Quiz Time - B99 Edition! What kind of Logical Fallacies are these statements?
Capt. Holt vs John Kelly
When John Kelly asks people to vote for him as Police Commissioner instead of Captain Holt, he tells them that they are either on his side in making streets safer or on the side of letting crime and wrongdoing prevail.
Lt. Terry Jeffords and the Leaked Crime Statistics
After Gina Linetti posits that nobody could have leaked the data because they were kept in the archives, Lt. Jeffords points out that Gina may have leaked the crime statistics herself by accident because she didn't take her work seriously.
Overcrowding
Detective Rosa Diaz says that ever since the uniformed officers moved up to the bullpen, the elevator smells terrible and the kitchen and bathroom are incredibly nasty. She says that the "downstairs" people have ruined their lives ever since they moved.
Detective Jake Peralta and Desk Duty
Detective Jake Peralta asks Capt. Holt to take him off desk duty because he's ready to get back to work. Capt. Holt tells him that such is the protocol for anyone experiencing a traumatizing work lapse and Detective Rosa Diaz had no qualms about taking a break from field work especially after being wrongfully imprisoned like Jake. Jake responds saying, "So what? Am I supposed to follow everything that Rosa does? What if Rosa jumps off a cliff?"
Detective my Santiago and the Sergeant Exam
Amy was spiralling. She says that if she doesn't pass the sergeant exam, she won't be able to take it for another five years which means her entire life calendar will be disrupted and everything will fall apart so she won't be able to have the right time to get married, have kids, and her parents will never be proud of her and she will never be the youngest detective to become a sergeant in NYPD history ever again. Her life is ruined.
What are your guesses? Drop them down in the comments below!
1. false dilemma/dichotomy
2. ad hominem
3. false causation/post hoc ergo propter hoc
4. circular reasoning
5. slippery slope
Hi Nicole! here are my answers!!
1. False dilemma
2. Ad hominem
3. Post hoc ergo propter hoc
4. Straw man
5. Slippery slope













