Squarespace vs. Wix vs. WordPress: Which is the lesser of all evils?
For the past few months I have been curating my work and building my portfolio. Like many interactive media professionals are advised, having one digitally is an automatic assumption. With little experience coding for the web, I was exposed to three platforms that on the surface appeared to be viable options – WordPress, Squarespace and Wix. This post will be centered on my experience and experimentation with all three platforms while trying to create my web portfolio.
First, let me define my needs. As a graphic designer, passionate about UX design and storytelling, my portfolio was going to be diverse. I wanted something that said “Digital Consultant” yet still highlighted my skills. I wanted something clean, simple, and visually intriguing. But, I also wanted something that embraced the art of storytelling. I needed something user friendly. I didn’t want to spend most of my time figuring out how to use the platform when I should be designing my site. I wanted something with beautiful templates that are both customizable and responsive to multiple devices. I wanted a platform that supported me in the middle of the night when I’m trying to figure out why my site is broken. Above all, as a student, “ballin’ on a student budget,” I needed something affordable. As a result, my experience and ultimate decision was based on these four criteria: ease of use, template design, customer support and cost.
I have been trained in WordPress.org and so I naturally thought that this would be the platform to host my portfolio. I had already installed the software on my computer and had a rough portfolio etched out from class assignments. For the most part, it was user friendly, and offered a ton of plugins to play with. I was comfortable with the platform and there were so many free and paid templates to choose from. But then the templates… In WordPress, templates are called themes. WordPress themes have a way of looking like “WordPress themes.” As a platform used by many Fortune 500 companies, it is not necessarily an insult, but I wanted a more authentic look that represents who I am. So this meant I would need to customize my code to truly feel authentic. However, the process is an investment and is ideal for someone who is fluent in HTML, CSS and Javascript, at the least. Moreover, not all themes were responsive or responded to customized code. To add to that, if the creator updated a theme and you updated the theme on your platform, you’re site could potentially break.
Feeling unsure about my platform selection, some collegues recommended I check out Wix and Squarespace. Starting with Wix, I loved the fact that I had so many templates to choose from. What I didn’t love was my inability to change templates once selected, if I wanted to. Content was not transferable and there was no way to apply customized CSS. Furthermore, while Wix has an easy-to-use mobile editor, none of the templates are made mobile ready. In the end, I felt overwhelmed by Wix’s interface, and I found the workspace too limiting for what I had envisioned.
In contrast, Squarespace offered far less selection with their templates. However, these templates were beautifully designed with rich features and mobile ready. In additional, I can apply custom CSS to any design. The imagery, font styles and layouts were clean and simple yet bold. And, I loved how uncluttered the workspace appeared.
In regards to blogging, WordPress and Squarespace are equipped with great content management systems. Having used both, I feel they are both easy to use. While WordPress offers more features in their CMS, the overall experience was comparable.
For WordPress, hosting was not included and so that would be the only cost I would have to incur. On the other hand, Squarespace and Wix offered packages that included hosting and I found their prices to be quite competitive and economical. Wix also offers a free version aside from four paid packages, which are discounted on a yearly plan. Note that Wix’s free for a lifetime service includes displaying a permanent ad and use of their subdomain. While Squarespace has no free plans, you can use it for 14 days free of charge. With plans starting at $7/month, the choice rested solely on the type of website.
In terms of customer support, all platforms have been praised for their assistance. In my experience, I noticed differences that ultimately made me feel differently. With WordPress, they have a great online community for support but I found the support on particular themes to vary depending on age and popularity. This is a pain point especially after committing hours to customizing a theme you may not be able to work with in the end. Offering premium help, Squarespace support includes tutorials, live chat and email support – it’s just unfortunate that it is difficult to find help when you’re in your workspace. By far, the Wix support is friendlier to its audience with their built-in help engine on each editable element in the control panel. In addition to that they are equipped with videos, how to articles and a community forum.
Decisions, Decisions, Decisions.
I chose Squarespace. While I could have saved a couple dollars monthly with Wix or WordPress, I found that Squarespace had the most well-rounded user experience while satisfying my needs. I felt inspired, supported, and relaxed (for the most part) using their interface. I also felt great about the end result. When choosing the right platform for you, first assess your needs, do your research and then experiment. All platforms offer a trial period – take advantage! (FYI: Try one trial at a time lol).
BTW - My portfolio – coming soon!