Why active investment management has a place in a portfolio
Passive investingânamely, putting money in an index fundâis considered the smarter choice for most people looking to put money to work in the market.
And the data are strongly in favor of passive investing. According to Standard & Poorâs, nearly 92% of stock funds werenât able to beat the S&P 500 over the past 5 years. No less than Warren Buffet, perhaps one of the greatest stock pickers to ever live, is a strong advocate for passive investing and has said he wants the bulk of his estate invested in index funds when he passes away.
Passive investing also received a boost, thanks in part to upcoming changes in federal regulations. Starting April 2017, the Labor Department will require financial advisers handling retirement accounts to be fiduciaries. That means they will have to find funds that offer lower costs. To get in on the action, BlackRock (BLK) recently announced plans to cut fees on 15 of its largest index-tracking ETFs.
Yet investors shouldnât completely turn away from active investing, according to Brian Barnier, director at ValueBridge Advisors and founder of FedDashboard.com. He argues that some money should be placed with active investment funds.
Barnier says that active investors have been getting a bad rap because of âstyle boxes,â the investment tool made popular by Morningstar. Style boxes force securities to be placed in a matrix of cap size (small, medium, large) and growth or value (or somewhere in between).
âThe thing about style boxes is it makes an assumption that youâve got to live in the box, which is not the way you and I invest,â he said. A company may go from being a growth stock to a mature value stock. But the investment manager, in order to stay within its mandated style box, may be forced to unload a good investment and keep bad ones, Barnier added.
Barnier says investors can outperform major indices by being selective. He notes that the number of S&P 500 companies with positive year-over-year growth has been trending downward since about 2000.
âWeâve all heard the phrase, âThereâs no way you can cut your way to success,ââ said Barnier. âThatâs how we look at the business models and why business-model investing is so important as a way to get real alpha. And, oh, by the way, what is Warren Buffett doing at his Berkshire Hathaway (BRK-A, BRK-B)? Heâs a super business-model investor.â
While Barnier doesnât recommend abandoning all index-tracking funds, those investing some money with an active manager should do so with caution.
âIf youâre using somebody else, are they unconstrained by that prison of the style box so they can follow the opportunity like Warren Buffett does inside Berkshire Hathaway?â asked. âIf theyâre closet indexing, then itâs not worth your money. So youâve got to focus on the better stock picking.â
In other words, investors should ask if their active manager is thinking outside the (style) box.














