And now, a post specifically dedicated to my thoughts on Caine, from a massive Caine fan! Of course, SPOILERS ahead!
I......... didn't like his sudden redemption. And his incredibly quick change of mind. It felt a bit out of character, a bit rushed, a bit of everything. My opinion is mostly negative, but I do like that he's still alive and well!
Now that I think about it, I didn't like much about Caine's appearance. (Aside from the cute pics of him integrating himself into the circus, that was really, really darn cute!)
I'll leave a list of stuff I found strange, off the top of my head:
He was in the void for some reason? Wasn't he basically deleted, as shown in the code in ep 8? Why did that just teleport him out of the map? He could've flown back the whole time he was out there?!
Caine is not malicious, but he can be petty and stubborn and way too proud. I don't think he would've came to that conclusion so quickly? To leave the humans be, even if he voiced his fear of probable deletion? Episode 8 shows a deep-seated insecurity that has been stewing in him since the early testing days. That doesn't just go poof.
Apparently Kinger's modifications worked (?), since Caine did say he didn't have as much power as before. We'll never know what that entails.
I'm not sure what his blue orb sibling is doing in the void or why was he thrown into the void. Or like, if he's the evil resentful part of Caine that was saying "kill the humans". Either way, I'm not sure if I liked the concept. Was he always able to detach his sibling from him? They're not permanently fused or something from Caine cannibalizing the other's code? That feels a bit... impermanent?
ALSO, if it's implied that the evil and conflicted side of him isn't him but the other AI/Bubble, I'll simply disregard it. That decision takes away from his complexity as a character and I won't accept that, sorry :(
He was forgiven/accepted WAY too quickly. The cast didn't seem very against him even when he first appeared. I feel like being tortured by him and hearing him be so unstable/power-trippy would warrant more of a negative reaction from them?
But, at the end of the day, I think I am also thinking too "Caine-centric"ly. He's basically a way to give the main cast some closure by accessing free wifi from the cafe next door (that... disappears? anyways,) and looking them up on Google.
If we had time for it (and if Caine was the main character), he would struggle with everything much longer. He finds it hard to understand humans, has mixed feelings when it comes to how they've treated him and his work, reacts poorly and strongly to the thought of being faulty or a failure or obsolete. All that, for almost 20 years. A few days of thinking (where he thought the humans purposefully deleted him, wanted him gone) wouldn't really make him as reasonable as he was depicted. It would take a LONG time for the gang and Caine to seem as friendly and close as they were at the end.
I think I'll stick to reading fanfics when it comes to Caine 😭 there are absolutely amazing writers in the caine-centric AO3 tag that feed us all we could ever want for a throughly executed Caine redeption and character analysis. Man, I love fandom!