Pairing: Katie McCabe x Caitlin Foord x Chloe Kelly
Warning: cheating, angst, comfort
Chloe Kellyâs life wasnât supposed to look like this.
Fresh off Englandâs near-mythical summers, with a Euros medal around her neck and a World Cup final in her back pocket, she was supposed to be untouchable. Instead, she sat frozen out at City, the minutes drying up until there was nothing left but hollow training sessions and smiling through clenched teeth. Gareth Taylor said all the right things in press conferences â "competition is healthy", "rotation is key" â but Chloe knew. She wasn't part of the plan anymore.
At home, things werenât much better. A freshly signed marriage certificate was supposed to be a beginning, not another thread unraveling. Manchester was their future. They had picked the house together. Decorated it. Dreamed in it.
And now? Chloe lived out of a suitcase in London, sleeping alone in an unfamiliar apartment, clinging to a loan move to Arsenal like it was a life raft.
"You could have gone to United," he said the last time they fought over the phone. "Stayed close to me. To us."
"United?" Chloe had snapped. "Are you fucking kidding me?"
Arsenal was her home. As a kid, she'd worn their kit until it was threadbare, watched Kelly Smith highlights on repeat until she knew every shimmy by heart. Arsenal was familiar faces, Leahâs permanent frown, Bethâs loudness, KIM FUCKING LTTLE.
It wasn't about proximity. It was about belonging.
Still, Chloe had been wary when she arrived. Katie McCabe and Chloe Kelly had history.
A ball to the head â an actual ball swung to the Chloeâs head â courtesy of Katie, during a heated Arsenal vs City clash. Chloe hadn't exactly covered herself in glory either, full of shithousery and physical battles, but... still.
There were words. Glares. A lot of unnecessary smugness. Chloe had been ready for frostbite.
Instead, Katie greeted her with a crooked grin and a casual, âStill got that egg on your head, CK?â
And somehow, that was it.
Katie was relentless. Loud and hilarious and infectious, dragging Chloe around the training ground like an excitable golden retriever. (âEverythingâs changed, you dinosaur, keep up!â)
And Caitlin â Katieâs girlfriend, Caitlin Foord â was somehow worse.
All sunshine and muscles, an arm slung easily around Chloeâs shoulders, grinning up at her like she was the best thing since flat whites. "Ignore Katie, sheâs just bullying you because she likes you."
They took her everywhere.
Dog walks in muddy fields. Coffee shops tucked behind training ground fences. Impromptu BBQs at Leahâs place where half the team piled in like a traveling circus.
Caitlin would lean against Chloe while they watched telly, casual and warm like it was the most natural thing in the world. Katie would wink across the dinner table, nudging a plate of chips her way.
They made her laugh again. They made her feel something besides the gnawing emptiness inside her chest.
And maybe that was the problem.
Because Chloe Kelly â newly married, newly adrift, newly lonely â was very much in the process of falling for both of them.
Loud, brilliant, chaotic women.
Women who were very much in love with each other, not with her.
She was supposed to be living her dream.
Instead, she was about to ruin everything â and maybe herself â for something she was never meant to have.
âââââââââââââââââââââââââââ
"Come on, Brody, Otis â keep up!" Chloe called her dogs, tugging lightly at the leashes wrapped around her wrist.
Brody â the elder statesman â trotted obediently beside her, but Otis, younger and always a little wild, strained against the lead, tongue lolling happily.
Ahead of her, Katie sauntered up the trail, takeaway coffee in hand, wearing a smug grin.
"Yer dogs are as bloody dramatic as you," Katie teased, half turning to smirk at her.
"Means they're brilliant," Chloe fired back automatically, a little breathless but grinning.
Beside her, Caitlin chuckled, the sound soft and warm. She reached down, letting Otis barrel into her legs before giving him a firm scratch behind the ears.
"They love you," Caitlin said, tone light but thereâs something under it. Something soft.
Chloe shrugged, heart twisting.
"They're mine," she replied simply.
One of the only things she couldnât bear to leave behind.
They found a small clearing, overlooking the misty North London skyline. It's grey and a little cold, but Brody and Otis were delighted, noses buried in the wet grass.
Katie flopped down onto the ground without a care in the world. "Get your arse down here, CK," she called lazily, patting the ground between her and Caitlin.
Chloe hesitated â not because she didnât want to â but because sometimes it felt too easy, being with them.
But she sat. Otis immediately scrambled into her lap, wriggling like heâs five pounds instead of fifty.
Katie snickered. Caitlin cooed, "Good boy, Otis," and ruffled his fur, so natural and familiar that Chloe's chest ached.
"You know," Katie said after a while, voice unusually casual, "you and the boys could move in."
Katie shrugged, tossing a twig Brody's way. "Our place is massive. Coopurrâll have to learn to deal with some dog drama, but heâs a tough little bastard."
"Plus," Caitlin added, smiling softly, "I miss having a dog around."
And suddenly Chloe remembers â Peach.
The way Caitlin went quiet whenever someone mentioned the winter break. The way she still paused whenever she walked past the empty hooks where a leash used to hang.
Peach, who had been Caitlinâs shadow until January.
"You donât have to decide now," Caitlin said quickly, reading her face. "Just... it's home, if you want it to be."
Brody pressed his head against Chloeâs knee. Otis nosed at her hand, impatient for another cuddle.
Chloe looked at Katieâs crooked smile, Caitlinâs steady kindness, her two dogs sprawled like they own the place.
And for the first time in months, she didnât feel like sheâs drowning.
"Yeah," Chloe said, voice rough around the edges.
Katie bumped her shoulder. Caitlin looped an arm around her back â casual, safe.
And Chloe leaned into them, just a little, pretending she didnât feel like she's already halfway home.
âââââââââââââââââââââââââââ
It started with Brody whining at the door.
Chloe shushed him gently, curled into the far end of the sofa with Otis snoring against her thigh, one hand mindlessly stroking soft fur.
She was not ready to move yet. Not ready to check her phone.
Not ready for anything outside this tiny, fragile world she had been borrowing.
The house smelled like them â Katieâs coffee, Caitlinâs lavender laundry detergent, the faint lingering trace of Coopurr prowling somewhere upstairs.
Brody whined again, more insistent. Chloe buried her face in Otis' fur.
Her phone buzzed on the coffee table. Again. And again.
Chloeâs chest tightened.
She knew she should answer.
Knew she should explain why she hasnât come home on her free day, why sheâs here instead, wrapped in someone else's life, someone else's warmth.
But what would she even say?
âSorry, Iâm busy falling in love with two women who arenât mine?â
âSorry, I donât know who I am anymore?â
Katie strolled in first, tossing her keys onto the counter with a familiar clatter. Caitlin followed, carrying bags from the corner shop, swinging one into Chloeâs lap with a grin.
"Got your crisps, Chlo," Caitlin said brightly, pulling off her jacket. "And a cheeky beer."
Chloe forced a smile. Takes the bag.
Katie frowned, instantly alert. "You alright?"
Brody pressed harder against Chloe's leg, whining low.
Otis lifted his head, sensing it too.
"I'm fine," Chloe said, too fast. Too sharp.
Katie didnât buy it. Neither did Caitlin.
Katie crossed the room in three strides, crouching in front of her.
"Chloe," she said, voice soft and careful. "Talk to us."
Something inside Chloe snapped.
Maybe it was the missed calls. Maybe it was Brodyâs worry. Maybe it was the way Caitlin was looking at her like she had already forgiven anything she hadnât even confessed yet.
"You don't get it," Chloe said, voice shaking.
"Iâm not supposed to be here. Iâm not supposed to..."
She stopped herself before too late.
Katieâs eyes narrowed. Caitlin stepped closer, frowning.
"Not supposed to what?" Caitlin asked, gentle, but Chloe could hear the hurt bleeding through.
Chloe shoved the bag away, standing up too quickly.
Otis yelped at the sudden movement.
"Fall in love with you," Chloe spat, wrecked and furious at herself, not them.
The silence was deafening.
Katie straightened slowly, mouth open like she was trying to find the right words but kept losing them.
Caitlin just stared at her, wide-eyed, heartbreak written clear as day.
"And Iâm married," Chloe finished, a broken, helpless whisper. "Iâm fucking married."
The words hang there, ugly and irreversible.
Her phone buzzed again, vibrating violently against the coffee table like it was accusing her too.
Brody whined. Otis barked once, sharp.
Katie stepped back like sheâs been hit. Caitlin reached for her hand without thinking â a reflex â and Chloe felt the ache in her bones.
"Chloe..." Caitlin started, soft and pained.
But Chloe was already grabbing Brodyâs leash, fumbling with Otisâ collar, anything to move, to run before they say something kind, something that might shatter her completely.
"I need to go," she muttered, voice cracking.
She didnât look at them.
She was out the door before they could stop her, two confused dogs tugging at their leads, the grey London sky swallowing her whole.
And she didnât stop running â not even when the first tear fell.
âââââââââââââââââââââââââââ
The final whistle blew, and Chloe dropped to her knees.
The stadium roared around her â Arsenal fans chanting, clapping, pounding the air â but all Chloe could hear was the ragged sound of her own breathing.
She hauled herself up, blinking sweat from her eyes just as Caitlin crashed into her, arms flung wide, laughter bubbling out of her.
"You were unreal," Caitlin beamed, practically bouncing.
Katie was right behind her, a breathless grin splitting her face.
"Fucking hell, CK. Didnât know you had that in you."
Chloe laughed â sharp and wild â letting herself be sandwiched between them for a second longer than strictly professional.
Like breathing again after weeks underwater.
But as the cheers fade, replaced by the low hum of post-match logistics, the three of them stood there â sweating, battered, vibrating with adrenaline â and the other thing settled back between them.
Katie was the first to crack.
She jerked her head toward the tunnel. "Come on. Weâre talking."
Chloe followed without protest, Caitlin was a quiet, steady presence at her side.
They found a tucked-away hallway, cool and dim and blessedly empty.
Katie turned on her the moment they stop.
"You canât fucking do that to us again," she said, not shouting, but fierce.
"You donât get to kiss us with your eyes," Katie growled, voice shaking, "and run away like it meant nothing."
Caitlin stepped in, gentler but no less determined.
"Weâre not mad you feel something," she said, quiet. "Weâre mad you think youâre not allowed."
Chloe shook her head, arms wrapped around herself.
"Iâm married," she whispered, and the words sound hollow now. Weak.
Caitlin took another step closer, voice soft but unyielding.
The truth sat heavy on her tongue.
"I donât know who I am anymore," she confessed finally.
Katie blew out a breath, some of her fury bleeding out.
"Then start here," Caitlin said, simply, "With us."
Katieâs eyes â fierce, bright â met hers without flinching.
Caitlinâs hand hovered, not touching, waiting for Chloe to choose.
And for the first time in months, Chloe didnât feel like she was drowning.
"I donât know if I can fix everything," she said, raw with emotion.
"I donât even know what I want half the time."
Katieâs mouth quirked in a tired grin.
"Welcome to the fucking club, mate."
Caitlin laughed â soft and real â and finally, finally, Chloe felt the tension ease out of her body.
She stepped forward, lets Caitlinâs hand land on her hip, feels Katieâs shoulder bump against hers in that clumsy, perfect way.
"Okay," Chloe said, voice breaking and sure all at once.
Katie threw an arm around her shoulders, pulling her into a one-armed hug thatâs rough and careful at the same time.
Caitlin pressed their foreheads together for a second, a touch full of messy promises.
Not everything was solved.
Not everything was healed.
But for the first time â maybe ever â Chloe knew she's not alone.
âââââââââââââââââââââââââââ
The end of Chloeâs marriage didnât come with fireworks.
No screaming, no final dramatic fight.
the missed calls, the cold silences, the "why are you so far away" arguments that stopped being about geography a long time ago.
When she traveled back to Manchester during the break, it was already too late.
He looked at her across the dinner table like he didnât know her anymore.
She looks back, realizing she didnât neither.
There was no villain here. Just two people who wanted to be happy and got lost along the way.
They didnât even fight about it.
And somehow, that hurt even worse.
âââââââââââââââââââââââââââ
Back at Arsenal, the tension didnât exactly... stay hidden.
Chloe was quieter. Lighter, somehow, but heavier at the same time.
Katie hovered near her in the gym like she might punch anyone who asks the wrong question.
Caitlin slipt her energy bars between drills, brushes Chloeâs fingers with hers, casual and secret.
The rest of the team noticed something, but couldnât quite pin it down.
Beth side-eyed Chloe once in the cafeteria, muttered to Lotte, "Did she always get that clingy with Caitlin and Katie?"
Alessia â bless her heart â whispered loud enough for half the table to hear, "Maybe they just really clicked?â
Frida shrugged like she couldn't care less.
Lia WĂ€lti â still impossibly calm, sipping her coffee, watching Chloe, Katie, and Caitlin with the lazy amusement of someone whoâs been there, done that, bought the heartbreak t-shirt.
She caught Chloeâs eye across the room one day â
gave her the smallest, most knowing smile.
Youâre allowed. Youâre seen. Itâs okay.
Chloe nearly choked on her electrolytes.
âââââââââââââââââââââââââââ
Some days Chloe still wakes up twisted in old guilt.
Still picks up her phone and scrolls through old messages she doesnât know how to answer.
Most mornings are softer.
She wakes tangled between Katieâs fierce warmth and Caitlinâs sunlit sweetness, Brody snoring against her hip, Otis sprawled across Caitlinâs legs, Coopurr perched resentfully on the headboard like heâs judging everyone.
Katie always wakes up first â always grumpy, always muttering â and presses her face into Chloeâs hair with a gruff, sleepy grunt.
Caitlin stirs next, slinging an arm across both of them with the lazy strength of someone whoâs spent a lifetime throwing herself into things without fear.
Chloe stays still in those moments.
Feels the way the ache in her chest finally eases.
Itâs messy. Itâs complicated. Itâs nothing she ever planned for.
And this time, sheâs not running.