Will looked up from his sketchbook as a familiar figure approached, a surprised smile forming on his face to see him out of the blue. Cole hadnât called to let him know he was stopping by, but it wasnât an unwelcome visit by any means. But then something about the nervous tone the other guy spoke withâor just the words themselves, thereâs something I wanna talk to you about, which were never usually the opener to a pleasant conversationâclued him into the fact that this was maybe more serious than a friendly little hang-out, and his easy grin faltered.
    âSure, wannaâŠ?â He motioned to the bench, the space next to him, offering a seat before Cole continued on to say that he had talked to Jonathan, andâŠwhy would he feel the need to tell him that, anyway? What was this all aboâŠLonnieâs my dad, too. Oh. Oh. That wasnât the last thing Will had expected to hear: it wasnât even on the list. His gaze suddenly focused on the sling Cole wore, the loose threads he fiddled with and he replied, âHow is your arm doing?â It was almost funny that he would rather talk about the aftermath of the carnival, with its explosions and casualties, than hisâtheirâfather.
    He had to answer the massive revelation that was just dropped. Paradigm-altering information. His dad was Coleâs dad, too. But what was he supposed to sayâmy condolences? This shouldnât be quite as much of a rug-pull as all that had been happening this summer with the border and the doppelganger and the cabin and who knew what else. Was it really surprising that Lonnie Byers had had another son with someone out there (even one whose age made it clear that the man had had an affair?) Not really. But Will couldnât help the feeling that in all of this, he was the butt of some cosmic joke right now.
    It was like he was always the last to know anything, like he was always the one who walked into a room right after something cool happened, always just missing the moment. Or in cases like thisâlike nobody thought he could handle the truth; he was just too fragile, too sensitive, or at least that was how everyone viewed him. Jonathan knew? Will didnât even think he and Cole were friends. How long was âa while back,â anyway: a couple weeks or even longer? When the hell would Will become an active participant in his own life, instead of stuff justâŠhappening and him learning to deal with it. Not today, evidently.
    Rather than allowing himself to get upset, Will had to remember that this wasnât just a big deal to him, in fact it wasnât about him. It was Coleâs news to share when he felt readyâthe fact that they wereâŠthey were brothers. They were half-brothers. They were related. They have been this whole time. Well, obviously. Cole has known it, the whole timeâŠ? Will forced himself to look up and meet his eyes. âThat must have been really difficult for you,â he said. âThanks for telling me.â That wasnât what he wanted to say. He had so many questions and no way to verbalize them, because the moment he started, he just stuttered, âSo, when didâŠI mean, have you alwaysâŠDid youâŠWhat?â
Too nervous to sit down, Cole leaned against the porch rail instead, his nervous fingers moving between picking at the cast to tapping on the splintering wood Coleâs expression betrayed his bewilderment at Willâs question. Had he heard what heâd said? Had he said it aloud at all? But, autopilot kicked in and he answered with a shrug, âItâs fine, I guess. Just a fracture. Should be off in a few more weeks.âÂ
He studied Willâs face, trying to read any emotion he could detect, and also trying to find any similarities, any features they shared. Growing up, Cole had always been told he was the spitting image of his mother-- he had her dark curls and her eyes and her cheekbones. Maybe he hoped he had her temperament too-- her easygoing spirit, her openness. But lately heâs wondered what all heâd inherited from the other side: the drinking? The standoffishness? The thought itself made him want to reach for the flask in his back pocket, but he could investigate that urge later.Â
Will seemed upset, which was understandable. It was a lot to take in, and Coleâs lingering feeling of being exposed intensified. Maybe Will and Jonathan were upset at him-- maybe he was right in thinking that his very existence was a scandal. It certainly made sense, even his own grandparents had wanted to hide him away, to let his mother and aunt raise him in New York. For a brief moment, Cole entertained the question: what would his life look like now if heâd stayed in New York? Who would he be? Would it be better for everyone in Hawkins if heâd simply stayed gone?
When Will finally spoke, Coleâs shoulders relaxed in relief. Whatever it was, it was better than the silence. But he certainly hadnât expected this. Cole opened his mouth to respond, then clamped it shut again. Will was... thanking him? He couldnât make sense of that. Will was a sweet kid, heâd always known that, but this level of empathy felt like too much to ask for. âNo, donât... I mean... Iâm sorry,â he managed. He was lost, wondering how Will was being so nice about it all. Maybe it wasnât a huge deal to him, but... wouldnât it be to Cole if the roles were reversed? Heâd probably be furious, but maybe Will hadnât inherited the rage gene from Lonnie.Â
Then, when Will tried asking for more information, Cole clicked into gear. That he could do. The minefield of what each of them were thinking and feeling, not so much in his lane. âRight. I found out five years ago,â Cole admitted, with an apologetic smile. âThere was sort of... a lot going on for you guys. I didnât want to, like, make it worse.â Cole shrugged, not sure if Max had told Will that Cole knew, but not sure it even mattered at the moment. âThen, I... guess I thought it wasnât a big deal for a while. But, with everything...â he gestured vaguely, hoping to communicate that he meant the bigger picture in town.
âI wanted you to hear it from me,â he settled on. Not that Coleâs life was in any immediate danger, other than the way that everyoneâs was all the time. Still, it felt like an urgent enough need to come here today.Â