1. Joanna Newsom – Have One On Me
Because, you see, of course it is.
More?
In that case, how about we start by recognising that even though this record came out on February 23rd of last year, nearly a full year ago now, it’s still somehow managing to keep its best secrets crushingly close to what initially seemed such a disarmingly bare chest. After the mesmeric, but nevertheless at times emotionally distancing, Ys (2006), all the motherhood imagery surrounding the pre-release buzz for Have One On Me painted a first listen in hues far bolder, far starker, far more primary than we’d been used to from JoJo. Prepared thus, it was probably the most lyrically direct tracks that hit home first, participating as so many of them appeared to do in that traditional pop-song conceit of exploring universal themes through particulars just a little more gnomic of detail. For me, then, it was the opening verse of ‘Baby Birch’ that struck the first shuddered chords:
This is the song for Baby Birch,
Though I will never know you.
And at the back of what we’ve done
There is the knowledge of you.
It was beginning to feel that, not only was Joanna singing in a clearer, more conventional-sounding voice, but she was choosing to adopt a vernacular specially primed for exploring the more excruciatingly commonplace of human dilemmas: whatever they did, whatever happened to Baby Birch, whether adoption, abortion, or even the choice merely to refrain, that unknown child remained as hypothetical as the constellations, so far away in their bulletproof cars. All the more, and pitched up alongside the briefest and most unswerving of the album’s similarly-themed tracks, ‘On a Good Day’ – ‘I had begun to fill in all the lines / Right down to what we’d name her’ – Joanna seemed to be inviting us to see her not as the pedestal-dweller responsible for, say, ‘Sawdust and Diamonds’, but just another writer into whose life her art was of necessity beginning to intrude, and vice versa.
But, of course, we’re far too smart to mistake ‘direct’ for ‘honest’, aren’t we? Aren’t we? Well, maybe: but, truth or fiction, or the neverland between, tell me you can watch a performance like this and not get to some kind of compelling ‘truth’ for yourself, howsoever you might find it to be composed:
So that’s the thing, then. Yes, these songs are founded more than ever before on emotions we recognise; and, yes, it’s to those emotions that the songs return when they're through; but it’s the residue those lyrical wanderings leave on our later perceptions of those emotions that render them altered, fashion them anew. And that’s all you can ask of an art, isn’t it? How about this one: try ridding yourself a moment, at least in theory, of those items you habitually use to beautify your life – maybe all your pretty dresses, sure, but maybe also your books, your sweeter memories – and then do so after you’ve listened closely to ‘Does Not Suffice’. Oh, how empty hang the hangers, huh?
There’s too much else here for me to go into, so I’ll end instead with a stolen anecdote. Not long after Have One On Me first dropped into our lives – inscrutable as Ludwig, pretty as spent remorse – a good pal o’mine and fellow elect to the cult of Newsom had the unfathomably jealousy-inducing fortune to get to see Joanna and co. play at a little 500-standing venue in Nashville, TN. I’m sure he won’t mind me sharing the tale of his greatest glory: long story short, a moment arose such that, by shouting the immortal phrase, ‘Fuck Eugene!’, into the still of a between-track lull, he made Joanna Newsom laugh. You probably could have done with some context there, I guess, but the point remains: HE MADE JOANNA NEWSOM LAUGH.
Now, I’m not normally one for lapping at the coat-tails of pop stars, no matter how affecting their music might be (seriously, you’ll only need to read this interview with Sufjan Stevens while listening along to Age of Adz to be reminded that the real heroes are, like, firefighters or teachers or whatever. Or Batman); but there’s something about Joanna – call it otherworldliness, or maybe better potustoronnost' – that sets her apart from the rest, and makes thirty-something-in-the-front-row-of-a-Take-That-reunion-gig idolatry somehow acceptable. So here’s an ending: just a couple of hours before she broke us all with her performance at Green Man last summer, Joanna brushed past me in the crowds, momentarily, then was gone. Oh, how can we forgive ourselves our follies? It’s not like any other love, we say to ourselves: this one’s different because it’s us.





























