretty much flawless. Almost too flawless and sterile for my taste actually, I feel like there is a lot of studio magic happening here~ Oh well, who cares? It’s by far the best version.
Kalafina 10th Anniversary LIVE 2018 at Nippon Budokan: Once again I am biased. Hearing this live at their 10th Anniversary concert was absolutely breathtaking and oh so special. I will admit that I prefer Keiko’s deeper singing but I don’t mind her cutesy voice either (because it’s her way of conveying more emotion which I appreciate). And yeah, Wakana’s voice has never been the same as it was back in the 2008 version but that doesn’t matter to me. She owns this song. PERIOD. (Note: Obviously, I was one of the people who voted for this song to be sung!) I would also like to point out that this is one of the few times where their harmonising at the end of the bridge doesn’t sound too cringey. Usually it does (or they are drowned out by some backing track).
Alleluia Single ~2012 Christmas LIVE ver.~: Keiko is ON POINT here. I realise that this is probably not Wakana’s best delivery but somehow I still love the way she sings here (there is just so much emotion conveyed in her voice). Also, the arrangement here is absolutely beautiful. The strings in the final section always kill me combined with Wakana’s heartbreaking singing. I feel blessed because I got to hear Wakana sing a similar arrangement for orchestra during her symphony concert back in 2018.
Kalafina 5th Anniversary LIVE SELECTION: Even though this version is from 2009 it’s not actually that great. Not bad either but it doesn’t do much for me I rarely listen to it.
TYPE-MOON Fes.: I love the emotions in this one, in terms of Keiko’s parts this might be my favourite actually (which is why I would like to rank it higher) but Wakana’s vocals are quite shaky here.
Kalafina 5th Anniversary LIVE oblivious: Not my favourite because the sound of this broadcast wasn’t too great. It takes away from my enjoyment. But it’s definitely not a bad performance. Not a huge fan of Wakana’s delivery towards the end.
Now we get to the really difficult part. It pains me to say this but I always skip “Hikari no Senritsu” during lives because I don’t really like the song all too much. That’s why I honestly cannot tell you which version is the best. Generally I do prefer their older live performances of it because in pretty much all the newer ones I am not a huge fan of Hikaru and Wakana’s vocals in the verses and chorus respectively.
So I will just go with this super old performance here 〈(•ˇ‿ˇ•)-→
Hikari no Senritsu ~2009.12.27 @ YOKOHAMA BLITZ~
All Kala-fans are invited to share which version of “Hikari no Senritsu” they consider to be the best!!
Unlike “Hikari no Senritsu”, I REALLY love “storia”. Having said that, I still don’t enjoy a majority of its live performances (especially the ones they have done on various music shows). It’s one of their most frequently performed songs and supposedly a shining example of Kalafina’s harmonies but more often than not I find myself having trouble making out that infamous harmony. Hikaru’s vocals just stand out too much in some parts of the song (not in a good way though >_<).
I don’t want to go with another ancient performance (even though I will have to admit that I do like Hikaru’s vocals more in those) so I will choose this one here since I thoroughly enjoy it〈(•ˇ‿ˇ•)-→
storia ~Kalafina LIVE TOUR 2015~2016 “far on the water”~
Check out my MASTERPOSTS to find video footage/audio recordings of lots of other Kalafina live performances.