An Ex-Catholic’s Wager, or No Binary Can Hold Me, Including the Binary of Belief/Unbelief
Two years since the last time
I stepped foot in a church, my friend asked me,
“Do you still believe in God?”
What an interesting question.
There is nuance to belief,
I wanted to tell her,
And belief
Is not the same thing as worship.
Like Pascal, let me lay out my wager.
Belief and unbelief, my lack of worship;
Even when I gain I lose.
God is, and is, and is, and is not
A church pew, a forest,
A father, a stranger, an asshole,
A street corner, a far-away star.
I believe in four choices.
Choice One:
If God is like the god of my childhood,
Then he can eat my entire ass and balls.
I was raised to love a god who hated me,
Raised to love the sting of fear,
To breathe in the incense and the candle smoke
And feel the hunger
Lightheaded inside of me, and call that holy.
I was raised to love pain,
To pour myself out onto the plate to be a sacrifice,
And I would walk, knowingly and gladly, into hell
Rather than worship that thing that almost killed me.
And I think I’d be right to.
If the god of my childhood exists,
He’s an abusive asshole,
And I want him to lose my number.
Choice Two:
If God is like the god of my adolescence,
Then God is a complicated, numinous,
And multivalent thing
Shining through the cracks
In our universe like a star.
God is the contradictory, diverse Infinite
That we're all already looking for.
The capital-t Truth,
A sun with a thousand different planets,
A star with a hundred thousand points,
And what I’m doing now
Isn’t any better or more imperfect a way to worship God
Than anything else.
If the God of my adolescence exists (in any comprehensible way),
Then he knows why I had to leave.
Choice Three:
Or maybe the Truth really is multivalent.
Maybe God isn’t just one thing,
And there are as many different spirits
In the wild, teaming universe
As there are blades of grass,
Not one path but a thousand thousand, curling
Through the rich, wild
Insect-bitten and overgrown forest.
Maybe each tree is holy,
And the river that sings does not sing
With another god’s voice, but with its own
And the gods are just as many and as different
As anything else.
If God is just one of many,
Then I choose a different path.
Choice Four:
And if God does not exist,
Then all we have
Is this one life, right now, that we’re living.
There is no perfect life,
No perfect Truth besides the stuff in front of us.
Doesn’t that make us
The most important fucking thing in the whole universe?
Doesn’t that make every person
And every empty parking lot and street corner
Unbearably precious?
And brief?
If there is no God, then I won’t
Spend my one life on my knees,
Small and waiting to be struck down.
I’ll spend it as whole as I can be,