Just gotta show you that I’m the one II
In which you kiss Rafe during a game of spin the bottle, and he can’t seem to leave you alone after.
.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._
Emotional Status: Manic, in theory. Well functioning, in practice.
You were getting ready for a special occasion. Well, this may just be the special occasion because you never perceived a world in which you'd be doing this. Like, seriously. Not even in an alternate universe where Rafe didn't grow up taking kids' lunch money and stuffing them in lockers. Okay, you don't know about the second part, but you were almost certain about the first. Almost.
How Rafe had managed to wear you down so quickly with his infuriating (appealing) gifts and his shameless (smooth) tongue was beyond you. But nonetheless, here you were, staring at your closet with a scrutinizing gaze, wondering what to wear.
See, if you got all dolled up and actually tried, Rafe would see it as a good sign— that his tactics worked. And the stubborn part of you didn’t want him to feel that satisfaction because your affection, and attention, can't be bought.
Oh! To add onto the list of never-ending stressors that appeared within a week because of Mr. Cameron— you didn't know where you were going. You'd quickly agreed to going out so he'd leave you alone, but didn't get to question him about what the date would even entail. What if he was taking you to some underground BDSM club where he'd pull a Christian Grey and introduce you to his freaky side? And before you know it, you're signing some contract and entering his Red Room. Or maybe he'd just take you to the middle of nowhere and murder you. Can never be too sure with men.
Or maybe, I'll have a good time. Maybe he'll surprise me.
Knowing Rafe and his loose purse strings, he wouldn't have any issue taking you to a fancy restaurant which would require you to dress to the nines. However, there was also a possibility he'd try to woo you by putting on some show and planning a picnic or something. Packing food and blankets, and setting it up near the lake like a sweet man from the country side.
None of your assumptions would get you anywhere so you decided to ask the source.
Jeans and a t-shirt it is.
You grabbed a pair that was a little tight, but were the only ones without a tear in the place where the sun doesn’t shine. And… a simple black tee. To make it look like you’d put in just the right amount of effort, you pulled out your black leather jacket.
Was it summertime? Yes. But were you delusional enough to believe the night would get colder? Also yes.
.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._
“Wow— you… you look— not bad.” Rafe saves himself at the last second, and throws you a teasing chuckle.
You tilt your head with a sarcastic smile, “and you. I almost didn’t recognize you without shorts on.”
To be honest, he looked great. Black button up with black jeans made his eyes pop. It was his colour, but you couldn’t tell him that! You couldn’t admit that it was hard to make eye contact with him because of how nervous he was making you.
He laughs, genuinely, which had you caught off guard as happiness was a rare look on him. He was always fucking brooding. You didn’t even know he was capable of the humour and the laughter and the, honestly, tasteful gifts. How had you not caught wind of any of this before? Did he not do this for people often?
“Well, I am trying to impress you. And I thought ditching the shorts was a start.” He states bluntly while staring at you closely.
Rafe couldn’t keep his eyes off of you. You looked so effortlessly beautiful. He never thought of jeans and a t-shirt as anything appealing, but on you? Absolutely breathtaking. He took note of your hairdo too. You’d pinned a few of your front strands to the side— the strands that usually framed your face. But it was so so pretty. He could see you fully and he wished he could just pull out his phone and take a photo. Not in a creepy way! But in a I-never-want-to-forget-you-like-this way.
You chuckled awkwardly at his comment and looked down so he wouldn’t notice the blush creep up on your cheeks. “Good call.” Clearing your throat, you gather the strength to meet his gaze. “So where are we going? Can you tell me now?”
He stares off into a space and contemplates for a moment before sighing and nodding. “I was thinking—because it’s so hot these days— we could cool down with some ice-skating.” He was the one avoiding your gaze now. “They have a couples skate thing at the Polar Rink— thought it’d be fun. And- and then I thought we’d go watch the sunset by the lake near my place. Then… then we could stargaze.”
Your eyes softened and looked at him in awe. Before today, you’d never understood the expression “heart melted”, and now you were swimming in it.
Rafe noticed the lack of response and hesitantly lifted his head to look at you. Fortunately, his worries fizzled when he saw you standing there with a soft smile.
He agrees and turns around to walk off your porch as you shut the door behind you. Rafe reaches his truck in your driveway and opens the passenger seat door for you.
His change in behaviour gave you whiplash— one second he was cocky, and the next he was a gentleman. But you were only hanging out with him—or, going out with him— so you wouldn’t have to see him again. For tonight, you could put up with a little inconsistency.
After thanking him, you buckle yourself in and Rafe comes around to sit behind the steering wheel.
He starts up the car and the engine comes alive. Before pulling out, he connects his phone to the aux— which had you a little annoyed. For some reason—due to his chivalrous façade— you expected him to let you choose the music. And the mere fact that he connected his phone had you shaking your head, internally.
However, you realized you had jumped to conclusions when he played a song you knew all too well.
“You like The Strokes?” The words leave your mouth like they couldn’t wait to be said.
He chuckles and begins reversing out of the driveway. Turning his head to check the rear of the car, he responds, “no. But you do.”
A deeper blush spreads across your cheeks, and you look out the window so he wouldn’t be able to see.
The drive was short and peaceful. You loved going on drives with your friends and, now, Rafe. Usually, It was rare for you to be in the passenger’s seat as you were somehow always the designated driver. So this felt new—but, good. Like you didn’t have to be the alert and responsible one right now. You could just be. And that realization had the permanent crease between your brows vanishing.
“You okay?” He glances to you and then back on the road. “You’re too quiet— not trying to jump out of the car or anything.”
You giggled— yeah, giggled. You were in a good mood.
“I’m soaking in this rare occurrence.” You turn to him and continue, “I’m always the driver. So this is pretty sweet.”
He nods in acknowledgement and asks, “yeah? You don’t like driving?”
Shrugging, you respond, “I don’t hate it, but I guess I just prefer to be driven. It’s like—uhm— like one less thing to worry about.”
You notice the corner of his mouth curl into a smirk and you braced yourself for some cheesy line.
“We’re meant for each other then. I love being behind the wheel.” He glances at you to see your reaction and laughs when you scrunch your nose in faux disgust.
He turns back to the road and takes a left.
“Is there a specific reason you love it? Or…” you think out loud.
After a moment, Rafe answers. “I guess I like being in control. Sitting in the passenger seat makes me feel like— I don’t know— like it’s out of my hands. You know?”
You noted that he wasn’t very good with words which, at that moment— maybe because your favourite song was playing— you found quite endearing. It was probably too soon to tell, but it seemed like you two complimented each other well.
You were good at communicating and expressing your feelings. Sure, vulnerability was difficult and you often isolated yourself before speaking about what bothered you. But, in the end, your point of view was always clear and concise.
Meanwhile, Rafe was all over the place. His emotions were never clean-cut— always overlapping, and often steering him. He didn’t have the time, or patience, to pinpoint what he felt.
But you were patient, and you were kind. You would never make him feel like a burden.
Both of you knew that was the case. It was like an unspoken understanding.
“Really? I think I’m the opposite— the responsibility scares me. Like being in charge of people’s safety.” You respond and look at him even though he was staring ahead.
“But isn’t it worse to have your safety in someone else’s hands? Like what if they make a mistake?” His eyes meet yours for a few seconds and he feels his heartbeat speed up. Which was weird because you weren’t even discussing anything worth being flustered over.
“I think…” you pause for a moment and figure out how to word your opinion. “I’m more forgiving when others make mistakes. So if someone hurts me… I would forgive them easily. But if it was the other way around… I couldn’t live with myself.”
He pulls into the parking lot and stops the car in the nearest stall. Turning to you with a curious look, he asks, “Are we still talking about driving?”
He chuckles and shakes his head at your confused expression.
You nod and he quickly walks around to the passenger seat to open the door for you. Feeling like a little shit, you open the door for yourself and Rafe gasps, offended.
“What’d you do that for?”
You shrug and hop off his truck. He closes the door behind you.
“I’m perfectly capable of opening a door, Mr. Cameron.”
The two of you begin your walk off the parking lot, and towards the ice rink.
“I know that. But I still wanted to do it for yo— Mr. Cameron?” He quirks a brow at you. The pouty expression, now, a smirk.
You smile like you were up to something. Some would see that as your poor attempt at flirting— maybe you were enjoying this one-time date a little too much.
“What? You don’t like it?” You ask and nudge him a little with your elbow. This was the first time you’d touched him— well, besides when you made out with him.
“I don’t not like it.” He matches your energy, but tries to ignore the feeling in his stomach that arose when you touched him. He hadn’t felt that way since Mady Foster lended him a pencil crayon, in kindergarten.
Is that what love is? Does it make you feel like a child again?
He holds the door open for you and you walk inside the arena, immediately feeling the cold air embrace you. Compared to the thirty degree weather outside that had you sweating through your makeup, this chilly air was absolute bliss.
Since it was a couples skate night, Rafe thought that the two of you should act like a couple. He didn’t voice this brilliant idea to you beforehand, which is probably why you flinched when he placed his hand on your lower back.
However, Rafe doesn’t frighten easily so despite your shock, he doesn’t move his hand. Instead, he quickly guides you over to the rentals booth in an attempt to distract you from the whole thing.
The two of you get your rentals and walk over to the nearest bench to put on the skates. Rafe quickly tied his skates up, slipping the laces around the eyelets at speeds you'd never seen. Meanwhile, you were going back and forth from the bench and the rentals booth, never feeling satisfied with the size. Rafe just stood there, now almost a foot taller, and watched you in amusement. Finally, you settled on a pair of figure skates that did squeeze your toes but, hey, at least they looked cute.
Slowly, you looped the laces through the eyelets, but out of frustration that they weren’t tight enough, you kept starting over. Rafe sighed and walked over, unable to watch you struggle any longer.
"Do you need a hand, or is this like the door opening thing again?" He stands in front of you, making you tilt your head all the way up to look at him like he was Gulliver.
"It's like the door opening thing, but I could use your speed." You smile shyly.
He chuckles at your inability to ask for help and then kneels before you. His hands reach out and bring your foot up to his thigh to rest, so he can tie the laces properly. The whole thing had you sweating like you were outside in the sun again. You noticed the blade of your skate was digging into his upper thigh, but he didn't seem to mind at all. A little bit of pain was worth all this— pretending like you were his.
He quickly tied the laces, tight and secured, and then patted the sides of your calves to signal that you were ready. The patting made you snap out of the trance you were in, internally cursing at yourself for getting all aroused over a fairly small thing.
You clear your throat and thank him under your breath.
On your way to standing up, you gripped the bench tightly, afraid you'd fall over.
Rafe was already walking towards the ice rink when he realized you weren't following him. With furrowed brows, he turned around only to see you hunched over, using the benches for support as you moved warily.
His laugh cut through your intense focus, and had your head snapping up to see him.
"Did you forget how to walk?" His laughter begins to dwindle as he walks towards you with his arms out for you to grab.
You stand up straight on your own, but end up clinging to him in a flash— hands wrapped around his forearms.
"No. But I forgot how to skate." You say through gritted teeth.
Rafe chuckles and responds, "how can you forget how to skate? It's like riding a bike."
"Well, if forgetting is the same as never learning, then that's where I stand."
His brows jump in surprise. "You don't know how? Then why'd you let me bring you here?"
"You never told me you were bringing me here! I just found out like twenty minutes ago and by then, I thought it was too last minute to say anything!" You snapped and whisper-yelled until you were red in the face.
Expecting Rafe to snap back at you with anger, you mentally prepared yourself for an early end to the date, and a painfully silent car ride home. However, Rafe's expression was as calm as ever, which had you wondering if he really had changed. Sure, it had been years since high school, but this complete one eighty was hard to wrap your head around.
"You still could've told me. I had a bunch of back-up options up my sleeve." He spoke with the gentlest voice, in contrast to your high-pitched one.
With a huff, you reply, "I didn’t know if you were the kind of person who gets upset when their plans get derailed."
Rafe tilted his head and spoke softly again. "I can be. But not tonight— not with you."
Your eyes meet his, finally. His words sent a tingle up your spine.
"Come on." Rafe takes your left hand in his, then steps to your side, slipping his right arm around your waist. He holds you close like a harness—and in that moment, you trust him completely. "I'll hold you," he says softly. "We’ll skate together."
Every word you knew had vanished from your vocabulary, so you just nodded.
Rafe walks you off the rubbery floor and steps onto the ice first. He quickly turns to face you, taking both your hands to help you onto the rink.
Your right foot touches the ice and immediately wobbles beneath you. Your upper body tilts back, and you squeeze your eyes shut, bracing for impact—but it never comes. When you finally open your eyes, you find Rafe holding you by the waist, firmly. He’d stuck to his word.
You let out a sigh of relief. "Thanks."
He nods, and you could tell he was holding back a laugh.
Out of frustration, you whine, "I think I'll just have to stay here. The ice hates me."
Rafe stops holding in his laughter. He shakes his head, "okay, close your eyes."
"Just close your eyes." He repeats.
So you do. Shutting them tight, making sure no light peaked through.
Although you couldn't see anything, you did feel yourself being lifted off the floor. Eyes fluttering open in a instant, you realized that Rafe was picking you up and placing you on the ice with his bare hands. You yelped and wrapped your arms around his shoulders, hanging on for dear life.
He carefully brought you down and onto the ice, but your arms stayed around him. You stood there for almost a minute, that’s what it felt like anyway.
“Y/N?” Rafe’s voice was muffled by your neck.
“You can let go now.” He laughs softly.
You opened your eyes again and slowly let go of him. His palms were still on your waist keeping you from slipping over.
You brought your hands to his shoulders and felt like they were being glued down because you couldn’t bring yourself to stand on your own.
“Okay, first of all, you need to bend your knees. That’ll keep you from falling over.”
You nod and do as he says. Surprisingly, he was right and you were impressed that he immediately solved your problem. It made you feel fuzzy inside because it made you feel like he was taking care of you. There really was no way to say that without wanting to scream from embarrassment, but it felt… really good.
To put things into perspective, you were quite the independent woman. Your parents raised you to be that way and sometimes, you think, you took it a little too far. In relationships, you’re so focused on keeping yourself from depending on others even the slightest, that it almost comes off like you don’t need the other person. Maybe it’s to keep yourself from being a burden— which is how you saw it at times. You always felt that no one would want to care for you, so you do it for yourself. A similar thing occurred in your last relationship. You didn’t want to overwhelm Nathan, your ex, and so you kept him at a distance. So much so that he went ahead and slept with other people. Nothing justified cheating, but that relationship made you wonder if you really were the problem.
“Y/N? You okay?” Rafe’s voice pulls you from your thoughts.
“Alright, knees are bent. You think we can start moving now?” His tone was sweet— it didn’t make you feel rushed.
“Okay— okay. Just… don’t let go yet, okay? I’m also gonna keep clinging and- and if you get annoyed— well, you can’t because this is your fault.” You felt pathetic, but also saw the humour of the situation.
Rafe laughed again. You’d memorized that sound by now, which was funny because before all of this, you didn’t even know what he looked like with a smile.
“I have unlimited patience for you, my love.” He professes dramatically.
Unfortunately, those godawful words made you blush like crazy. And that’s not what tonight was about, so you took a deep breath and dropped your hands from his shoulders.
Rafe knew exactly what you were doing, but he couldn’t imagine a world where the two of you weren’t physically close. And desperate times called for desperate measures. So with his hands on your waist, he began skating backwards—pulling you with him—without warning.
You yelped, your hands flying to his shoulders—fingers digging in so hard he could already picture the crescent-shaped red dents on his pale skin. Which Rafe liked, because the marks were proof that tonight was real and not just a wonderful, wonderful dream.
He smirked at your frightened expression and continued dragging you down the rink.
A string of “Are you insane?” and “Oh my God!” and “Rafe, I’m going to kill you!” followed your little joyride of fear across the ice. Rafe just stared at you in amusement, finding your threats more endearing than intimidating.
When you finally reached the other end, he took pity and brought the both of you to a halt.
You let out a strangled breath and muttered, “That was… blasphemy.”
He snickered, lifting a hand to your cheek and caressing it with his thumb. Your anger melted in an instant, and you were reminded—yet again—that physical touch was your love language. Oh, it was definitely at the top of the list.
Looking into his eyes properly for the first time that night, you almost got lost in them. That, and the soft stroke of his thumb on your cheek, was making you dizzy.
“You did so well though,” he murmured, leaning in so you could hear him clearly over the love songs echoing through the arena. “Look me in the eye and tell me you didn’t like that.”
His words replayed in your mind, and you weren’t sure if you had a dirty mind, or if he just spoke in constant innuendos—but your brain immediately flashed to an image so vulgar, you were the one guilty of the blasphemous act.
“It was fine.” You grumbled.
Rafe couldn't help himself and leaned forward to press a quick peck to your forehead. It was so fast, you didn’t even have time to register it—and when you finally did, he was already hauling you back around the ice rink, ignoring the shouts of protest erupting from your mouth. He pretended to sing along to the slow jams playing, and before you knew it, the two of you were back on the rubber floor.
Rafe had decided you’d had enough ice-skating for one night. As much as he could watch you struggle forever and hold onto him for eternity, he wanted you to enjoy yourself—and right now, your hair looked like it was turning grey from fear.
"Here you are," Rafe places a plastic tray of an assortment of roller rink food in front of you.
He'd sent you off to sit down at a bench near the concession stand, since you complained about your sore feet, while he bought you two some cheap sustenance. If it were up to him, he'd take you to some private rooftop with a personal chef who would cook anything you could name, but he had a feeling if you found out how much it costs, you'd jump off the building.
You looked at the two hotdogs, poutine to share, and two cups of pop, and your stomach growled.
"Thanks," you reach for the wooden fork and stab a fry, "see? We're making memories on a budget. Has this made you see the world differently?" You pop a fry into your mouth.
Rafe lets out a short laugh and shakes his head. "No."
Rolling your eyes, you take another bite. "So, is this— me— living up to your expectations?"
He furrows his brows and takes a bite of his hotdog. "What do you mean?"
"You know... you were so excited when I agreed to this, finally. I'm just wondering if you still feel the same... or if you've realized this wasn't what you thought it would be." You stare at the tray, and take another bite, scared of what his answer could be.
Rafe puts his hotdog down and tilts his head in confusion at you. "I'm having a good time." He leans forward and uses his hand to push back the sleeve of your jacket so it wouldn't touch the poutine. "And also, tonight is about you. So the real question is: am I living up to your expectations?"
You felt yourself heat up at his thoughtful action. He did it so casually, without thinking, you kept staring at your wrist still feeling the ghost of his fingers.
Clearing your throat, you respond, "you should be proud to learn that you're exceeding them."
A genuine smile crosses his face and he almost giggles. "Yeah?"
You nod slowly and take a sip of your pink crush. "Yeah, congratulations."
"I'm surprised. I honestly thought I'd fucked up when I found out you didn't know how to skate."
"Well, it was my fault that I didn't tell you." You admit your shortcoming.
He disagreed right away and then added, "next time, don't hesitate to let me know."
You quirk a brow and playfully smirk at him, "next time, huh? You're awfully confident."
"You're the one who said I exceeded your expectations. That sounds to me like you're dying to see me again." Rafe kisses his teeth and leans back in the booth.
"I don't know..." You trail off and speak in a singsong manner.
"Oh, come on. What's it gonna take, hm? All I've done is kiss you — really well, might I add— showered you in gifts, and now, taken you on a date which, so far, you're enjoying." He grabs your fork and takes a bite of the poutine.
You looked up at him with a more serious look. "Well, I told you I didn't like gifts."
He sighs, and props his chin on his palm with his elbow resting on the table. "Why?" He asks, exhausted.
"Rafe," you shake your head and then decide to continue, "okay, look." You lean in too, ready to launch into a monologue. "It's like... okay, it's like a pool."
"Yes, like we're both in two separate pools. Swimming pools. And you keep pouring your water into my pool because— well, I don't know why. But you do it. And so I'm here in my pool and it's getting more and more full and you're happy and I'm... good too. Then, one day you look around and wonder hey, how did I end up in a kiddie pool? Like the water level is so low, you're like dry— completely dry—"
Rafe's eyes followed your every hand gesture, your lips, your words. He was absolutely enamoured in that moment.
"— and then you look over at me, and my super full pool. It has you thinking that you gave me so much and I didn't return it, so now you want it all back. But me? I've gotten comfortable with my overflowing pool, and I can't fathom a life without it. But I have to give you back your water. And now I’m in my shitty pool by myself for the rest of eternity.”
You took a deep breath when you finished your rant. It was quite a surprise, too, that Rafe didn’t interrupt you once— no he listened closely to the whole thing. Hesitantly, you look up to meet his gaze— afraid that he would be judging you harshly. But to your relief, he just picked up his hotdog again, and took a bite.
“Gets pretty busy in that head of yours, huh?”
“You have no idea.” You reach for another sip and continue, “but you get what I mean right?”
He takes a moment to think. “I guess so. But you have to realize that if the other person—me— wants to do these things for you, the pool getting shallower means nothing. And besides, in my case, the pool isn’t just some ordinary pool— it’s never not full. So take a deep breath and relax.”
You swallowed your bite and leaned back in your chair. “Maybe the pool analogy wasn’t the right one.”
Rafe snickers and speaks up after a few seconds. “So what do you like then? What makes you think oh, he’s the one?”
Your eyes narrow at his question.
“Asking for a friend, of course.” Rafe adds.
You rest your arm on the table and stare at the skate rentals behind him, trying to come up with an answer.
“Uhm…” you gaze at him again. “I don’t really know how to say this without being inarticulate.”
He shrugs, “inarticulate is my middle name. Go on.”
A soft laugh slips through your lips and you nod. “I think if they remain curious about me. No matter how well we know each other— if they still find me interesting enough to always ask for more… I- I’d l… I’d be happy.”
Rafe was taken aback by your answer. He didn’t expect it— he thought you’d say something along the lines of loyalty or honesty. But you managed to surprise him yet again. Oh, how he wanted to kiss you so badly.
He takes a sip of his drink and leans forward again. “Curious? Like… like they ask you lots of questions?”
“Yeah… yeah, but not just for the sake of asking questions. Like they want to know more. Sincerely.” You avert your gaze again. “I think I’ve just been with, or around, people who don’t really give a shit about me.” You chuckle to ease the tight feeling rising in your throat. “And I’m always the one carrying conversations and asking others about themselves so when… uhm someone does the same for me, it means a lot. And you’d be surprised at how rare it is. People can be so self-centred.”
God, for someone who says they don’t talk much about themselves, I’m sure not acting like it.
"I get that." He reflects on your words momentarily. "So who are these people who don't care about you?"
You take a deep breath and purse your lips. "Well, from off the top of my head I'd say Nathan." You clear your throat and add, "my boyfriend—sorry— ex-boyfriend."
Rafe's ears perk up. "yeah? What'd he do?" He tries to sound casual and take a bite of the poutine, but anyone could hear the emotion buried in his words.
"What men have been doing since, like, the Stone Age probably." You adjust in your seat. "Cheated."
Rafe's eyes widen. He couldn't believe anyone would want to cheat on you. You. You were beautiful inside and out. And he never said that about anyone.
To put it simply, Rafe didn't like people. So the way he acted with you was truly a rare sight.
"What a bitch." Rafe exclaims. "Does he live around here? Do I know him?"
You laugh and feel warmth creep its way into you. When things ended between you and Nathan, you took the high road. You didn't yell at him, didn't argue, didn't key his car. No, you just stopped talking to him and blocked his number. You didn't even badmouth him to your friends because, well, what was the point? It wouldn't make him un-cheat.
But this? Rafe calling him a bitch was like music to your ears. It's what Nathan deserved.
"No and no." You tilt your head. "Why though? You gonna beat him up for me?" Another poor attempt at flirting on your end.
Rafe nods, "I could if you wanted me to. Just say the word."
You blush and shyly smile at him. "I'll keep that in mind."
He pipes up again, "also, you said cheating is what men have been doing for a long time— I just wanna clear my name." He pretends to straighten his tie. "I've never done that."
Crossing your arms, you reply incredulously, "really? I don't know if I believe you."
He gasps, faking offence. "No it's true! Swear on... I don't know, but I swear." He then adds a little embarrassed, "but... because I want our epic Shakespearean romance to begin with honesty—"
"— I've never really been in a proper relationship. But my casual flings have never had any overlap."
"Wow, what a man you are."
.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._
"Sorry, where are we going again?" You turned to him as he drove through an empty intersection.
The two of you wrapped up your evening at the ice rink and moved to the second event of the night.
It was supposed to be watching the sunset, but your chit-chat at the rink ran a little long, and when you left the arena, it was dark out. Rafe was visibly bummed and you felt a little guilty for talking his ear off and wasting time. However, he read your mind and proceeded to reassure you that it wasn't your fault at all. But, of course, you didn't believe him and to cheer him up, you held his hand on the walk back to the car.
He wasn't bummed anymore. And to revel in the moment, he walked as slow as humanly possible, and even pretended to forget where he had parked. You saw right through the act, but didn't mind the feeling of your hand in his.
"The lake behind my house. Or we can just cut to the chase and go to my house?" Rafe says in a teasing manner.
"You're gonna introduce me to your parents on the first date? Are you insane?" You joke.
Rafe was stunned at how quickly you intercepted the shameless line he was setting you up for. Stunned and disappointed. He was obviously going to hint that the night should conclude in his bedroom. And then he'd turn and watch you blush for him. Maybe next time.
So he just shakes his head sheepishly, and turns up the radio.
The car came to a halt on top of some grass, and you looked around at the beautiful scenery. It was like something out of a dream. Sure, it was dark— but the moon shone on the lake water and reflected back up to you two. It casted a dim light on your face, along with Rafe's. A beautiful glow, that you wished you could see every time you closed your eyes.
You let Rafe open the door for you this time. And you even let him hold your hand on the small walk down to the water. The walk was quiet, but not in an uncomfortable way. You both listened to the sound of each other's breathing, along with the crickets in the distance.
He stopped in his tracks when you two reached his favourite spot. Right by the water, but surrounded by a few trees and the softest grass you'd ever seen.
You let go of his hand to tie your hair back.
"It's nice, right?" Rafe smiles and goes to sit down on the patch of grass. He nodded his head towards the ground, asking you to do the same.
"Very." You accept his invitation and sit down too.
After a few seconds, he speaks up again, a little nervous this time. "I uh... I haven't enjoyed anyone's company this much uh... in a while." Uncomfortable with the vulnerability, he picked up a pebble and through it in the lake.
You grin at his words. The feeling was mutual, but for some reason you didn't mention that. You were still a little skeptical of Rafe, even though tonight proved you otherwise many times. The image you had of him before this week was just so so different than what you had seen now. It would take a while to change the way you viewed him, but you were well on your way.
"I am quite the upgrade from Topper." It was a joke, to ease the growing tension between you two— sexual tension.
He snorts and leans back until he's laying flat on the ground. So you join him.
You both laid side by side and stared at the night sky. The light pollution usually got in the way of seeing the stars, but since you were on the outskirts of town, the sky was full of twinkling lights. It was breathtaking.
"I'll take the gifts back." Rafe's voice cuts through the sounds of the outdoors. "I'm— I should've listened to you. I- I know I can come off too strong sometimes." He didn't look at you as he spoke— instead, speaking out into the night. Confessing to the moon.
"It was a sweet gesture. You have great taste." You comfort him and chuckle softly. "I just—y'know? Pool water."
He nods, "yeah." Then he adds, "and also uh... if you don't wanna see me again, it's okay. No pressure."
Your brows furrow and you turn your head to the side to look at his face. You attempted to read his expression, but he was too stoic.
Flipping over so you were laying on your stomach, you prop yourself up on your elbows and face him properly.
"Where did all the confidence go, Mr. Cameron?" A playful smile rested on your lips.
He brings his arms up and rests his head on his forearms— accentuating his biceps. Your eyes quickly took them in, then returned to his face.
He was looking at you now too.
“I don’t know. I guess I used it all up during our courting stage.” He chuckles awkwardly.
You nod with a quiet ahh.
"Besides, I thought you weren't into that." Rafe says shyly, "you seemed pretty mad over text."
You purse your lips and shake your head. "I was just a little freaked out... by the attention."
He quirks a brow and asks, "my attention?"
"Yeah," you pause. "It was new and unexpected. I mean I thought the presents were initially from Caleb," you exclaim.
He pulls his bottom lip between his teeth and holds back a laugh. "I know... I was overheard your conversation that day at the Wreck."
Your eyes widen and you lightly slap his chest. "And you didn't say anything?"
He giggles at the sensation and responds, "it was entertaining! And I thought the mystery would be... I don't know? Romantic."
You kiss your teeth and scoot closer to him. "Well, it wasn't."
Rafe deflates slightly and mumbles an apology.
"But tonight— that was pretty romantic."
"Yeah?" He feels better and lifts his head to bring one of his hands to stroke your cheek.
You let him. Actually, you do more—you lean into his touch.
"Yeah... I really like our conversations. And you put thought into the whole night which I really appreciate." You lift your own hand and place it on top of his as it rests on your cheek.
You wanted him to laugh, but he just stared at you like he was picturing your whole life together. One bedroom apartment during college and then after graduation, you'd move into a house. That he buys for you, of course. A dog, too. You'd host dinner parties that would start in the living room, and end in the backyard with a wine in hand as you admired the new patio he built. You'd hug your friends goodbye and make plans for the next one. Then he'd pull you into his arms, impatiently, because he missed you all night and he couldn't resist the red lipstick you had on. You'd tell him you were tired, and he'd shush you with a million soft kisses. Rafe would walk you to the bedroom and help you undress and take you to be—
"Rafe?" You tilt your head. "You okay?"
He snaps out of his idyllic daydream and nods his head. "You look really beautiful tonight. I was just joking around earlier... but I wish I didn't."
You smile and rub soft circles on the back of his hand with your index finger. Leaning in, you whisper, "and you look really fucking hot." You giggle at his widening eyes. "I thought that the second I saw you."
Rafe didn't know what to do with himself. He knew he was blushing all over, and was relieved you couldn't tell in the darkness.
"So then I'm assuming— and feel free to correct me if I'm wrong— you do want to see me again?"
You scoff dramatically and reply, "it really pains me to admit— but, yeah. But if we go ice skating again, you will never—"
You were interrupted by Rafe's lips on yours. He'd sat up and leaned down to kiss you as you laid on your stomach. It was awkward and slightly uncomfortable, yet, perfect. He noticed your initial surprise which he thought was adorable, and then when you moved your lips, he felt like he was on fire.
Without breaking the kiss, you slowly rose until you were kneeling on the grass.
The two of you tasted each other's lips like they were made of taffy.
He brought his other hand to rest on the back of your neck as he pulled you closer, like that was even possible. Your hands cupped his cheeks like the first time you two had done this, and Rafe moaned breathlessly into the kiss, just like the first time.
You were the first to pull away which caused Rafe to groan in protest, but it died down when you pecked the tip of his nose.
"It's late," you whispered inches away from him.
"I know." His breathing was uneven, and he was having a little trouble thinking straight with the rising situation in his pants.
But he was a gentleman— or at least he could try. Because he really liked you and all he wanted was for you to feel the same. So, tonight, he'd push his selfishness and impatience away, and focus on you. A kiss was enough for the night. If you wanted more next time, he'd gladly provide it. But he'd never pressure you.
"Drive me home?" You ask and kiss his bottom lip.
He closes his eyes and whines internally when you pull away.
"Y/N?" His voice came out a little desperate. "I don't want tonight to end."
Your heart melted at his words. "It has too." You lean in and kiss his cheek. "Or else I won't be able to take you out for breakfast tomorrow."
.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._.._
So sorry for the wait, and thank you so much for reading!!
Tags <33: @pogueee @moomoo-17 @vanessa-rafesgirl @drewsphswife @scne-vampire @sturniolo1trips @lia-wyllt @x-angel-o @swhistledown @v1h-lin0 @444xkyi
Also, fun fact lol my "Make me feel" Patrick fic was initially going to be about Rafe, but then I decided to change it last minute.
I thought that was worth mentioninig, in case you guys would like to see something similar for Rafe, let me know!!